Showing posts with label interest rates. Show all posts
Showing posts with label interest rates. Show all posts

2022/03/14

Quick Shots - 14/Mar/2022

Dissatisfaction At The RBA

You read the news long enough, you do get educated into weird things. One of the things I've been taught over the years is that the RBA is independent of politics - that it operates apart from executive and legislature branches of government in order to be impartial. To that end it has a charter and it works to control inflation and work towards full employment. And now the RBA is getting reviewed because something really wonky has happened to our economy as result of the RBA doing its thing. 

The bank’s charter, which includes a commitment to full employment, is unchanged since it was formally established in 1959. Its inflation target of 2-3 per cent, which it failed to meet in the 7 years leading up to the COVID-19 recession, was established in the early 1990s.

Apart from failing to meet its inflation target, the RBA now holds $356 billion in state and federal government debt as part of its quantitative easing program and has official interest rates at 0.1 per cent while households are carrying record levels of property debt.

KPMG senior economist Sarah Hunter said given how many unconventional monetary policy tools were used to deal with the coronavirus recession, the time was right for a review.

One of the things I might offer up is how the RBA uses the Consumer Price Index instead of the Cost of Living index to make its decisions on interest rates. The thing is, it is well known that for 3 decades now CPI has under-reported the inflation figured compared to Cost of Living. This has led to an overall easing bias over the 30 years, and amazingly (or not) this has led to the current state of affairs where interest rates sit at 0.1% and there is record private sector debt locked up in housing. I mean who'd a thunk it, right?

If the RBA had not decided to calculate CPI differently to how it did it back in the early 1990s, maybe CPI would not have under-reported inflation and consequently interest rates would not have been as low as they are today. Are low interest rates a problem on of themselves? No, but the accumulated byproducts of this low inflation regime is startling. There is the record private sector debt in mortgages; there's the housing crisis in general that is so problematic, governments cannot devise policies of sufficient aces to combat them; then there is the general problem of people not being able to save enough for retirement. A whole generation of people's retirements have been compromised by the regime of low interest rates that have followed the Global Financial Crisis, which in turn has forced their money into riskier assets late in life. Equities are at a historic high in spite of negative sentiment in such areas as the pandemic, accelerating Global Warming and associated natural disasters and generally low growth across the developed world that dates back three decades as well.  

As well meaning as RBA Governor Philip Lowe is, we've seen a radical accumulation of paper wealth for the rich. Arguably, had the RBA followed the Cost of Living numbers over the CPI for the last 30 years, there might not have been the insane frenzy for real estate that suddenly seems to define the economy. So if nothing else, there's ample evidence the RBA needs to be reviewed. I'm certainly for doing it.  

The 4th Dose Is Coming

I got my booster shot back in early January. I actually managed to get my Moderna shot a day before proper eligibility - the chemist wasn't really going to argue the toss at a time when they wanted everybody to be getting the booster anyway. I figured on the law of averages we would likely be doing yet another booster around May to June, given that even when properly motivated my shots seemed to take place 4-5 months apart at a time. During those months the politics would gyrate and new variants would come and go but the net effect was this thing where we needed to get another shot. 

Now the chatter is that a fourth dose is inevitable. 

“The protection that you are getting from the third, it is good enough – actually quite good for hospitalisations and deaths. It’s not that good against infections, but doesn’t last very long.

“But we are just submitting those data [on fourth doses] to the [Food and Drug Administration] and then we will see what the experts also will say outside Pfizer.”

Dr Bourla said Pfizer needed to be well-coordinated with US regulators the Food and Drug Administration, Centres for Disease Control and Prevention, and the wider industry, so “that we are all providing to the American people and to the world a cohesive picture rather than confusion” on whether four doses were necessary.

I am guessing that the Deltacron hybrid discovered in the UK and France recently is going to pose a problem. Basically, the mRNA vaccine Pfizer and Moderna have been making is based on the spike protein of the original. Omicron spikes are sufficiently different so render the vaccines much less effective. The Deltacron seems to have the spike of the Omicron but the pathogenic capability of Delta which means it's the worst of both worlds.  It was bad enough when Moderna's boss said current vaccines would not terribly useful against Omicron back in December. If we don't get vaccine against the Omicron spike, we're kind of sitting ducks all over again. Amazingly, just as when Omicron started to break, the government is carrying on like living with all variants of COVID is like living with the Flu. 

I'm also guessing that in roughly 2 months time we will find this current approach of relying mostly on the vaccine was way too loose. So I peg that we'll be doing our 4th boosters around May.

A Weird Take on Putin's Russia

So Big had this link wherein it is argued that Putin has won. It's a take based on the assumption that Putin is a psychopath and is acting accordingly (plausible) and therefore the outcomes he would be aiming for would be psychopathic outcomes. As such he is likely to get whatever it is because in all our sanity, we cannot fathom the depth of Putin's psychopathic goals. 

It's an interesting take except a lot of psychopaths that do terrible things in public at least tend to end up imprisoned and incarcerated. Serial killers tend to hide their tracks and do their dirty deeds in secret but the public psychopaths tend to meet the pointy end of law and order. If Hitler's psychopathic outcome of his dreams was the destruction of European Jewry, then he sure did accomplish that outcome but he also ended up in the bunker shooting himself (if officials versions of events are to be believed). The same applies to any number of Nazis, Fascist dictators and unhinged royals of many a family in history.

It is true Putin is sitting on a good supply of wood, oil, grains, fertiliser and aluminium. It is true cutting off those supplies would hurt the world economy. Yet it is also true none of those commodities are exclusive to Russia, so it remains to be seen if these sanctions really will hurt us more than it hurts Putin's Russia. I'm inclined to think that in the 21st century commodities market, it's impossible to corner anything to be able to wrest control of the markets. I still think Putin is holding a bunch of losing cards right now. 

PSA - New Album Coming

Just a quick note to let you know my new album 'Cosmic Orphans' is due out through digital only release on 17 March 2022. 

Pink Floyd pulled all their tracks from Russia on Spotify because of this Russia Ukraine thing. I thought I might do the same but I realise none of you listeners are from Russia so it would be redundant. 

Anyway, this one is my 'pandemic lockdown rock-down'. All of the songs were written and produced during this pandemic. Most of it was in fact recorded and mixed in the second half of 2020 and first half of 2021 - but lining stuff up for a release can be a bitch. I think just about everybody sent home to work from home worked on their album so the logjam must be intense. Some people wanna fill the world with digital audio information. And what's wrong with that? 

Anyways, do be good, stay tuned. Go to Spotify and keep an eye out for it this week. 




2022/01/08

Up And Down With The Numbers

Curious, No?

The markets go up and then they go down. Over a long period of time, they tend to go up a certain percentage - and so if you're wise to it, you should just go put your money in indexed ETFs. Warren Buffett even claimed that his wife's ETFs did better than Berkshire Hathaway during the 2010s after the GFC. It may well be true, I don't quite have the means to verify the Berkshire Hathaway end of it. 

