Showing posts with label Bill Shorten. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bill Shorten. Show all posts

2017/02/08

News That's Fit To Punt - 08/Feb/2017

That John Alexander?

Long time readers know of my immensely low pinion of John Alexander as tennis commentator. He was simply terrible, in as much as he offered no technical insight and often ascribe bad motives to the characters of the players, much like an armchair psychology buff. A typical line of John Alexander commentary would be that a player X missed a shot because he has a bad character. It drove me away from watching tennis on channel 7.

Anyway, it has been the big surprise of his time in politics that he backs building a high speed rail network in this country, and all for the right reasons. He is still continuing his push, and even getting called a crusader for it.
Crusading Turnbull government MP John Alexander, who has supported a debate about negative gearing, said vision and innovation needed to replace the "debilitating political argument" about housing. 
A bipartisan committee chaired by Mr Alexander backed his vision for high-speed rail, recommending the government seek proposals for a link between the two major cities, and evaluate ways to raise private capital through value capture. 
Under that model, previously trumpeted by Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, major infrastructure is privately funded by the increase in land values that accompanies the creation of new or larger cities made possible by that infrastructure.
(edit) 
"It would appear there's a perfect storm of opportunity to liberate [regional] cities through high-speed rail," Mr Alexander previously told Fairfax Media. "You will push up prices enormously around Goulburn; people will be delighted." 
But he warned on Tuesday the report's ambitious goals were only achievable if all three levels of government co-operated and were "willing to forgo individual revenues to ultimately maximise total revenues". 
Mr Turnbull and the new assistant minister to the treasurer, Michael Sukkar, have promised the government will say more about housing affordability this year, as Labor continues to push for negative gearing reform.
It's kind of crazy that the only person in government making any bloody sense is John Alexander.

About That Housing Situation...

Turns out the record private sector debt is now sitting at about a trillion dollars, and the cracks are beginning to show. Don't be fooled by the price rises in Sydney and Melbourne, there's substantial pressure on the housing bubble right now.
Homeowners, consumers and property investors around Australia are making more calls to financial helplines as three warning signs back up the spike in demand: mortgage arrears are creeping up, lenders' bad debt provisions have increased and personal insolvencies are near an all-time high.

"It's steadily out of control -- I don't know of too many financial counselling services where demand doesn't exceed supply," said Fiona Guthrie, chief executive officer of Financial Counselling Australia, who says the biggest increase in calls is from people suffering mortgage stress. "There are more people who have got mortgages that they can't afford to pay."
(edit) 
"There's so much household debt that a couple of rate hikes here would completely knock the wind out of the housing market, and a lot of people would be impacted by it," said Gareth Aird, economist at Commonwealth Bank.That's partly why he doesn't think the RBA will lift rates until 2018 at the earliest. 
While most borrowers in Sydney have plenty of equity in their homes as prices keep rising, that's not the case elsewhere. In the mining state of Western Australia, which is struggling to cope with the end of an investment boom, more than 10 per cent of mortgage holders have little or no equity buffer, according to a Roy Morgan report last week. In South Australia and Queensland, 8 per cent and 7.2 per cent of borrowers respectively are in negative equity. 
That may not matter if you're a homeowner with a secure job and comfortably servicing your mortgage. But Australia's labour market is far from solid, with the RBA citing it as one of the economy's biggest uncertainties. The jobless rate rose for the second straight month in December to 5.8 per cent, while underemployment -- the number of workers wanting more hours -- is near an all-time high. At the same time, wages growth is the lowest on record.

It's notably unaffordable, everybody's been so eager to get into it, there are signs of housing being over-bought everywhere. It's okay in the main but the fracture lines are running elsewhere. Hmmm...

The truth is that the RBA sort of glommed into this problem by keeping rates low for such a long time, and because nobody's ever had the negative signal for the market, there's a profound belief that it only goes in one direction, up. All the while they invited the other parts of the economy needed the low interest rates, but also, by under-measuring inflation they've given themselves even more reasons to keep the rates low. If the average household debt is 187% of income, you know it's not sustainable - but all the while they've not really addressed the irrational exuberance.  

Politics being what is, its practitioners like to emphasise different parts of problems instead of talking about the private sector debt for what it is, and despite the more-than-abundant evidence that there's a  property bubble in progress, the politicians have sought to characterise all this as a 'housing affordability' problem. Implicit in this shifting of focus is the idea that the problem isn't with the property bubble, it's with the people who can't afford to get in on the same RBA-funded gravy train investment. Even more pernicious in that shifty little manoeuvre is the idea that they want to keep the asset price gains, and to that end - all the politicians are property owners and investors, as well as the big wigs at the RBA - these people will do and say anything to talk down the bubble. A simple cui bono examination explains how the interest rates stay low in a bid to keep the asset prices inflated.

As somebody who dabbles in the equities market, I find the utter lack of caution for the bubble to be quite absurd. Markets by their very nature are meant to go upend down. The fact that the housing market in Australia hasn't fallen to historic norms in a very long time, can only mean there's long way to fall when the perfect storm will hit.

Housing never falls, right? We all love housing. In case you're wondering how this all shows up in our political rhetoric, have a look at this next one:

"I've Got Mine, You Can't Have Yours" Says Malcolm Turnbull

This is pretty ugly.
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has unleashed a blistering attack on Opposition Leader Bill Shorten, slamming him as a "simpering sycophant" and a "parasite" who yearns for his own harbourside mansion. 
The energetic end to Question Time came after Mr Shorten launched his own barbs at the Prime Minister, accusing him of attacking families, attacking standards of living, of being tough on pensioners and soft on banks. 
"The Prime Minister is seriously the most out-of-touch personality to ever hold this great office of Prime Minister," Mr Shorten said. 
Mr Turnbull's response, which led to the rare display of Coalition members thumping their desks, was brutal and an effort to counter attacks on his personal wealth just days after he revealed his $1.7 million donation to the Liberal Party. 
Mr Turnbull said Mr Shorten was a "would-be tribune of the people" and accused him of rising to prominence by networking with prominent Melbourne businessmen like Richard Pratt. 
"There was never a union leader in Melbourne that tucked his knees under more billionaire's tables than the Leader of the Opposition," he said. 
"He lapped it up, yes, he lapped it up." 
The Prime Minister accused Mr Shorten of "knocking back Dick Pratt's Cristal" and looking forward to living at the personal expense of taxpayers. 
"This sycophant, blowing hard in the House of Representatives, sucking hard in the living rooms of Melbourne, what a hypocrite," Mr Turnbull said.
"They call themselves the Labor Party; well Mr Speaker, manual labour is a Mexican band as far as they are concerned. Most of them have never done a day's work in their lives."
If you are an egalitarian liberal as Malcolm Turnbull claims he is, how can he begrudge his fellow citizen for wanting a Harbourside Mansion when he has one himself? I mean, what's wrong with that aspiration if it's good enough for himself? 

How can Bill Shorten be a parasite just because he has had career benefactors, when Malcolm Turnbull himself had a career benefactor in Kerry Packer? People need a break here and there. What is so morally objectionable about that reality? 

It's really weird how the conservatives have a thing about harbourside mansions. Barnaby Joyce recently said people should move out of Sydney because not everybody can afford a harbour views. If you notice, its only the coalition talking about harbourside mansions. It's not as if the ALP's in Parliament screaming everybody needs a harbourside mansion. 

You'd think these people never watched 'The Castle'. 
 

2016/07/04

Quick Shots - 04/Jul/2016

A Well-Hung Parliament - A Balls-Up By Any Other Name

Oh what strange joy it is to find out we've got a hung parliament again. And I'm not being sarcastic - I'm getting a kick out of it. It was on the cards, and in an interesting mirror image re-run of the 2010 election that took place after Julia Gillard replaced Kevin Rudd, we now have the same outcome with Malcolm Turnbull after he replaced Tony Abbott. There are some - crazy some - who are screaming out in the far right yonder that the Coalition should have stuck with Tony Abbott because he wouldn't have done any worse. That's hard to imagine. By rights, Tony Abbott was looking more like he was going to surrender a landslide so those far-right people are frantically rewriting history right there.