Still a quick look at the last 5 years of the S&P 500 tells an interesting story:


So at the end of 2018, it hit a little divot of sorts and was at 2416.62. from there, it climbed to 3380.16 on 14 Feb 2020 when the pandemic hit. It tumbled through march but recovered quickly, responding to the incredibly loose monetary conditions and has been climbing steadily ever since. The most recent peak was on New yers eve at 4766.16. Roughly double from the divot I mentioned. All in a span of 36 months. If you bought ETFs for S&P500 in December 2018, you'd be larfin' hard right now. How extraordinary is this? It took from Feb 1998 to Sep 2014 for the index to go from 1000 to 2000. Doubling your money in 36months is like, I dunno, Sydney real estate?

It makes you realise that what we're looking at is quite extraordinary, and probably tied closely to the extremely low interest rates and Quantitative Easing program run out of the US Fed - the Bernanke Put, so to speak - which was carried on by Janet Yellen and Jerome Powell most dutifully. All that money that was supposed to prop up the economy essentially propped up and rocket-launched the equities market instead. It went on for most of last decade.  

So people have been wondering about the inflation rate over in the USA because since about April 2021, we've seen it go up to 4.2%and then stay above 5%, and now creeping up to 6.8%. The original explanation was that it was the supply chain problems caused by the pandemic. However, more recently the explanation has turned into this being a serious bit of inflation thanks to the Fed printing money. For that to be true, I want to know where all this inflation was between Jan 2007 and March 2021 because if there was one thing the US Fed could not get up, it was the inflation rate. 14 years of the Bernanke Put and no inflation. Then the Pandemic came along and screwed trade and flow of goods, so now you've got inflation. 

Do we honestly think this bit of inflation is because the Fed is printing too much money and wage claims are rising? Come on - I haven't seen wages rising in the 5-10% range at all. At worst, some states raised the US minimum wage in 2021. The way the commentary is going, you would think that the lowly paid got double their money, but really, it's equity holders who got to double their money. The minimum pay raise looks like this. Sad. Clearly nobody doubled their money and a lot of places didn't budge from their paltry $7.25 an hour. You can rule out wage claims as the reason for the CPI rising in the USA. 

And yet the narrative is out there. The Fed's printed too much money so that's why there's this inflation. They ant the US Fed to cut back the QE thing and raise interest rates. It reads like equity traders and investors wanting to have a crash so they can buy back in. They're coming up with any old story to put pressure on the US Federal Reserve Bank to raise rates. They may come to rue what they wished for, because all those beautiful gains in the S&P500 just might come tumbling down when the rates start going up. Just remember, blaming the QE for the inflation that causes the rate spike is a lie.  


2017/03/13

News That's Fit To Punt - 13/Mar/2017

Mining Bust Out West

Jeez, that election in Western Australia looked like a real rout. It's funny how the state votes in the conservatives during the years of the boom and somehow trusts them to do the right thing with it, and then when the boom turns into a bust they discover the conservatives have squandered it. It seems to be like a collective insanity that takes hold of the state. During the mining boom years, the rest of Australia had to listen to utter idiocy coming out of the WA Government thanks to the fact the recent mining boom turned  WA into a net contributor to the GST regime rather than a net recipient. Then they cried poor about it , and got very little sympathy - as they should - and now that the state finances are in ruin, the people finally vote in the ALP. When you consider that at one point the WA LNP were mouthing off about seceding from the rest of Australia, it's certainly laughable that they will be a net recipient to the GST regime once more.

I guess one shouldn't laugh at the misfortune of others, but this one was pretty predictable.
Mining booms often turn to busts. Most Australians know this, except it seems, the outgoing administration of the nation's resource-rich west. 
Western Australia's now former premier Colin Barnett bungled the bonanza, splurging windfall cash during the good times only to find the cupboard bare in the bad ones. The upshot is the state's budget deficit and debt have spiralled, the AAA rating is gone and people are fleeing, the latter at least has the advantage of containing an unemployment rate that's already the nation's highest. 
"There's an element of Dutch disease there, and the government certainly mismanaged the boom, but it also reflects the sheer size of the mining sector in WA so when it collapses it drags everything down," said Shane Oliver, head of investment strategy at AMP Capital Investors in Sydney. 
"WA didn't seem to learn any of the lessons from Australia's past mistakes during commodity cycles and now the state is effectively in recession." 


(edit)
Western Australia's Treasury was projecting the revenue windfall from mining would still be continuing in 2018-19, despite commodity prices peaking in the third quarter of 2011 and mining investment not too long after. 
As a result, the government has been trying to cut outlays in a weakening economy and there's even been talk of tax increases as gross debt is on course to surpass 20 per cent of gross state product in coming years.
It's pretty laughable when you have a long memory. So much for the notion that WA somehow had organised things differently to all the other mining boom and bust cycles in the past. Tire's a lesson in there for the fossil fuels industries too.
There's a lot more to be said bout all this, so I'll come back to this below.

100 Days Of Tesla

We live in times such that a tech billionaire tweets something and it turns into a head-to-head discussion with the Premier of SA and PM of Australia. It's weird but all of a sudden people want this project to happen - which would be nice of South Australia but also, - which would be the proper part of the renewables tech business getting a crack at the Australian electrical grid.

Tesla's Elon Musk may have put large scale battery storage on the national agenda with his offer last week to solve South Australia's power crisis for free if he did not deliver a large system with 100 days of signing a contract, but both the Prime Minister and South Australia's Premier are looking for more detail before taking him up on the offer. 
Mr Turnbull and Mr Musk spoke for an hour early Sunday afternoon, with the Prime Minister yet to form a view on the merits of power storage systems in solving South Australia's power supply woes. 
"They had an in-depth discussion on the value of storage and the future of the electricity system," a spokesman for the Prime Minister's Office said. 
Their discussion was not political in tone, but rather a discussion between two people "picking each other's brains" over the options for energy storage in Australia, one source familiar with the discussion said.
Elon Musk for his part has resumed campaigning for a shot on Twitter. You'd look an idiot if you turned him down now, wouldn't you? Of course these are people in government in Australia are people who don't mind looking like an idiot, so you have to subtract your optimism. Or is that curb your enthusiasm. In any case, the offer is there. Now begins the process of looking the gift horse in the mouth.

Time To Start Collecting Canned Food?

This link is from Pleiades.
While economists love trade, it has extremely political ramifications. And it is politics that in Every’s view is driving the world back to a 19th century style trade world. A world where after a period of free trade, high tariffs were set up and where trade became a conflict involving domination of one country over another.

And the problem is that economic conflict can quickly become real conflict.

It was a scary prospect – not only would raising trade barriers reduce our standard of living – but if the path of the next 10 years follows the path of the late 1800s and early 1900s then the world gets very dangerous very quickly.

The biggest difficulty for those selling the idea of free trade is that a soon as you start talking about things such as “comparative advantage” people quickly switch off. It’s much easier to understand trade in what is known as a mercantilist sense – the “domination” point of view, where the aim is to export more than you import.

That is certainly the view of Donald Trump and his trade advisor, Peter Navarro, who has recently argued that because GDP is made up of consumption, government spending, investment and net exports (exports minus imports) reducing the US trade deficit is a good way to grow the US economy.

The problem with that view is that in the US – as in Australia – the size of net exports pales in comparison to consumption, investment and government spending.
Clearly, if the benefits of trade are not doled out to the public but instead, accrues to a small percentage, as has happened in the last 30years, the public becomes less enamoured of free trade; and so we must wonder if we've hit that point where the public has decided it won't back free trade any more. It would explain the shift toward  parochial kind of anti-tradepolitics as seen in the Brexit debate/debacle as well as the rise of Trump-ism (devoid of any coherent ideological framework, it does seem to to be a cry against free trade).

A Scary Passage From Crikey

Also from Pleiades was Crikey's entry about the WA election, which I think deserves a long quote.
They have to do something. They should have done something before. When the red dust settles and the tallying’s done, the verdict on the mining boom in WA will be a harsh one. No Norwegian-style social fund was established — Norway now has a trillion dollars under management from North Sea oil and gas, and the whole country could retire — and much of the money that did come in served principally to inflate prices to, well, Norwegian levels. FIFO was imposed on people who wanted settled jobs, and no government stepped in to oblige the companies to give their workers more options. Men and women of modest skills and earning capacities were suddenly pulling in huge wages, with little advice as to how to invest it. Many bought houses in regional FIFO towns at prices approaching capital city levels — and then saw them halve in value as the boom died away. Meanwhile, the towns that became FIFO bases — from Singleton in NSW’s Hunter Valley to Kalgoorlie to Bunbury — were drained of the communal stability that makes life possible. “How can you organise a footy team? How can you even get a picnic going,” a woman had said to me in Singleton, two years ago, “when you never know who’s going to be here? The shops are empty, the town’s bled dry.” Two days ago, someone said the same thing, near word for word, in Kalgoorlie. In both towns, and many others, the miner’s mansions have “for sale” signs in front of them, directed at a market that isn’t there. 
Some didn’t even make it to the bad-investment stage. A lot of people were drawn to FIFO by the idea that it would allow them to make big bank, on the simple principle that once you’re in camp, there’s nothing to spend your money on. But that scheme misses the effect of 14-day, 21-day, 28-day stints of 12-hour shifts on the human psyche. Beyond a certain point of such punishing, inhuman labour, it is all but impossible for most people not to blow their money in the first days off, especially if they’re young. Everyone who’s done night shifts, continuous shifts, back-to-backs knows this. The money spends itself, burns its way out of your pocket. Potlatch, the old tribal custom of wanton destruction, takes over. You stride into a bar and fuck it, you’re not going to drink beer, or Red Label, you’re going to drink Chivas! A double! Chivas for everyone! For some people who just came to do a couple of years in the mines and party up, that’s probably no great tragedy. Others have worked years at grinding, dirty, dangerous work and have nothing to show, a fact that must be part-cause of the suicides, depression, domestic violence and addiction that has broken through FIFO communities like a long wave. 
Given a free kick by 4 billion years of geology, and a chance to reinvest, Western Australia appears to have created a situation in which Wake in Fright and The Unknown Industrial Prisoner serve not as dystopian warnings, but as HR manuals. Now a state that has spent a decade chipping bits of itself off and floating it northward for silly-money prices cannot pay for its most basic services, pay down its debt, and is proposing taxes that should have been being levied since the 1990s and scrambling to fill the gap with infrastructure projects it can’t afford to start. Services cut include those to Aboriginal people, which in turn has produced unwilling population movements, pressure on centralised and reduced services, and a resultant and distinct fraying of white-black community relations in a range of towns, a fall away from such detente and mutual understanding as has been achieved in recent years. What looks like a racial political issue, is, in reality, a product of the state’s fiscal crisis, and its panicked efforts to plug the gap.
That's pretty bleak reading. It turned out they needed a mining tax but realised it after they campaigned hard to get rid of it. Oops. What do you do with this kind of collective hubris and stupidity? It doesn't end well:
The gap has been plugged, instead, with meth, a drug that has boomed out of control in WA, simply because it has become so cheap, easily made from base chemicals, in suburban labs springing up in every city and town. Those looking to explain its reach in WA by its occult power to turn people into speedfreak zombies are ironbarking up the wrong tree — meth hit the big time when it became cheaper than dope. Its popularity is a product not of addled obliviousness, but of the judicious application of rational choice theory by substance abusers, looking to maximise their investment. It’d make the Institute of Public Affairs proud.

All that, in overlapping bits and pieces is the conversations you get into across the state — with everyone. Miners, ex-miners, civic boosters, NGO officers, emergency services, journos, snappers. In WA, everyone’s become an amateur political sociologist, hot on the trail of where it all went wrong, and what the solution might be.
Whatever happens on Saturday, the state’s dilemma concentrates the mind wonderfully. Kalgoorlie stands as a metonym for Western Australia; Western Australia for Australia itself. We are all aware that we have not stored away for the lean years, and the fat years come to an end. The prospect, delicious for pundits, less for the public, is that either major party will fall short of a majority, and have to cobble together government in both houses of Parliament. Looked at clear-eyed, this often delivers good government, but the public rarely thinks so, and the golden west exemplifies the decay of political legitimacy and effectiveness in Australia, and if that occurs here, it may not be too long before the state is back at the polls once more. 
What WA needs is the Unflux, the many nations in one — a party with a realistic and integrated program to deal with the reality of resources-led states, not the fantasies they offer. As goes the state, so goes the nation.
Everybody's got 20-20 hindsight it appears. Right now, it's hard not to think of all those mortgages underwater in Western Australia and what that's doing to the banks' bottom line.  It all went crazy out there with the low interest rates and the seemingly low inflation as 'measured'y the RBA. If the reality was in fact significant inflation, then clearly Western Australia was not served well at all by the RBA's policies in the last decade. You can start to see the whole thing start to unravel. You have to wonder just how long will it be before it hits the East Coast?

2016/09/01

Economic Growth, They Say

They're Doing It Wrong

Nick Xenophon made an interesting remark last week that the RBA should shift its focus from inflation and on to nominal GDP growth. This is one of those interesting shifts worth considering because which ever way you look at it, inflation isn't the problem it used to be when Keating cut the RBA independent of government, so that it could independently set rates with the ai of controlling inflation. We're at a far cry from the era when Paul Volcker tamed inflation in America through jacking up interest rates. That world seems quaint, for we haven't been in that environment sense before the Dotcom Bubble burst at the turn of the Millennium.