It is being painted as a disastrous outcome for Malcolm Turnbull, but that overstates his impact on the campaign given what he inherited, as well as how much the party tied his hands. The Malcolm Turnbull people thought they were going to get, and the one the Liberal Party allowed him to be were two completely different people. The Coalition are blaming the ALP for the medicare scare campaign but here's the problem with that theory: 1) Who exactly created the social environment where a Medicare cut would be so devastating? the Coalition; 2) how puny were the Coalition's selling points if a mere scare campaign could defeat their proposition; and 3) blaming other for your own mistakes is unbecoming of the party that tells people to pull themselves up by the bootstraps.
Just sayin'.

We all know the sordid sorry truth: Had they let Malcolm Turnbull properly address the issues that mean so much to the political middle instead of holding him captive to the right wing of the Liberal Party, they would have had a positive proposition to sell to the electorate. What's amazing is that the Liberal Party can't see it at all. They had the biggest election-winning advantage in Malcolm Turnbull's personal popularity, and they managed to squander it by not letting him do the things people expected of Malcolm Turnbull. That the party strategists seemed to think his popularity was somehow separate to the policy positions he espoused in earlier incarnations is quite staggering in its wrong-headed-ness. It is what it is, and what it is, is the height of stupidity.

The ALP medicare scare campaign? I mean, put-lease!

I Thought More Old Codgers Would Have Died Since 2013

I recently attended a funeral of an elderly woman who passed away. The attendance was scant of the elderly. When I enquired I was told most of the deceased's friends had already died or were too senile and demented to attended. It made rethink the Howard-supporting geriatric generation were finally pushing off their mortal coil, moving on into the next world. I mean, let's face it, we've lost some pretty big Baby Boomer musicians this year alone - you'd think the even older were even more dying-er. So in the three years since the 2013 election, one could surmise the ranks of the Howard's grey-power demographic would have shrunk considerably. The hung Parliament sort of shows that maybe this wasn't as big a factor as other things after all.

Of course, I'm told the percentage of the young not enrolled to vote is as high as it's ever been, so perhaps that balanced itself out. Really, we live in difficult times when we need everybody's thinking caps on. It's amazing that this is the moment at which youth apathy has reached pinnacle.

In other sad news, we find Tony Abbott is still alive and well, elected and in office as member of Warringah. Who will ind us of of this meddlesome Abbott?

The Good News

Sophie Mirabella is gone. Miserabella is done as a lower house candidate having now lost twice. With a 3.1% swing against this time and 9.5% swing against last time, she managed to freshly alienate 1/8th of an entire electorate that was once a safe seat for the Coalition. She sure won't be running again - unless of course the Liberal Party is a lot more stupid than we're led to believe.

The Ungovernable Demographics Of Australia

It's no coincidence that the hung Parliament comes so close on the heels of the previous hung Parliament. When you think about how the seats are allocated and distributed, it is pretty clear that over time, seats are becoming more entrenched, not less. The entrenched Liberal seats of the Sydney North Shore, together with Wentworth represents a particular demographic that keeps getting more entrenched, not less. It's hard to imagine any of those seats going to the ALP in the next 10 elections, Maxine McKew's amazing effort in 2007 notwithstanding. The equivalent of those seats in other Australian cities represent the bastion of Liberal Party support. Around those suburbs are the suburbs that are the traditional ALP heartland - and these might get flipped to Liberal as they become wealthier and gentrified, but on the whole the parties are entrenched according to class and income.

If the seats divide up so easily and get entrenched as a result of increasing inequality and disparity, we're going to see a lot more of these hung Parliament scenarios. There's a lot of disillusion going on out there in the deep electorate. It's no coincidence that Pauline Hanson and her One Nation brand have made a comeback, exactly at the moment of maximum uncertainty. The Two Party system funnels everybody's votes into two parties, but people are squirming like mad for another option. Add this altogether and you get a picture of a deeply divided electorate that is suspicious of anything and everything it seems. The hung Parliament isn't a simple dis-endorsement of politics or politicians or the political elite; it's a deeply structural problem manifesting itself in votes.

If the major parties can't pull themselves together they can damn well expect this to keep on happening because the entrenched rigidity of class mobility is only going to increase and reinforce what is already there. People are actively looking for an alternative that is not the major parties. It's only going to get worse for the major parties from here on in, and they themselves are to blame.
The same voter rage that drives support for Donald Trump in the US and Brexit in the UK has taken hold here. Some of it is a perfectly rational response to a political system that is not working for the people it is designed to serve. 
Australian politics broke in December 2009 when the major parties could not reach a consensus on Labor's climate change bills. 
Mr Abbott rose from the ashes of the Coalition leadership spill and so terrified Kevin Rudd that he cut and ran from "the greatest moral challenge of our time". 
That massive breach of trust with the Australian people was compounded by his midnight assassination. It, in turn, fatally wounded Julia Gillard.
The parallels between the two major parties are now eerie. 
Labor dispatches a first term prime minister in 2010 and emerges from an election into a hung parliament. The Coalition did it last year and now faces the same future.

Remember what happened next?
Yes, Tony Abbott ran at the ALP with maximum malice and no intention of governing properly. So the question is whether Bill Shorten is going to pull the same stunt. Arthur Sinodinos seems to think so.
Senator Sinodinos said Mr Shorten's election night speech was "very negative". 
"What comes out of that speech is he's saying the government has lost its mandate. [Mr Shorten] doesn't have a mandate for anything." 
When asked if he meant a re-run of the election, he said: "If Bill Shorten is saying... that he will be frustrating everything the government wants to do. He wants to cut the government down. 
"That is what he is saying. He's saying I've got them on the run, I'm going to cut them down. For what? Is he endorsed on a scare campaign. Is this what this great country has been reduced to?"
Good heavens. Really? Who did the reducing last time? 
Anyway, that's the picture we have of this increasingly unruly electorate. Yay for the unruly electorate, I say.

2016/06/19

Quick Shots - 19/Jun/2016

Are We There Yet?

I guess if I don't read a little about the election I'd be amiss in keeping breast of what the pundits think. The call seems to be a narrow Coalition win, which is like a kiss of death. Mark Kenny is also a little down on Bill Shorten and the ALP in spite of what he thinks has been good campaigning. I wouldn't know whether Bill Shorten has been all that great but e seems to be turning around the loss of smarter people to the Greens, which was a serious issue as late as 1 year go, which I covered in the last post.

Peter Hartcher thinks that Shorten has a credibility problem every time he promises policies that will involve spending billions. In a vacuum, yes, but he is running against the Coalition who are infested with climate change denialists. It's not like the Coalition have any degree of credibility at all. Compared to that, Bill Shorten sounds like a measured, controlled, proper leader. Of course, we don't know if this turns into votes in country that is persuaded mightily to treat asylum seekers in the shabbiest of manners possible.

I'm not holding my breath - but if this electorate votes this Coalition back in, I think I'll go on a bender.

The Unpredictability Of Climate Change

Some time in the last decade, NSW was in the middle of a drought so bad it saw the Warragamba dam water level down in the 30% level. It was so bad, there were water restrictions and people were killing each other in suburban streets over the use of water. It led to NSW Premier of the late 2000s, Morris Iemma green lighting a desalination plant which now looks to be a white elephant of sorts - but you can't rule anything out in the future. I say that because this week it is at 98% and with more rain falling, it may well spill over.

Both the drought and this excessive rain came about because of climate change. This is what it means to live in volatile weather conditions.

This kind of leads me to the Pleiades mailbag today.

From The Pleiades Mailbag

Here's a scary article about the runway melting of the polar caps.
Wadhams: “A whole series of consequences, which are all unfortunately rather serious. Firstly, the retreat of the sea ice or the loss of the ice will mean that global warming will increase because you are changing a large area of white to dark, reducing the average albedo [reflection] of the planet… Secondly, there will be an acceleration of sea level rise because warm air that lies over the open water in the Arctic Ocean moves over to Greenland and gives you surface melt at the Greenland ice sheet [equals 23’ of sea level rise] to an extent that didn’t used to happen. We found in 2012, for instance, the entire surface of the Greenland ice sheet was starting to melt for a period in the summer, and this is completely new, and this means that sea level rise will be accelerated because that melt water runs off into the ocean… Possibly one of the most severe threats is the that the shallow waters off the Arctic coast, especially the Siberian coast, are very wide continental shelves, only about 50 to 100 meters of water. That water could warm up during the summer months because the area is ice-free now already, and this will give you positive temperatures on the seabed which will start to thaw out the seabed permafrost which has been sitting there frozen since the last Ice Age. This has never happened before because the sea ice never retreated very much in the summer and the water temperature could not rise above zero because of the ice cover… The permafrost is acting as a cap for a very large amount of methane (CH4), which is sitting in the sediments underneath in the form of methane hydrates. You release the pressure by removing that permafrost and methane comes out as huge bubble plumes. It’s already happening; it’s been detected by scientists all over the Russian Arctic and most recently by a Swedish expedition and by various U.S./Russian expeditions. Each time they go there’s more and more bubbles coming out, and the fear is that there’ll be a general release of methane trapped under those sediments, which could cause a very rapid rise in the rate of sea level. We calculated it could give you 0.6 C warming of the planet in five years. That’s a big boost because methane is such a powerful greenhouse gas.”

As for rapidity of climate change, Dr. Wadhams says that the situation is already getting very serious, and brand new feedback processes are coming into play. Accordingly, that’s what is most worrying, extra feedbacks from what global warming itself produces. It’s like AI with a “will of its own.”
If that doesn't sound apocalyptic enough, you should check out Peter. Wadhams' lectures on Youtube:


...and here's a scary article about what Hillary Clinton would like to do as President. The funny thing is the US policy think tanks seems be making up scenarios for 2050 when in fact climate change might make the world totally uninhabitable. There might not be a world worth dominating in 2050.

2016/06/17

View From The Couch - 18/Jun/2016

This Damned Election - This week's Edition

Sometime last year I reported that a bunch of academic types wanted to vote Green and they abandoned the ALP. I decided to see if that were still the case, and it turns out that it is not still the case. A lot of them have headed back to the ALP. I asked why they switched back and they said it was because Bill Shorten was making a better case for himself with the policies he's put up, and back then the ALP were being very coy about their policies that it drove them to despair. Now, they do not despair so much - which goes to show political support is indeed ephemeral.

I'm certain that the Coalition are terrible managers of the economy. So it goes without saying that the ALP should get the nod over the Coalition. If anything the purgatory for the ALP seems to have been too short to be in such a good position so soon after the defeating 2013. After all, they did make a big hash government. What's troubling is that people like Tony Burke who were instrumental in making a hash of it, are still around and bound to become a minister should the ALP win. That into say, even if the ALP win, this is going to be tough-to-stomach in the new government. Should the Coalition win, then well, we know it's going to be three more years of this unimaginable, unmitigated disaster that is government by stupidity ("of the, for the...stupid").

If there's one thing that's becoming clearer in this election, it is that we really aren't given a greatest setoff choices - and this lack of a good choice is necessarily so because we've made so many people who are undeserving of office into politicians. These professional politicians exist because politics has been seized upon as a career to have. This careerism in turn is precluding the depth and breadth of thinking required to really build this nation. Instead, we have the kind of people who think it's pretty damn cool to cash in long held government assets through privatisation, trying to find ever more silver to sell off. To what purpose? - we're told it is to cut the deficit.
You know, at a certain point incredulity kicks in. Which is sort of where we find ourselves.

Shintaro Ishihara Writes About Kakuei Tanaka

Shintaro Ishihara is the rightwing conservative everybody thinks Shinzo Abe is. Let's clear about this: there are people in China and South Korea who carry on like Shinzo Abe is going to re-militarise Japan into the war machine it once was, and start invading the peninsula and continent. It' a crock of shit because in the years Abe has been Prime Minister this time around, he's barely increased the JSDF budget. When you consider the oldImperial Army and Navy combined took 70% of the budget, 1% seems like not much an attempt to re-militarise.

The point is, Shintaro Ishihara, was the politician who would love to go back to a strong Japan. He certainly was right up until the moment he retired. After all, he wrote the book "The Japan That Can Say No". Anyway... Shintaro Ishihara came to political prominence back in the late 70s as being anti-corruption and therefore anti-Kakuei Tanaka within the LDP of Japan. Now he has a bestseller that is a novel about Tanaka, but written in the fist person. A sort of imaginary auto-biography. The title is 'Genius'. In it, he goes into loving detail of Kakuei and his convictions.

It's a slight volume and covers the terrain we all know very well. If anything we don't learn much from it except for the fact that Ishihara seems to have turned the corner on his appreciation for, and appraisal of his old political foe. He really means it without irony when he calls Kakuei Tanaka, a  kind of political genius and visionary. Which is pretty strange.

Kakuei was a card, and did have a big-picture view of Japan. I don't know if that qualifies him as a genius - but the book certainly is interesting. As an attempt at polishing a turd goes, it showed Ishihara has quite the intellectual stamina for such a task.

In case you might have forgotten the kind of character Kakuei Tanaka was, here's my entry on how he advised his runners to deliver bribes.


2015/09/19

News That's Fit To Punt - 19/Sep/2015

ZIRP Didn't End Today

After months of threatening to lift interest rates, the US Fed decided not to raise interest rates today. Which is pretty damn amazing really because it does nothing but punch a hole in the credibility of the US Fed when it talks about how it sees its own policy. Think out it for a moment. If it were the RBA and Glenn Stevens, it would be unthinkable for him to spell putsch a move for 9 months of the year, only to squib on the threat when you were supposed to do it.

As it is, the RBA has us on a strange parallel world to ZIRP with our very own TWIRP, which is causing its own havoc. Interesting then that the constraints of the US Fed running ZIRP forcesAustralia to adopt its TWIRP and so Glenn Stevens wants to urge Janet Yellen to just get on with it.  Of course if the US Fed does raise it even 0.25%, about a trillion dollars worth of derivative contracts go up in smoke. but this is the thing about derivative contracts: they're only tangentially related to the real world economy.

Of course, the reason the US Fed didn't raise their interest rates according to Janet Yellen's statement is that they are concerned about China's economy - Something both Glenn Stevens and Michael Pascoe think are over-stated as being problematic. And yet, you have to wonder what the US Fed knows about China.

The Wild Wishcasting Phase

Those conservative chumps in the Coalition must be dreaming big, now that albatross Tony has been sent packing, and the poll bounce shows they would demolish a Bill Shorten-led ALP if there were an election held today. They haven't had numbers like since the days of Julia Gillard and even then Tony Abbott himself had terrible poll numbers. They might have to go back to 2010 just before Kevin Rudd got knifed by Julia Gillard to a time when they had a commanding lead in the polls.
Which is to say, at least for this week they've got it good.

They're probably starting to think big about how this might translate into votes, but really we need to put a big caveat on Malcolm Turnbull's alleged popularity. For a start if your predecessor is Tony Abbott, even a pile of dog dung is bound to come up smelling roses. This electorate was dying for something much better than Tony Abbott, so naturally there would be a poll bounce.

But here's the thing, if Malcolm Turnbull is really going to capture votes from the Left, he's seriously going to have to do something that even the hardest credential-ed lefty is going to admit is good, and that means having to do something the right hates, and there's simply no leeway in Malcolm Turnbull to do any such thing. And that being the case, it won't be long before the stench of old Liberal and National Party policy positions will stink like the dead fish that they are, and bring Malcolm Turnbull's popularity down to their level.