Anyway, here's something interesting by Greg Jericho, going into the rationale for why Nick Xenophon might push for that change:
With the current policy, the worry is always that were inflation to rise due to fiscal policies, then the RBA would raise interest rates.

Thus we had the absurd situation last year where then Treasurer Joe Hockey was claiming the RBA had “room” to cut interest rates because the Abbott government’s spending cuts meant it “had been able to control the inflation genie”.
He said this at a point when underlying inflation hadn’t been above 3% for five years and nominal GDP was growing by just 1.3%.

Targeting nominal GDP resets the conversation.

Rather than having the government cutting spending (which reduces growth) in order to allow the RBA to cut interest rates to stimulate growth, both the fiscal and monetary arms could focus on improving growth – and it would put more pressure on the government rather than the current situation where it is leaving most of the work up to the RBA. 
Given government revenue has been hit due to the decline in nominal GDP growth, making that a focus would also assist with improving the budget balance.
Yes, it would make too much sense but of course the system isn't built for quick handbrake turns of policy like that, no, no.

It's worth going back to Glenn Stevens' last speech as Governor of the Reserve Bank.
Reserve Bank governor Glenn Stevens has used his farewell speech to implore the Turnbull government to take on more debt, saying that rate cuts alone can no longer "dial up the growth we need". 
Although interest rate cuts still had some effect, they worked through encouraging private borrowers to borrow more and had "possibly less" effect than in the past.

"The problem now is that there is a limit to how much we can expect to achieve by relying on already indebted entities taking on more debt," he said.
The government had far more room to borrow and spend than the private sector – owing only 40 per cent of GDP instead of 125 per cent.

"Let me be clear that I am not advocating an increase in deficit financing of day-to-day government spending," he said. "The case for governments being prepared to borrow for the right investment assets – long-lived assets that yield an economic return – does not extend to borrowing to pay pensions, welfare and routine government expenses, other than under the most exceptional circumstances. 
"The point I am trying to inject here is simply that popular debate in Australia about government debt and how we limit or reduce it seems so often to be conducted while largely ignoring the size of private debt. Foreign visitors to the Bank over the years have tended to raise questions about household debt much more frequently than they have raised questions about government debt."
So it's one thing for Nick Xenophon to say we need the RBA to prioritise growth rather than whacking signs of inflation. Given the toolset available to the Reserve Bank, which is basically raising or lowering the interest rates, there's really not much more the RBA can do to help growth.

That is to say, the limits of RBA policy - any Central Bank policy - resides at the zero-bound where Zero-Interest-Rate Policy lives. Glen Stevens may well retort to Nick Xenophon, "what the hell do you think we've been doing for the last 8years since the GFC, with historically low interest rates?"

Indeed, that's exactly where the Bank of Japan is at, trying to get economic growth to happen. It's trying massive "trans-dimensional" quantitative easing and yet there are minimal signs that the Japanese economy is coming out of its long slump. The conservative Prime Minster of Japan is telling the heads of the major corporations to raise wages instead of sitting on hoarded profits. It's a wild frontier of Central Banking experiments over in Japan, and really, I'm sure they wouldn't care which came good first, growth figures or inflation figures.

I'm going to go out on climb and say something that would scare fiscal conservatives and hawkish bankers. What Australia needs is a kind of debt forgiveness. So if the economy ends up at the Zero-bound with ZIRP, the RBA needs to forgive the private sector debt and helicopter that printed money into banks. People are going to hate that because basically they'll scream "moral hazard",   except when the economy has flatlined at the zero-bound, then the whole show needs a complete re-boot; and if there's one thing that keeps any economy from re-booting, it's debt.

Ben Bernanke's 'Helicopter Money', Applied

The logic for doing Helicopter money in Australia is pretty simple. People are not spending money because they're busy paying down mortgages as fast as they can. This isn't doing much good because it means the money goes from the bank to employer to employee and back to the bank without going through the economy. So you alleviate the mortgage stress, and the people will be inclined to spend their money. The government hands the printed money to the banks, buying out the debt on paper. Immediately there should be inflation because people now have money to go spend it on the next asset, That's when the Central Bank can re-set the interest rates at a more historic normal level.

Of course, it won't go that way because the bankers would lose out on long term money, but that would be the point. Somebody has to take a loss and the bank would have to get its money while losing out on future profit based on the booked loans. It hasn't happened because ultimately the economy is owned by the 1% and the 1% stands to make nothing out of "helicopter money". But the alternative is the current, comatose, low-growth low-inflation state in which we find ourselves.

The problem with QE as it's been carried out to date, and lots of it, they're finding in Japan, is that the money simply doesn't go to where it's supposed to go. The BOJ stuff the banks full of money, but the banks don't lend to sell businesses and entrepreneur. The lending practices still tend to lead the banks towards lending for fixed assets like property - and even then there's just not as much of that going around. The big companies of Japan's old industrial growth era are still profitable but they don't pay out dividends, and they don't give out pay-rises. They tend to sit on the big piles of cash and say they see nothing in which they want to invest.

The only way to make sure the money gets out an about in the economy is to hand it to the consumer and have them spend. In other words, it's like Capillarity Up economics. They cam very close to pulling the trigger on 'Helicopter money' this year in Japan, but at the last minute they held back. I guess there is something fundamentally weird for government stop simply be giving people money. Be that as it may, the Japanese may eventually have to do it; and if the precedent is set, other countries will do it. It's not like it's a new idea.

The Wisdom Of Solon And All That

It doesn't get discussed a whole lot unless you read a bit of ancient history. Solon, famously forgave debts. He also forbade the export foods except olives. He encouraged the cultivation of olives specifically as en export commodity. Meanwhile he forbade the export of foods because if staples got sent away, the poor would starve and that had terrible consequences for society. If you asked Solon, he'd object to 'Helicopter Money' as a policy but his big thing was debt forgiveness.

The ancient world is full of instances of debt forgiveness. The people in power in the ancient world probably looked at debt as something that becomes intractable and kills the economy. The Romans famously refuse to forgive debt and of course the aftermath of the Roman civilisation were the Dark Ages. So it is worth pondering what the hell we're going to do with a financial system that has created so much debt the world's GDP cannot begin to repay it. It's not likest's a problem that's going to go away. The more it sits there, it's going to chew away at the future, just as it is doing right now, only worse.

That's the historic context of all this bickering about debt. Something tells me the debt won't be forgiven, there won't be Helicopter Money, it's all going to crack up and turn to shit right before our very eyes. So much for civilisation.