In turn, the smart advice going for Lefties is for them not to get too excited.

Not All That Dies Old Is Bad, Not All That's Young And Remaining Is Good

I haven't paid much attention to the Canning by-election brought on by the death of Don Randall. Don Randall of course tabled to motion for a spill back in February and was founded in his car not long after that. If this were a mafia movie, you'd draw your own conclusions - but it is not, they say he died of a heart attack in his car. It's hard to tell what sort of MP he was, but if he thought enough to urge his party members to dump Tony Abbott, there was probably a decent man right there.

Andrew Hastie is the man running for the coalition in his place and he's an ex-SAS man. This sort of candidacy makes my skin crawl because those guys lead a pretty narrow life with a narrow world view and they might have a world of experience in the extremes of a combat zone, they're not guys known for a deep and compassionate outlook on their fellow man.

Andrew Hastie has accused the ALP of not supporting our troops in the Afghanistan based on his personal experience. It seems like a really crass thing to say in your run up to your polls, and really shows you the sort of grubby candidate that he is. It's pretty bleak that a sensible elder dies to be replaced by some narrow-core one-eyed zealot. Our polity is doing really badly right there.

Ragging On Bill Shorten

You can count me as one of the people who got very hot under the collar about Bill Shorten's role in bringing down Kevin Rudd in 2010. I'm still not that crash hot about how that all went down as you know; but then, I wasn't exactly crazy about the whole ALP way before Kevin Rudd even became Leader back in 2007. For a better part of 24months while the Abbottoir reigned, Bill Shorten's stint as Opposition leader has looked at times like a very contrived, stage-managed wave to *his* people, a knowing wink that he was just going to sit pretty and be a small target - even though Tony Abbott made things simple.

An even then I have enough perspective and patience to say, the ALP need to let Bill Shorten do his thing, what ever it is. There isn't an easy road to government; there isn't a short cut.

In the wake of the Turnbull seizing the day, Shorten's approval rating has sunk to 24% and there are now grumbles in the electorate about his 'performance' already. This is galling because it's from the very same people who wanted Malcolm Turnbull over Tony Abbott but vote only for the ALP anyway.
Folks, you need to grow up and grow a brain.

Mind you I had a chance to chat to somebody who told me they were one of these ALP voters who wanted Malcolm Turnbull and their reasoning was that independent of sides, Abbott *had* to go for the good of Australia (which is hard to dispute) and that it was now time for the ALP to step up and put in their best leader to square off against the best the coalition has brought to the table. I enquired of them who they thought the better leader would be and they answered in a heartbeat, "Albo!"

When I expressed incredulity, they replied that Tanya Plibersek would make a better leader than Bill Shorten. I just want to point out that the ALP haven't contested a single Federal Election with Bill Shorten as leader. Do you think there might be a problem with the Australian political culture precisely because the electorate is already so bloodthirsty? These politicians are only reflecting our choppy-changey electorate.

It's not shopping for shoes or the next sugar hit at the candy store. It's political leadership we're talking here. ALP supporters would be out of their fucking minds to want to start jockeying for replacing Shorten.

2015/07/12

News That's Fit To Punt - 12/Jul/2015


Are They Petty? Or Are They Just Bog Stupid?
It turns out all that weird attacking of wind farms calling them ugly, was covering fire to cut investment into wind power in this country.
Treasurer Joe Hockey and Finance Minister Mathias Cormann​ have issued the so-called green bank with a directive to change its investment mandate, prohibiting new wind funding. It's understood the directive was issued without the approval or knowledge of Environment Minister Greg Hunt, angering the minister.  
The decision is another blow for the multibillion-dollar wind industry, which has just started to recover from the uncertainty created by the government's Renewable Energy Target review. Analysts say $8.7 billion is expected to be invested in wind power in the next five years, while the corporation has invested about $300 million in wind projects to date.

And international investors are warning the government's move sends a bad message about how safe it is to do business in Australia.
The directive is just the latest salvo in the government's attacks on the wind industry.
Good grief. So much for "Open for Business". We know they're fighting a rearguard action against the eventual move from fossil fuel to renewables that must inevitably take place so it's not that difficult to see that the top level of this government is deliberately mismanaging an issue to suit their crony-capitalist friends. But then there seems to be a belief in this government that Tony Abbott's own unpopularity gives him carte-blanche to just do what his cronies want because he's never going to be popular for ever doing the right things. If the electorate is not going to reward you for doing the right things, then it seems they're willing to damn the electorate and do their corporate masters' bidding and secure themselves a lucrative after-political-life. 

Which is to say, under Tony Abbott, Australia's polity has become no better than Indonesia. At this point in time, we're Indonesia-without-the executions. This place only looks respectable to people because it's white middle-aged men in suits running these crappy policies up the flagpole. You'd think this was the 1950s - which is exactly what Tony Abbott wants. Tony Abbott only needs look to his own faith to see how far off base he is on the issue, in this day and age when the Pope issues encyclicals about protecting the environment and curbing carbon emissions, slamming corporate greed as the Devil's own Droppings. You sort of wonder how he can sustain his opposition to things like Renewable Energy and kinder treatment of asylum seekers on the basis of his religion and not listen to his Pope. Evidently, it has nothing to do with his faith, it's all to to do with uncompromising cultural prejudices.

Using Federal Money To Tar The Opposition

This lousy circus that is the Royal Commission into union corruption keeps rolling like an unwanted circus caravan, waiting to find its miserable end. Earlier in the piece it was Julia Gillard who fronted the commission to explain her time at Slater and Gordon working as an IR lawyer, wherein she might have been a little irregular with some paperwork. Now it is Bill Shorten in the dock, being asked whether he short-changed his union members to cut a deal with the business sector. It's kind of weird that the Abbott government is asking these questions, seemingly-suddenly-amazingly interested in the welfare of the rank and file union members. We'll put that bizarre irony aside for a moment and ask the simple rhetorical question, what does this look like?


It looks like one of those show trials seen in military juntas and theocratic councils when they put the opposition on trial for being the Opposition. The Kim Dynasty did this a lot (now they just shoot them). Malaysia keeps doing it to Anwar. The Gang of Four in Communist China did this sort of thing to purge the enemies of Maoism and ended up in their own show trial. It goes on in Iran to this day and heck, even South Korea does this to presidents who leave office at the end of term. What all those countries have in common is that they don't have democratically functioning states. Even the ones that purport to be democratic and have elections can't be said to be functioning properly if they're doing show trials of the opposition. 

However, "a loyal opposition" is a difficult concept for a lot of countries that simply don't understand the adversarial system of law that developed in the English speaking world. Its underpinnings are culturally alien to them and so they concoct these kinds of show trials. It's a dead giveaway that they don't get democracy. 

Imagine my grievance and dismay then to see the Opposition Leader of this land, sitting in the dock over this stupid political show trial in Australia; Australia, the once most progressive nation in the English speaking world, reduced to the spectacle of a political show trial. You'd think we were Indonesia-without-the-executions; but no, we're even worse than that because they've stopped doing these for now in a sign that they've begun to get democracy. Clearly, our own political leadership has lost the plot. The exasperation in that photo says it all. 

What Yanis Varoufakis Has To Say About The Debt Deal For Greece

Pleiades sent in this nugget. Yanis Varoufakis has a piece in the Guardian. 
In 2010, the Greek state became insolvent. Two options consistent with continuing membership of the eurozone presented themselves: the sensible one, that any decent banker would recommend – restructuring the debt and reforming the economy; and the toxic option – extending new loans to a bankrupt entity while pretending that it remains solvent. 
Official Europe chose the second option, putting the bailing out of French and German banks exposed to Greek public debt above Greece’s socioeconomic viability. A debt restructure would have implied losses for the bankers on their Greek debt holdings.Keen to avoid confessing to parliaments that taxpayers would have to pay again for the banks by means of unsustainable new loans, EU officials presented the Greek state’s insolvency as a problem of illiquidity, and justified the “bailout” as a case of “solidarity” with the Greeks. 
To frame the cynical transfer of irretrievable private losses on to the shoulders of taxpayers as an exercise in “tough love”, record austerity was imposed on Greece, whose national income, in turn – from which new and old debts had to be repaid – diminished by more than a quarter. It takes the mathematical expertise of a smart eight-year-old to know that this process could not end well. 
Once the sordid operation was complete, Europe had automatically acquired another reason for refusing to discuss debt restructuring: it would now hit the pockets of European citizens! And so increasing doses of austerity were administered while the debt grew larger, forcing creditors to extend more loans in exchange for even more austerity.
And that's about as succinct as it can be put. In the 9 years since the GFC broke, I've had to think a fair bit about what the bail outs and Quantitative Easing meant. The best explanationI can give you is that it is an attempt to freeze the clock so that the participants in the world's greatest casinos have time to take their chips of the table and walk away without cashing in the losses, while the bill is sent to Joe Q Public. In the aftermath governments ran out of money do their normal government-y things, and so they committed to 'austerity' which further shrunk the economy and made things worse. Iceland, which refused to give the bankers a pass, has recovered nicely, which tells you something about all this glorious QE I II and 4Eva we've seen. 

David Cameron of course did have one standup moment where he declared he would not balance the books of the United Kingdom on the backs of the poor and needy. It's a great line, whether he actually followed through on it or not. It perfectly describes what Germany is doing- balancing its own books on the backs of the poor and needy in Greece. Whether 'Grexit' happens or not, the world's sympathies are with the Greeks on this fact alone. If Grexit should happen, the Greeks at least would have a fighting chance. As for Deutsche Bank that has trillions in derivatives tied to Greek bonds, I don't think we'll give them much sympathy when it all blows up, and Angela Merkel has to clean up that mess. 

2015/06/16

Answer The Questions II - The Return of Serve

Part 3 - You Did It Too? Oh You Suck Too!

Turns out the ALP Government paid the people smugglers too!

After telling his caucus that Labor had made mistakes in this fraught area of policy and learnt "difficult lessons", he was unable to articulate what these mistakes were and how they would be rectified in the policy Labor will take to next year's election. 
As Julie Bishop sees it, this failure is a product of tensions within the Labor party on what direction that policy will take, with the sections of the party determined to oppose aspects of the Coalition's extremely punitive, but successful, approach to stopping the boats – including turn-backs. 
Labor's shadow immigration spokesman, Richard Marles, is promising a better balance between border protection and humane treatment of those who ended up in Australia and in offshore detention centres, as well as a more concerted effort to build a regional approach. The detail may become clearer at next month's Labor national conference.
Is this the end of the payments-to-smugglers issue? Hardly. Both sides of politics are guilty of using taxpayer funds to disrupt people smuggling ventures and both refuse to comment on the activities of Australian intelligence operatives abroad for obvious reasons. 
But only Labor has asserted that it has never paid people smugglers to turn around boats at sea (or put asylum seekers in new boats and pay the crew to take them back to Indonesia).
Just fantastic. So much for beating upon the government after that comes to light. Bill Shorten was doing the "won't deny that they did or did not get paid, but not to turn back boats" routine. 

Was there a difference between the Coalition paying people smugglers on the water and Labor paying out on the land, he was asked? 
"I'm not using the land-sea distinction. I am saying Labor has never paid people smugglers to turn back boats as it appears the Government has done," he said. 
And, as Mr Shorten's face took on that green patina suggesting seasickness, there was this: "We don't know who paid what to where. When it comes to national security, there is bipartisan on that." 
By which he meant no one talked about operational matters; and certainly not what ASIS might have done with great wads of secret cash when Labor was in power. 
Which, he almost certainly saw by then, left him a pretext short of justification for demanding to know what the Coalition's secret operatives had been up to on the ocean. 
And so the subject was allowed to sink without trace, as often happens when politicians find themselves at sea clutching at nothing more than a pot or a kettle.
Well that was most unedifying. 

Part 4 - "Show Me The Money? I'll Show You The Money!"



Oh what joy. 

2015/06/15

Answer The Questions

Part 1 - "We Did What?"

This week's odd burbling news is that our government officials paid people smugglers to take asylum seekers back to Indonesia. It is in many ways unsurprising that such a thing should happen when our government decides that 'Stop the Boats' is some kind of high-minded policy platform instead of an electioneering slogan that it was to begin with. Indonesia are investigating the claims, an their foreign minister has called in the freshly returned Australian ambassador for a "please explain" chat. naturally, the Prime Minister is dodging answering the questions. To not too fine a point on it, it is reported that he is not denying it.

I mean, really? Is that what you've got Tony Abbott?

So what we are now to make of this government is that it doesn't want transparency or scrutiny, it doesn't want to be answerable to the people, it doesn't want to explain its thinking or its methodology, and it sure as hell doesn't want to criticised for the on-arrival of asylum seekers on boats and the manner which it delvers such results.

In short, you have a government that is holding all of us in contempt as it takes us down some very dangerous directions with regards to our human rights record. Honestly, it's a joke that this was good governance promised by this bunch of buffoons.

Part 2 - "You Wouldn't Have Cared Then, And You Don't Really Care Now"

Meanwhile the insidious trawl through the mud of unions has fished upside awkward facts about the stewardship of the AWU by Bill Shorten, back in the day when he was its president, continues. The strange thing about the ALP is that its total symbiosis with the union movement means that it's always going to throw up veterans of union politics as their political candidates - unless you're Kevin Rudd and we all saw what happened to him. The increasing awareness we have of this symbiosis is actually what is driving down the ALP primary vote as the genuinely leftists move to the Greens while educated social democrats are stranded outside of the ALP power structure, unable to help it change - but these are all gripes for another day.

The whole inquiry into union corruption is a cover for the coalition to be using the power of the state to impugn their opponents like some tinpot dictatorship in Africa, but given the depth to which this government is willing to sink, it should come as no surprise then that this kangaroo court wants to interview the leader of the Opposition. Then again, it is the same government that wants to indulge in stripping people of their citizenship,so we shouldn't be surprised that they want to behave in a manner that can only be described as rampant authoritarianism.

We've had patriarchal governments before but this is the first government in my memory that tries to behave like a teenage bully rather than a scolding father, in order to get its way.

2015/01/29

News That's Fit To Punt - 29/Jan/2015

Everybody Has Advice For The PM

If you screw things up as knottily as Tony Abbott has done in his short tenure as Prime Minister, it becomes something of a sport to offer up advice. The best one for laughs I have seen to date is from Rupert Murdoch tweeting that Abbott should sacrificially sack Peta Credlin as his chief of staff. In other words, in a partnership of a brain and the mouthpiece, the mouthpiece should sack the brain. I guess if Abbott just took calls directly from Rupert all the time, it would save having to talk through Credlin, presumably.

Oddly enough Bill Shorten defended Peta Credlin. Then again, I would too if the opponent is about to sack its worst tactical liability.

Andrew Bolt thought the 'Knightmare' was so bad, it was possibly fatal for Abbott's prime ministership. Of course, on a long enough timeline, all prime Minsters fail and leave office in one way or another, so something will remove Tony Abbott eventually. Perhaps ridicule is more powerful than the sycophantic support of rightwing nut job radio broadcasters. If so, hooray for ridicule!

Tony Abbott's standing is so low, he's been asked not to go up to Queensland for the state election,  by the incumbent LNP Premier himself; I might add it is a premier who is in danger of losing his own seat, and he still doesn't want any 'help' from the Federal branch of his own party. It's so bad NSW ALP strategists think Tony Abbott alone is worth 3-4 seats coming off Mike Baird's Liberal Party majority. The Liberal Party strategists think it's more like 6 seats.