2016/05/04

May The Fourth Be With You 2016 Edition

Fighting Deflation In Japan

Here's something from Zero Hedge.
Interestingly, the BoJ’s attempts to achieve its price inflation target continue to end in failure with unwavering regularity. While the central bank’s astonishing ineptness in this respect is a blessing for Japan’s citizens (at least for the moment, their cost of living doesn’t increase further), it harbors the danger that even crazier monetary experiments will eventually be tried. 
While threatening additional easing measures at his press conference (such as driving negative deposit rates further into negative territory) Mr. Kuroda seems to have explicitly ruled out the adoption of “helicopter money” by the BoJ. This is quite funny, since it seems extremely unlikely that the BoJ will ever be able to extricate itself from its balance sheet expansion (which de facto amounts to an “unannounced” case of helicopter money provision)
Of course BOJ boss Haruhiko Kuroda ruled out 'helicopter money' provisions for the way to go about funding the government directly because it would be illegal. Thus it follows that they'll have to think up something else other than the Negative Interest Rates Policy to do in order to reach this 2% inflation goal. 

It's sort of interesting how the Bank of Japan went looking for this 2% inflation rate and did so by massively expanding the monetary base - which inlay man's terms is "printed lots of money" - and somehow still managed to have the Yen go up. From our old high school texts we learned that the Weimar Republic era Germany printed money to pay reparations and this resulted in astronomical inflation. It is therefore interesting that the emir scenario hasn't kicked in at all.

One of the reasons the expanded monetary base hasn't done the trick is because the printed money has gone to the banks who do not lend the money out as planned, and so the money sits there in the banks unspent. The banks for their part complain that there is nothing in which to invest. Thus the great printing press experiment remains stuck in the vaults of the banks. 

The problem is that the inflation would only go up if that money went around the economy chasing assets. To do that, they need consumers to spend, but consumers have all sort of reasons not to spend. Shinzo Abe for his part has been imploring the major corporations to raise their wages. Yet even pay has stayed largely stagnant. 

What this indicates is that the printed money went to the wrong place, pretty much as TARP and QE money went to the wrong places. As objectionable helicopter money is, the BOJ need to figure out how to shove that money into the pockets of the ordinary citizens so they feel they can spend that money. Otherwise all the prince money is going sit in the vaults of banks.

Reserve Bank Of Australia Cuts Rates

So much for the prognostication that the RBA might cut rates around June.
Instead, they were decisive.
Tuesday's historic interest rate reduction coincides with the federal government's third budget, which is expected to be mildly stimulatory despite pressure to narrow the deficit.
Deflation in the headline consumer price index, due mainly to falling oil prices and aggressive retailer discounting, was the first such quarterly contraction in seven years. 
Moderate inflation, the result of demand for goods and services – including labour – just outstripping supply, is usually the mark of a healthy economy. 
However, when prices and wages continue to fall, consumers often hold off on buying and companies on investing. Deflation also pushes up the relative burden of debt.
The cash rate is now easily at its lowest level under the current system of monetary policy setting. 
The latest cut puts Australia into the club of developed economies with ever-falling interest rates and bond yields. Japan, the European Union and parts of Scandinavia now have zero or even negative nominal rates. New Zealand, too, looks likely to keeping cutting from an already-low 2.25 per cent official cash rate.
Let's not kid ourselves. If the economy were actually running well, the RBA wouldn't be cutting interest rates. As the vagaries of politics go, it happened on the same day the Budget was brought down and really gave no scope for the Federal Government to argue it was managing the economy well.

If there's one dumb thing that the Howard Government entrenched in the public consciousness, it was the asinine idea that lower interest rates were a sign of better government. Now that interest rates are at historic lows and set to go even lower, it puts a big lie to the position that the Governments doing any good management of the economy. If this is good management of the economy, for goodness sakes give us the other stuff.

And So The Budget Happened

This year's budget would underline just how ineffective this government is.
Labor has questioned why the government is cutting corporate taxes while the budget is in deficit and only handing income tax relief to Australians on over $80,000 a year even though 75 per cent of Australians earn under that amount. 
In his first interview since Tuesday night's speech by Treasurer Scott Morrison, Mr Turnbull said he believed his first budget - which delivered tax cuts for small and medium businesses, new measures to encourage young people into jobs and cutbacks to superannuation concessions for wealthy Australians - was an "exciting" one.

"A lot of newspapers are saying, 'this is a bit of a dull budget'," Sunrise host David Koch told Mr Turnbull. 
"We all thought you would bring the big excitement and changes."
Mr Turnbull responded: "Scott Morrison was delivering a plan for jobs and growth - I think that's exciting but everyone has their on views on that. 
"The BCA [Business Council of Australia] described the changes to business tax, the biggest changes to business tax in more than a decade. 
"These are substantial tax reforms but these are reforms that are designed not for the short term, not for an election. 
"They are designed for the long-term, to ensure that we continue to get that successful, economic transition from an economy that was fired up by a mining construction boom to one that enables us to live within our means, have a sustainable tax system but above all, drive that economic growth and jobs upon which our futures and those of our children and grandchildren depend." 
Despite the RBA's shock decision to cut the cash rate to a record low of 1.75 per cent on Tuesday, Mr Turnbull said the economy remains fundamentally strong.
I like the insistence that it is an exciting time and that the economy remains fundamentally strong when on the same day the RBA goes and cuts interest rates to historic lows. For reasons and factors totally out of their control, the Australian economy is heading into the ZIRP twilight in the next few years without a plan to get out. It's not even as if Australia has a really matured manufacturing sector or the population growth is stagnating (thanks to immigration it's not) so it can be sheeted home to the massive amounts of money tied up in the Property Bubble together with the world's largest private sector debt per capita. If you want us to get excited about that, you've got another thing coming Mr. Turnbull. 

None of those problems are solved. Negative Gearing stayed in place, which was something expected, but you have to wonder about the wisdom of tightening the Superannuation loopholes fr the rich while keeping Negative Gearing going because some people think the money is going to flood into the property market, furthering the Bubble. It strikes one that the Federal Government - regardless of which party is in power - refuses to acknowledge the elephant in the room and keeps trying to talk around it as if there's room to manoeuvre. 
A crackdown on superannuation tax concessions for the rich, coupled with a budget day cut to interest rates, could increase the flow of funds into negatively geared investment property.

Ahead of the 2016-2017 federal budget announcement, two of the country's leading actuaries, Rice Warner chief executive Michael Rice and Mercer senior actuarial partner David Knox, warned that any crackdown on super tax concessions for the rich without any changes to the negative gearing rules could have the unintended consequence of pushing more money into property. 
That is exactly the policy combination that we got on Tuesday night. And to add fuel to the fire, earlier in the day, the Reserve Bank of Australia dropped the benchmark interest rate by 0.25 per cent to a record low 1.75 per cent.
In other words, this Government just fed the elephant in the room while not acknowledging it's there. 
All that being said, it's not as if it's making outlandish forecast projections for growth like WTE Joe Hockey's last budget. There's some difference between a plain old crappy crap sandwich and a double poo sundae. 