And so, the latest scuttlebutt is that yes-maybe-probably the Liberals are considering alternatives and this is rounding on the usual suspects of Julie Bishop and Malcolm Turnbull. It's so transparent that bookies are taking bets. The problem with all this is of course the Right wing (of a largely right wing party, which is like saying the "glans of the dickhead") won't tolerate Malcolm Turnbull and well, Julie Bishop is - Margaret Thatcher's fine fascist career notwithstanding - a woman, and such a stunt as to installing a woman as a Liberal Party Prime Minister and one not by election at that, is just too Gillard-ian for their own tastes. Let's face it, Malcolm Turnbull probably still hasn't developed any judgment and is liable to run the party into the ground in his own way, the way he did with Ute-gate; and Julie Bishop's best attributes are still the death-stare-denial-of-reality and the moral nihilism that allowed her to defend James Hardie and Big Tobacco together with the strategically acquired Claire Underwood hairdo.

Be that as it may, the cat is surely out of the bag and working the phones, canvasing for votes. Do I bet on equities, bonds, derivatives, horses or do I bet on who will replace Tony Abbott? It's a tough choice. Here's my advice to the PM: If I were Tony Abbott, I would march in to the party room before any spill and announce a Double Dissolution and go to the polls.


2014/10/03

(Yep,) It's War

As We Go To War Again...

What sucks more? That we're going to send troops back to Iraq again, or that we think it's going to be a long engagement? I'm sick of war, frankly. It's just been this horrible on-going aggravation for well over a decade, we just barely got out of the last fracas - knowing we'd be leaving behind a snake pit in Iraq, and hey presto, that's where we're going back to fight the next one which is a continuation of the last one.

One of the more pernicious things about this Forever War - and yes, it's turning in to exactly that - is that we're not even certain as to why we're fighting it and what we hope to achieve through fighting it. And war is like a corrupting influence on our society that erodes away our freedoms while claiming to protect them; erodes away our compassion when we most need to exercise it; erodes away hope in exchange for an imagined security; and erodes away aesthetics in favour of crude jingoistic symbolisms. And it seeps all over the place like some wretched ill-contained sticky oily fluid. It infects us, it coats us, it taints us.

I'm sick of the khaki and olive green and the grey marl and the bogus epaulettes on clothing. I'm sick of the movies that have good guys sporting military credentials and ranks and insignias. I'm sick of this statist claptrap that masquerades itself as 'security'. The rhetoric of war, the praise of the war dead, the erecting and commemorating of battles and things, are all killing us bit by bit. I'm not some peacenik either. I believe in the proper application of force where necessary but in this instance, I'm failing to see it. ISIL/ISOR are halfway across the planet and are yet to affect Australian interests. Yes, they've called for acts of terror on our soil but seriously, would that necessitate the expenditure we are about to make?

Even allowing for the possibility of it being a 'just war', there's the issue of us having spent the last decade fighting a war that was hardly just or called-for in Iraq. If this war is just now, it's only so because we screwed up Iraq so badly. This is going to be punishing exactly because it is punishment for our previous misdeeds.

Wartime Prime Minister? The Gods Laugh At Thee Abbott

If you asked any voter back in September 2013 as to whether anybody thought the last federal election was going to be about war, I doubt anybody sensible would have said 'yes'. I know Tony Abbott and his government have banged on about a mandate since that election, but I don't really recall the election being such a resounding win for Tony Abbott and the Coalition they could claim a mandate on anything, let alone going to war.

The turn of events that has led to this moment in history is deplorable, and by that I'm not talking about beheadings in the Levant, I'm talking about our idiotic polity. It's not just Tony Abbott or the Coalition, it's the ALP also and the previous governments of all Howard, Rudd, Gillard to boot. While we've been busy navel gazing, we've lost the ability to make mature nuanced decisions. Instead we've allowed ourselves to be led by stupid, simplistic slogans shouted by an eminently stupid sloganeer, and now we're about to send troops all over again to one of the shittiest places on the rump of the Earth.

Doubtless Tony Abbott thinks he's making history but I can assure you that he is more making-it-up-as-he-goes-along. What is going on is a travesty. That's right. Our government has gone from tragedy to comedy to farce, all the way down to unintelligible nonsense. Somewhere along the way, we have allowed people with the worst judgment to lead us into figurative political minefields, and there's no easy crawling out. This is a terrible war to be fighting and by the time when all is said and done, I'm pretty sure Tony Abbott's name will be mud in the history books. If he thinks this war is going to make him as a Prime Minister, I think he's going to be very surprised.

The Glorification Game

Pleiades sent in this article. It's about how militarisation has been creeping into our social fabric for some time. There is this paragraph that I think bears repeating:
Perhaps the most concerning feature of the spreading militarisation is the deliberate targeting of children. Schools across the nation are bombarded with free, professionally developed curriculum material including films, books, CDs and posters. Subsidies are provided for trips to the Australian War Memorial in Canberra. Essay competitions award winners with fully funded tours of European and Middle Eastern battlefields. There seems to be no reticence among the promoters of war as the defining national experience. They openly canvass the importance of reaching out to children from the earliest years of primary school and seem never to consider that their crusade is closer to propaganda than to pedagogy. And the sanctimony that pervades all treatment of the “fallen” stands in the way of healthy scepticism or dissident interpretations.
It makes you wonder about what we have in Canberra. There are two cultural museums in Canberra - the War Memorial and the Australia Museum. The latter is like the product of political correctness gone wrong. It celebrates things like the Hills Hoist and refrigeration, together with commemorating unknown indigenous people. It's boring and tedious, forced and guilt-trip-enforcing. It's like the creation of leftist academia with an axe to grind about Australia's incontrovertible colonial (and colonial-ist) past. Trust me, I'm a regular pinko, and I found it boring as hell and borderline idiotic.

The War Memorial stands in stark contrast where everything in it is the glorification of war. The entire Australian self-image is constructed around the great conflicts in which Australia was a participant. It's macho, geeky, nerdy, un-apolgetically colonialist, backward-looking, and dripping with repressed homoeroticism. It is in short, just as disturbing as the Australia Museum, except it seems to have become the favourite toy of the sort of conservative you laugh at for wanting to talk about the war all the time. It's a place that shows you how disturbing human affairs are, when you look at it just through the prism of war.

Together they compete to paint a picture of our national identity, coming out of different corners of ideology, talking at cross-purposes and largely astigmatic about the way they come across. Combined, it gives us a fractured view of our polity. One side loves to hate on the white mainstream. The white mainstream just likes war for its own sake because that's the only thing that is given any historic meaning. It explains at once the ineptness of the ALP opposition at stopping us sliding into this war as well as the eagerness and ease with which the Coalition has shoved us back into a war.

On this issue of going to war with ISIL/ISOR, Bill Shorten and Tanya Plibersek have been utterly useless, with terrible judgment.

2014/05/15

Block Supply, Bill Shorten!

No, Really, We Mean It!

This is a pretty shitty budget brought down by the Coalition. No matter what the Coalition is claiming and  will continue to claim over the next little while, there's no way this budget was what the Australian electorate voted for in September. Abbott clearly lied or changed his mind. In either case this budget has no legitimacy. Lots of people are unhappy with this thing.

The only thing that can be done to stop it dead in its tracks is to block supply - and then Governor General Peter Cosgrove can sack Abbott as Prime Minister.

Come on Bill Shorten, show some balls.

2013/11/26

Where Were These People On Election Day?!

ALP's Early Comeback

Polls are an awful thing really, because they measure results of what people allegedly think when given thoughts they wouldn't ordinarily have by themselves on choices they didn't formulate. If somebody told you the options for managing emissions was a 'carbon tax', an Emissions Trading Scheme', 'Direct Action' and nothing at all, you would be led to thinking this was the be-all and end all of all solutions and answer something out of this bunch of bad choices. Not to mention the inherent hostility of the polled person who can then bag out the incumbent for their incumbency and berate the Opposition for their opposition and so on and so forth.

In that light, I can only shrug at the newest poll showing the ALP have surged ahead of the Coalition.



The graphic says it all - less than 3months since the fateful election, the current Government finds itself in a position it would lose the two-party preferred vote. It didn't take long, and it didn't take much for the dissatisfaction to set in. If these people had exercise a bit of forethought, they might have  avoided the Abbott government altogether. Doesn't it make you sick?

The truly interesting thing might be this bit here:
But in a blow to the Prime Minister's plans, more people like the supposedly ''toxic'' carbon tax than his proposed replacement policy.


An Age-Nielsen poll shows little support for Tony Abbott's proposed carbon tax replacement policy.


Just 12 per cent of voters believe Mr Abbott's ''direct action'' policy of using taxpayer funds to purchase emissions reductions from polluters, and planting trees, is the answer. That amounts to a virtual vote of no-confidence in direct action, which has support 4 percentage points lower than the 16 per cent in favour of keeping a fixed carbon price.

The Age-Nielsen poll of 1400 voters found that Australians overwhelmingly wanted to see Australia meet the nation's commitment to cut emissions by 5 per cent by 2020 based on year 2000 levels.

While both sides of politics have committed to the minimum target, the poll shows voters prefer the policy Labor took to the last election - a switch to an internationally linked emissions trading scheme.

Fully 29 per cent nominated an ETS as the preferred mechanism to combat global warming - well ahead of ''some other policy'' on 24 per cent and 11 per cent who favoured ''no policy at all''.

In other words, the only reason people want the Carbon Tax removed is so they can go to an ETS. That's right, the only tangible reason people want the Carbon Tax gone is because they want the ETS So much for that mandate Tony Abbott's been going on about. Listening to his coded dog-whistling you would have thought Australia's electorate wants to go the way of the Ostrich in any discussion on trying to mitigate Climate Change.

The Drum on ABC 24 featured some Liberal Party apparatchik last Friday who wanted to tell us that the future lie in adapting to climate change, and not mitigating it. If I were a man in possession of inclinations like Elvis Presley I would have shot my TV set. instead I screamed and turned it off. It's like some bad joke from the Easter Bloc of old that Tony Abbott got elected.

Delaying The Carbon Repeal

In another one of those election promises that is being broken by the Coalition, we have the Carbon Tax repeal. They've got it through the Lower House but there's enough resistance in the Senate to shoot down the repeal. The Coalition solution is  therefore to hold off taking it to the Senate until the new Senate sits in July.
The Abbott government has scheduled two weeks of sittings, two for the Senate and one for the House of Representatives.

Usually Parliament stops for the winter break at the end of June, returning for the spring session in mid-August.

In the last 15 years federal Parliament has only sat once during July - for a single week in 2011 - which lends weight to the theory that the Abbott government has deliberately arranged this voting period for the carbon tax repeal.

Leader of the House Christopher Pyne released a schedule of sitting dates on Monday, showing the Senate sitting for a fortnight from Monday, July 7.

Mr Pyne said more sittings provided an opportunity for debate and consideration of the important bills that will come before the Parliament in 2014.

The lower house will sit for a week from Monday, July 14.

It seems the Coalition has twigged to possibility they would lose a Double Dissolution election - which is to say they had no mandate at all like they have claimed. The fact that the new poll has blunted their resolve points to the inherently opportunistic, populist and largely spineless nature of this government. Have they no shame? It appears not. Have they no dignity? No. Clearly, that's why they need the Monarchy to drape them with some (imagined) dignity.

Christopher Pyne has been rather disruptive in other ways.
Mr Pyne told Sky News on Sunday evening that two of the states that had agreed to the Gonski reforms, Victoria and Tasmania, had never signed "final agreements" with the federal Labor government, and neither had the National Catholic Education Commission.

"That isn't a national model, and it's very difficult for us to implement the complicated, confused, very dense model that they came up with because of Labor's predilection for prescription and regulation," he said."We want less regulation, less prescription from Canberra, and that's what I'll set about trying to put in place when we can do that."

Opposition Leader Bill Shorten accused the Coalition of breaking the promise it made before the election that it was on a "unity ticket" with Labor on school funding.

"The weasel words of the government saying before an election they will look after schools and properly fund our children in the future, and ... they now dial forward and say all deals are off, there were no deals."

Well, Bill, the answer is that these people really will do and say anything to get into power, hold power and abuse power. No surprises whatsoever there.

2013/10/19

Generation Change

The ALP's Gen-X Crew

The Herald was making the point today that the ALP have gone Gen-X with their choice of frontbench. When you think about it, Bill Shorten is 46 going on 47 so that puts him at the older range of Gen-X, and Tanya Plibersek at 44, it's true that the ALP have indeed gone Gen-X. I have a late Boomer friend who tells me that all this demographic stuff is just a construct not worthy of analysis, except I've been writing here under the banner of 'Gen-X View Of The Universe' for a good 5 years now. It obviously means something.

What could it mean?

The Generation X politician in Australia would have arrived at Tertiary education after the AUS was disintegrated by the likes of Peter Costello and Tony Abbott in 1983, Interestingly enough, Julia Gillard was the last President of the AUS when it collapsed in 1983. If you anted a model to the fractious politics of the Julia Gillard Prime Mininster-ship, you would have found it in the demise of the Australian Union of Students, with the same cast of late Baby Boomers thrashing and trashing institutions to make their political mark. What's scary is that they're still around aplenty in the Liberal and National party ranks, and they probably still don't think much of indulging in that sort of ratbag behaviour. This explains the histrionic opposition style Tony Abbott chose to work with - because it is the method he used in his youth to destroy the AUS , headed up by Julia Gillard. Worse still, it worked again, so that may be why he's so convinced he has some kind of mandate.

The demise of the AUS and the years where there was no student lobby until the NUS got up in the late 1980s allowed HECS to be brought in. Unlike the Baby Boomers, most of the Gen-X politician would have had to pay HECS. When they say education and the opportunities it affords are important, they know what they are saying. All these things are intimately entwined.

If there is one thing that I do think is encouraging about the Gen X ALP politicos is that they are of the generation that had to put back together the NUS and have the experience of rebuilding institutions. If the ALP under Rudd-Gillard looked positively fractured, then I think the current group might be able to start from scratch and build a proper agenda that suits the time. As I wrote the other day, I'm feeling fairly optimistic about the Shorten-Plibersek team, much more so than I felt about the Rudd-Gillard team when they first rose to the level of Opposition leader and deputy back in 2006. They're not perfect human beings and they will make their mistakes. I just don't think they're as fractious and crazy as the generation of politicians who were forged in the dying days of the AUS.

Right now, the Coalition are the party of the Baby Boomers much more than Gen-X or Gen-Y by dint of the ageing population and makeup of the Liberal and National Party demographic. The fissure hasn't been more stark than any other time since Mark Latham as late Baby Boomer was taking on John Howard who was born before the Boomers. That fissure sort of leaves the current ALP firmly in the Gen-X camp with the hope of picking up a big portion of support from Gen-Y.  The question then is whether Gen-X+Gen-Y interest is a big enough voting constituency to overcome the Baby Boomers' interests in their twilight years.

Demographically speaking, Gen-X is small and shorter than either the Boomers before or the Gen-Y that follows. That being the case the duo may never make it. And if they did, they may be seen off by a Gen-Y politician. Consider the American experience. Bill Clinton was the first Boomer President, who was followed by George W. Bush who was followed by Barack Obama, all of whom are Boomers. All three Presidents won two terms, so the Baby Boomer reign will last 24years. If a Gen-X candidate won 2 terms after Obama, the next election after that will likely see a pair of Gen-Y candidates. It's entirely possible there will never be a Gen X President of the United States.