2016/04/28

Deflation Shock?

What They Mean By Deflation

Where do we start with the news that we saw deflation in Australia in the last quarter? We haven't seen deflation since 2009 when markets were at their nadir after the GFC broke.
The surprise drop in the price of a wider-than-usual range of items drove the Australian dollar down more than 1.5 per cent and could force the Reserve Bank of Australia to cut the cash rate as soon as next Tuesday, say economists. 
The Australian Bureau of Statistics said on Wednesday the consumer price index (CPI) contracted 0.2 per cent in the three months to the end of March, taking the annual rate to 1.3 per cent, compared with 1.7 per cent at the end of December. 
More importantly, the core annual rate, after lopping off or re-weighting volatile items such as fuel, came in at 1.55 per cent, well below the bottom of the Reserve Bank of Australia's target band of 2 per cent to 3 per cent. National Australia Bank described the core inflation rate as "the lowest ever".
And so we are led to believe that interest rates will be cut soon. 
I know it's contrarian of me to say this, but the inflation rate has been under-reported since the ABS changed the way it measures inflation rate. Given that it is prone to (or rather, intended to) under-report the inflation, it's not surprising that a few commodities dropping below trend would give rise to such figures. In particular it's notable that health, insurance and education still went up. In an overall sense, things are not getting cheaper  in the cost-of-living stakes as the deflationary figures would have you believe. It's not even certain that the deflation would persist into the next quarter. 

Still, the cheated inflation rate has led to a very big tendency towards looser monetary policy which has fed the Property Bubble through low interest rates. In a way it is a self-defeating feedback cycle where, as inflation is cheated downwards it creates conditions for lower interest rates, which in turn create conditions that results in a Property Bubble forming because there is nowhere else for the money to go. As more and more money is tied up in Property and Financial instruments, the less money is spent in the economy so there is even more pressure downwards on inflation figures but not necessarily inflation itself. We know there must be heavy duty inflation going on somewhere because the very definition of inflation is too much money chasing too few assets, and Australia for all its riches isn't that rich in assets beyond housing and mining and banking.

What should be galling to the Government if not the RBA is how all the money that's flowed into the market through low interest rates is finding a way not into industrial capital investment but into housing and property. Given the lowered interest rates there should be a lot of money going around but somehow it all finds its way to the big four banks who then don't invest in anything because, well, there's nothing of note into which to invest. While the mining boom was going on, there were any number of things in which to invest, but the post Mining Boom economy has shown just how hollowed out Australia's economy has become. 

Let's face it, the most glaring problem might be that even at 2% official interest rates, there is only anaemic economic growth in a country that cannot be described as mature industrial. It's not like wages are rising rapidly. It's not like the government has a plan beyond being excited and wanting to be agile. It sounds as hollow as the economy when the same government spent enormous political capital crippling the NBN. Should our country be in the sort of economic-figure-doldrums like Japan, Germany or France? 

From TwIRP Towards ZIRP

Of course, the markets are factoring in a couple of rate cuts this year. If they do cut 0.25% in May and the another 0.25% by the end of the year, we'll be a lot closer to ZIRP than ever before. 

I don't know if the Property Bubble is starting to affect people's spending, not so much through debt being a problem, but more in line with the fact that lots of Millennials are staying at home. They probably won't be buying whitewoods for a start but they are also restricted as to just how much stuff they can buy if they're still dwelling in their parents' house. There's a lot of demand right there that's essentially blocked by the very physicality of the economy. Even if people had money to spend, they can't buy things because they have nowhere to put them. They can't spend on services because in most part they are met easily by living at home. The only things they do buy are gadgets like smart phones. 

Indeed, one of the interesting things about the Property Bubble in Australia is that has been going on for so long that it hasn't needed to pop to significantly hinder economic growth. The low interest rates that continue to fuel extraordinary valuations has led to record profits for banks, and that's no accident. The post-GFC economy might be hard on primary and secondary industries but the financial sector has been doing really well on the back of all the easing.

And lets face it, the Central Banks of the world are most likely swayed by the opinions of bankers so it comes as no surprise that banks have made out like bandits under these loose monetary policies. Pretty soon all the bankers are going to be telling the Reserve Bank how 'deflation' is killing asset prices and make it like there's a major crisis going on out there in the various markets. If the deflation goes two or three quarters, it will be a clamouring of bankers knocking on Glenn Stevens' door. You have to wonder then how long the RBA is going to take before it gets down to Zero Interest Rate Policy. When we get there, we'll understand the wealthy have locked in their advantage, and that Australia is officially 'post-industrial' like Japan and European countries with low interest rates, low inflation, and low growth. The joke would be that we were hardly industrial before we got there - we put the money into housing and the road came to an end.

John Howard Did Us No Favours

I guess you have to go back in time a bit to the Howard Government to see where the number-fiddling started. Unemployment in the second half of the 80s and first half of the 90s was a big thing. The figures were such that it was part of John Howard's pitch that he would bring these figures down together with the high interest rates. It was under the Howard Government that welfare was cut and privatised, while pushing people off unemployment benefits and on to things like disability pensions. It was an attempt to recategorised the people who couldn't easily find employment so that they wouldn't all show up as unemployed. They no longer showed up as unemployed so it looked like the Government was finding people jobs.

Similarly the under-reporting of inflation started during the Howard Government. When governments talk about inflation rates of the 80s and 90s as if those figures can be compared directly, they're being mightily disingenuous. Back then the inflation rate and cost-of-living figures were in line and almost interchangeable. Today, there is a huge blow out in the difference between the inflation rate and cost-of-living, so much so nobody's even talking about it any more.

So if part of the Howard Government's big achievements were lowering unemployment figures and interest rates then it did so by cheating on the numbers. By cheating so hard it set up this decade for the inherent contradiction of its claims to surface. The economic growth figures are so low because the Howard Government didn't make proper investments in its time - it chose to fiddle numbers and created the conditions for the Property Bubble to manifest instead. Now it's time for the subsequent Coalition government to clean up the mess but it's flying blind because the numbers are phoney. All thanks to the Howard Government.

But hey, we kept our AAA ratings!





2015/12/16

View From The Couch - 16/Dec/2015

ScoMo Is A Different Kind Of Economic Animal

The MYEFO has come out and well, Scott Morrison isn't exactly cutting everything in sight. Yes, he's cutting some things, but he's vowing not to chase the fall in revenue down. 
Scott Morrison has learnt well from Joe Hockey, Chris Bowen and Wayne Swan.
The best thing to do when revenue is collapsing is to let it, lest it bring the economy down with it. 
As he put it: extreme measures would have placed "a hand brake on household consumption and business investment growth" and unnecessarily threatened emerging signs of economic momentum.
That's pretty contrary to the Coalition diatribe about debt only months ago, and as enacted in two disastrous budgets under WTE Joe Hockey. It must be that at heart, we're all Keynesians now, as the saying goes. 