Similarly, I don't see any Gen-Xers knocking on the door in the Coalition ranks. If Abbott is replaced for some reason, it's possible the leadership reverts to Malcolm Turnbull or goes to Joe Hockey - both of whom are Boomers. The longer the Coalition stay in power, the less chance there will be of a government of Gen-Xers in Australia.

So when you look at it through the demographic filter, that's what we have with Bill Shorten and Tanya Plibersek: The one and only shot at Gen-X forming Government in Australia.

2013/10/16

News That's Fit To Punt - 15/Oct/2013

Tony Says He's Got A Man Date

It's a bit gay isn't it Tony?

Alrighty, so Tony Abbott is saying that he has a mandate to repeal the Carbon Tax. He's been banging on with this since winning the election and as far as we can tell, he's put the topic at pole position of his agenda in Parliament. I guess if you say you're going to do it and win an election it might look like you have a mandate but most people polled seem to think this is a terrible idea; and that the reason they voted for Abbott was because they reviled the Rudd-Gillard-Rudd ALP so much but hadn't really given much thought on the ramification of ousting the ALP government.

So much for the wisdom of crowds. Our electorate is stupid.

You can basically see that not too deeply down, Tony Abbott is still a Climate Change Denialist who has hijacked the agenda so he's in a hurry to sort this out in favour of his denialist position as quickly as he can. This then turns into the absurd spectacle of Tony Abbott trying to apply pressure on to the new Opposition Leader Bill Shorten like so:
Prime Minister Tony Abbott says he believes Bill Shorten will be forced to back the Coalition's plan to repeal the carbon tax, saying Labor's new leader is “nothing if not a political pragmatist”.

Mr Abbott dismissed the new Labor leader's repeated statements in support of pricing carbon, saying his government was “giving the Labor Party a chance to repent” on the issue.

It's interesting how he uses that word "repent", as if introducing the Carbon Pricing mechanism was somehow a sin. You imagine that in Tony Abbott's mind, any market driven mechanism to push down carbon emissions is somehow 'evil' (like 'adultery' or 'murder' - the mind boggles). Is it the tax part that bothers him? Or is it simply that he just disagrees with the mountain of scientific data?

Whatever little faith you had in his Direct Action policy to replace the Carbon Emission Trading Scheme evaporates like so much morning dew in the rising heat when you consider that word "repent".

I Voted For Him But He's A Terrible Pundit

Mark 'Arm-Breaker' Latham said that the ALP faithful shouldn't vote for Anthony Abanese because 'Albo' had terrible political instincts and was basically too wishy washy for Mark Latham's Liking. Whilst ranting on against union power and factional deals within the ALP, Latham said he was voting "ABA. Anybody-But Albo". Which is to say he voted for Bill Shorten but didn't really want to endorse Bill Shorten in any positive manner, no.

I guess Bill Shorten is a tough character to take given the Rudd Gillard years and the role he played in both PM swaps. As 'faceless men' go, he's been the very public face of the faceless men, and so, on some level probably deserves to be given the shot in the same spirit that led to John "I don't take bribes But I don't report Them' Robertson leading the ALP in NSW. I guess we could be heading for a travesty with Bill Shorten as Opposition Leader but I doubt Albo was a better choice.

While I am no member of the ALP - so this is completely an outsider's view - I think Albo was and still is a potential liability. One shouldn't cast aspersions but one has to ask how close Albo is to Eddie Obeid and whether he will get linked to those wonderful ICAC hearings slated to deal with the morbid Obeidity in NSW. Oh, and that Ron Medich guy who put out a hit on that McGurk guy. In that sense 'Deputy Prime Minister Albo' might have been the high point of Anthony Albanese.

Shorten has his failings. People have been writing about those in spades. In amongst reading all the bad press, one thing I did like about Bill Shorten was that after he switched back to supporting Rudd, he came out fighting. He wasn't fighting for his reputation, but for deeply core ALP values. You know, the stuff we always ascribe to Gough and Bob and Paul. On that level he appears to be a politician who speaks on behalf of a greater portion of Australia than Julia Gillard, while possibly not having the insane charisma of Kevin Rudd. You'd have to say the guy has a fighting chance; especially against a willful, dogmatic, Tory ideologue like Tony Abbott.

The other net benefit of the Shorten leadership over an Albo leadership is that you get Tanya Plibersek as Deputy Opposition Leader.I'll be honest with you, I think Tanya Plibersek has been great through the election campaign and into this post-election period. Any time I've seen her on Q&A, she's been setting the record straight and has countered the attempts by the Coalition to paint the Rudd-Gillard government as somehow a failed government. She's been logical, persuasive and very circumspect.

If you had to come up with a credible one-two punch, it's hard to do better than this duo, given the ALP's current state. Anna Burke might feel bitter and twisted about the shadow cabinet selection, but the Shorten-Plibersek team up gives you a lot of hope that the ALP can get their mojo back. When I think back to how negatively I felt about the original Rudd-Gillard team up back in 2006, I think this is a lot more promising. And I never thought I'd be saying that so early after an election loss. They haven't even gone back to Parliament yet.

Housing Bubbles Are Harder To Observe Than The Higgs Boson

Look, if a Nobel Prize winning economist says you're in a housing bubble, you probably are in a housing bubble.
Robert Shiller, the joint winner of the Nobel prize for economics, is worried about bubbles. The Yale University professor expressed alarm at the rapid rise in global house prices soon after the award was announced.

"There are so many countries that are looking bubbly," he said.

If he's right, and bubble trouble besets Australia, it's bad news for growth and jobs.

The Reserve Bank has cut interest rates to record lows to encourage businesses and consumers to spend and invest as the effects of the mining boom fade. The aim is to boost non-mining sectors like home building, retail and tourism so they can take over from mining as drivers of national economic growth.

But low interest rates have also stoked demand for established houses. Sydney has led the way – the city's median dwelling price (comprising houses and units) rose by a frothy 13.1 per cent in the year to September.

If house price growth becomes unsustainable the Reserve might decide to take some heat out of the property market by lifting interest rates. It would be unlikely to tolerate the longer-term risk of a devastating house price collapse.

But under that scenario, interest rates would be set at a higher level than required by the broader economy. The cost of containing house prices could be subdued growth and fewer jobs.

The really odd thing about all this is that the RBA has been insisting we don't have a Housing Bubble in face of the same evidence being presented to the Nobel Laureate Economist. I mean, we take the existence of the Higgs Boson on about the same level of scrutiny - and they gave Dr. Higgs his Nobel earlier in the month - so I'm sitting here wondering what exactly the RBA thinks is going on that makes it not a bubble; but here it goes...:
But AMP capital chief economist Shane Oliver believes many of them don't fully understand Australian property markets.

"The basic problem here is a lack of supply caused by chronic under-building," he said. "There is a shortage of housing in Australia and that partly explains why it is so unaffordable."

Given the blend of very low interest rates, a stable economy and pent up demand, it is no surprise property markets are showing signs of life. While Sydney property prices have grown strongly in the past year, this follows nearly a decade of weak growth. Data published by the Housing Industry Association this month shows the average annual growth in Sydney house prices over the past 10 years has been just 3.4 per cent – a rate that has hardly kept up with wages.

At this stage, the Reserve Bank isn't convinced by talk of housing bubbles in Australia. Last month the bank's assistant governor, Malcolm Edey, said those predictions were "unrealistically alarmist".

Dr Edey cautioned against reaching for "the bubble terminology" whenever house price increases were higher than average, because by definition that's half the time.

AMP Capital's Shane Oliver offers an explanation why Australian real estate is so expensive and unaffordable, but it's really not an answer as to why or how this is not a Housing Bubble. The RBA says if you take the average growth of property in Australia, it's only 3.4% p.a. which sits behind wage growth over that time, so it can't really be considered a bubble. I'm more interested in how that 'average' was derived, because the mathematician inside me smells a rat.

I guess we'll just have to wait and see how things play out.

Blog Archive