It also shows that the Turnbull Government really is a different beast to the Abbott Government, at least on an operational level. A simple question of "what would Tony have done?" yields images of a cigar-chomping, axe-wielding WTE Joe. Instead, he's telling us it's not going to be austerity all the way down. I don't want to praise Scott Morrison in the least freaking bit but you have to hand it to him, he's not reacting as one would have imagined from his turn as minister for turning back boats. 

I have to admit, I'm a little surprised. On another level, I think I can see we're heading towards ZIRP a lot more than raising interest rates. As it turns out, it's really hard to get the market off the easing bias. Who'd a thunk it? 
Which leads me to the next thing... 

When The US Fed Dons Wolf's Clothing

This is weird when you reflect back to the utter chaos of the GFC at its height in August 2008. The US Fed is about to raise interest rates by 25bps sometime this week or early next year. Indeed, the speculation is that they have to do it this month because there are no more months beyond December and they committed to doing it before the year was out. So, logically, it's this month. The countervailing view is that the situation is so dire and the High Yield bond market is collapsing so fast, the Federal Reserve Bank would have to be crazy to pull the trigger. 

The fact of the matter is, they didn't pull the trigger when it was benign back in October, so we were left asking the question, if not then, when? If things get precarious enough, the FRB is going to have to think about easing again in no time, which means they'll back at ZIRP in a matter months. It is as if Wall Street is permanently addicted to having cheap indefinite credit and anything else makes it fatal to the whole financial system of the planet. In other words, nothing structural has been fixed since the GFC, that caused the GFC. The risk factors are right back up to where they were on the eve of the meltdown. 

And still, the language from Janet Yellen has been that they're going to raise rates because things are going so much better now. Goodness, it's hard to think all the way back to Paul Volcker in the 1980s. Would he have hesitated? No not a chance. 

On a more local note, the anticipation of the move has created ructions in our own equity market in Australia. It's very strange:
"Amazingly enough it hasn't been priced in. It really is quite extraordinary," he said. "Perversely we may see markets rallying on the back of it once we have some certainty about what the central bank is doing in the US." 
"It's all around these issues regarding sustainable, stable commodity prices and whether we get a decision out of the US Federal Reserve," said Mr Lakos.
Chris Conway, head of research at the Australian Stock Report said while some traders were dipping back into beaten down stocks, the overarching vibe was one of caution. 
"We don't expect any large moves ahead of the US Fed decision on Thursday morning (Australian time), with no-one ... willing to take on too much risk or place any big bets despite the outcome being largely expected," he said. 
"We also expect some volatility immediately after the decision but hopefully, once everyone has processed the result, markets calm and we rally into the end of the year."
So shares got oversold in the last 48hours because everybody suddenly remembered that Janet Yellen was possibly/probably going to go for it with the interest rate hike. Which means that if and when it gets announced, shares are likely to bounce back from 2.5year lows. Like I said, this is really weird. 

China Crisis On The Brew

Nobody's really talking about it in the mainstream news but, China's economy's actually on the ropes. How do we know this? Pretty simple. When China was going great guns, commodity prices were up. For commodity prices to hit the skids this low, this hard and for this long, means China's really run out of puff and can't turn the commodities into economic growth. The collapse in demand for iron ore and coking coal is more than telling, it's both a white flag from China and a red flag for the Australian economy.

In that spirit, here's a story that you might find explains a lot of things.
Several local officials in China's Northeast region sought to explain dramatic economic drops in their areas by admitting they had faked economic data in the past few years to show highgrowth when the real numbers were much lower, Xinhua News Agency reported on Friday. 
"If the past data had not been inflated, the current growth figures would not show such a precipitous fall," one official was quoted as saying. 
The report cited several officials in the region who acknowledged they had significantly overstated data ranging from fiscal revenue and household income to GDP. 
Three years ago Liaoning province's GDP growth was reported at 9.5 percent, but its current figure-over the first three quarters of this year-is just 2.7 percent. Jilin's growth was reported at 12 percent three years ago, but its current rate is 6.3 percent in the same period.
That right there is your confirmation. The Chinese figures have been worse than rubbery, they've been fraudulent. Not only is the commodity boom over, we're in uncharted waters as to exactly what the hell is going to happen next in China when all the debt racked up to fake the demand to fake the growth comes home to roost. So if you're inclined to believe this week's offical statement about strong industrial production and retail sales in China... sure why not? Let's all take that blue pill from Morpheus' hand. 

2015/09/19

News That's Fit To Punt - 19/Sep/2015

ZIRP Didn't End Today

After months of threatening to lift interest rates, the US Fed decided not to raise interest rates today. Which is pretty damn amazing really because it does nothing but punch a hole in the credibility of the US Fed when it talks about how it sees its own policy. Think out it for a moment. If it were the RBA and Glenn Stevens, it would be unthinkable for him to spell putsch a move for 9 months of the year, only to squib on the threat when you were supposed to do it.

As it is, the RBA has us on a strange parallel world to ZIRP with our very own TWIRP, which is causing its own havoc. Interesting then that the constraints of the US Fed running ZIRP forcesAustralia to adopt its TWIRP and so Glenn Stevens wants to urge Janet Yellen to just get on with it.  Of course if the US Fed does raise it even 0.25%, about a trillion dollars worth of derivative contracts go up in smoke. but this is the thing about derivative contracts: they're only tangentially related to the real world economy.

Of course, the reason the US Fed didn't raise their interest rates according to Janet Yellen's statement is that they are concerned about China's economy - Something both Glenn Stevens and Michael Pascoe think are over-stated as being problematic. And yet, you have to wonder what the US Fed knows about China.

The Wild Wishcasting Phase

Those conservative chumps in the Coalition must be dreaming big, now that albatross Tony has been sent packing, and the poll bounce shows they would demolish a Bill Shorten-led ALP if there were an election held today. They haven't had numbers like since the days of Julia Gillard and even then Tony Abbott himself had terrible poll numbers. They might have to go back to 2010 just before Kevin Rudd got knifed by Julia Gillard to a time when they had a commanding lead in the polls.
Which is to say, at least for this week they've got it good.

They're probably starting to think big about how this might translate into votes, but really we need to put a big caveat on Malcolm Turnbull's alleged popularity. For a start if your predecessor is Tony Abbott, even a pile of dog dung is bound to come up smelling roses. This electorate was dying for something much better than Tony Abbott, so naturally there would be a poll bounce.

But here's the thing, if Malcolm Turnbull is really going to capture votes from the Left, he's seriously going to have to do something that even the hardest credential-ed lefty is going to admit is good, and that means having to do something the right hates, and there's simply no leeway in Malcolm Turnbull to do any such thing. And that being the case, it won't be long before the stench of old Liberal and National Party policy positions will stink like the dead fish that they are, and bring Malcolm Turnbull's popularity down to their level.

In turn, the smart advice going for Lefties is for them not to get too excited.

Not All That Dies Old Is Bad, Not All That's Young And Remaining Is Good

I haven't paid much attention to the Canning by-election brought on by the death of Don Randall. Don Randall of course tabled to motion for a spill back in February and was founded in his car not long after that. If this were a mafia movie, you'd draw your own conclusions - but it is not, they say he died of a heart attack in his car. It's hard to tell what sort of MP he was, but if he thought enough to urge his party members to dump Tony Abbott, there was probably a decent man right there.

Andrew Hastie is the man running for the coalition in his place and he's an ex-SAS man. This sort of candidacy makes my skin crawl because those guys lead a pretty narrow life with a narrow world view and they might have a world of experience in the extremes of a combat zone, they're not guys known for a deep and compassionate outlook on their fellow man.

Andrew Hastie has accused the ALP of not supporting our troops in the Afghanistan based on his personal experience. It seems like a really crass thing to say in your run up to your polls, and really shows you the sort of grubby candidate that he is. It's pretty bleak that a sensible elder dies to be replaced by some narrow-core one-eyed zealot. Our polity is doing really badly right there.

Ragging On Bill Shorten

You can count me as one of the people who got very hot under the collar about Bill Shorten's role in bringing down Kevin Rudd in 2010. I'm still not that crash hot about how that all went down as you know; but then, I wasn't exactly crazy about the whole ALP way before Kevin Rudd even became Leader back in 2007. For a better part of 24months while the Abbottoir reigned, Bill Shorten's stint as Opposition leader has looked at times like a very contrived, stage-managed wave to *his* people, a knowing wink that he was just going to sit pretty and be a small target - even though Tony Abbott made things simple.

An even then I have enough perspective and patience to say, the ALP need to let Bill Shorten do his thing, what ever it is. There isn't an easy road to government; there isn't a short cut.

In the wake of the Turnbull seizing the day, Shorten's approval rating has sunk to 24% and there are now grumbles in the electorate about his 'performance' already. This is galling because it's from the very same people who wanted Malcolm Turnbull over Tony Abbott but vote only for the ALP anyway.
Folks, you need to grow up and grow a brain.

Mind you I had a chance to chat to somebody who told me they were one of these ALP voters who wanted Malcolm Turnbull and their reasoning was that independent of sides, Abbott *had* to go for the good of Australia (which is hard to dispute) and that it was now time for the ALP to step up and put in their best leader to square off against the best the coalition has brought to the table. I enquired of them who they thought the better leader would be and they answered in a heartbeat, "Albo!"

When I expressed incredulity, they replied that Tanya Plibersek would make a better leader than Bill Shorten. I just want to point out that the ALP haven't contested a single Federal Election with Bill Shorten as leader. Do you think there might be a problem with the Australian political culture precisely because the electorate is already so bloodthirsty? These politicians are only reflecting our choppy-changey electorate.

It's not shopping for shoes or the next sugar hit at the candy store. It's political leadership we're talking here. ALP supporters would be out of their fucking minds to want to start jockeying for replacing Shorten.

2015/07/08

News That's Fit To Punt - 08/Jul/2015

The Optimists' Corner

The really funny thing is that when things are going wildly in a bad direction, somebody will come up with a contrary opinion in wildly the opposite direction. It's hard to fathom it, but on a day where the Shanghai index had to suspend trade on 40% of their blue chip firms to stop people trying to squeeze out the door at the same time, Goldman Sachs said that it sees no bubble in the Chinese equity markets.
Goldman Sachs is sticking with its optimistic forecast in the face of record foreign outflows, the biggest-ever selloff by Chinese margin traders and a chorus of bubble warnings from international peers. The call hinges on the success of unprecedented government efforts to revive confidence among individual investors who watched equity values tumble by 3.2 trillion over the past three weeks. 
"It's not in a bubble yet," Lau said in an interview. "China's government has a lot of tools to support the market." 
Lau, who set his CSI 300 target on July 1, confirmed on Tuesday that the projection still stands. He's been forecasting gains in Chinese shares for much of the past year, a stance that paid off as the CSI 300 surged to a seven-year high last month.
Heck, they may be right. Maybe there will be an almighty bounce soon, what with China's government pumping in liquidity, but... there's just this chart here:



...which sort of paints a picture of how these kinds of things don't work out too well. 

Just to be sure, I sort of poked Roger in HK who - as his living - gives investment advice to the stupendously rich in Asia. To which he replied:
The Chinese can't go to the Macau casinos because of govt crackdown on corruption, so the money's gotta go somewhere. It's like one big wet market where you can get leverage financing. Buy10 bananas for the price of one now and pay later? Yeah give me a hundred!
After lunch, he sent back two phrases. The first, as the market opened was, "Meltdown". A few hours later he told me "It's a Bloodbath." I told him to tell his clients to BTFD ("Buy The Fucken Dips"). I only got a smiley-emoticon back. I'm sure Roger's laughing-out-loudly, because that's his natural nervous reaction to anything out of the ordinary.  

The other wildly optimistic article was this one that said there is no housing bubble, Australian property prices were 30% undervalued. 
What has changed since then is that real long-term interest rates have fallen substantially. That fall made housing more attractive relative to renting, despite the increase in prices." 
Dr Tulip and his co-researcher compared the cost of renting and buying identical properties, avoiding the common trap of comparing national average rents with national average prices. Because owned homes are typically "bigger and nicer" than rented homes, a lot of the apparent price difference reflects a quality difference. 
They calculated the annual cost of a bought home from the purchase price, the transaction cost, the expected mortgage rate and the running and depreciation costs offset by expected capital gains. 
The annual cost of owning a home bought in April was likely to be 2.7 per cent of its value. The annual cost of renting the same home was likely to be 3.9 per cent. 
"So you can either pay 2.7 per cent of the value of the property to buy, or you can pay 3.9 per cent of the value to rent," Dr Tulip told the conference.
"The undervaluation is 30 per cent. 
"It's unusually wide, the widest in at least 30 years. I can take you back further but the data quality deteriorates the further we go back.
Ri-i-i-ight. I can follow the maths where 3.9% is 30% over 2.7%. But this is based on TwIRP. I wonder what it would look like under ZIRP - probably even better. Mathematically speaking, the gap would open up even wider as interest rates asymptotically reached towards Zero. While mathematically being true, you sort of wonder whether the real world economics would reflect such calculations. When we get down to ZIRP, we may no longer have banks that are willing to lend to people wanting to buy multimillion dollar homes as their first homes, given that the economy is at a zero-sum game. 

Anyway, I just thought you'd be amused by those two wildly optimistic views of what we are looking at: a market crash in China and a property bubble in Australia.

The 'Greferendum', Revisited

Walk-off HBP thinks this one's a bit alarmist, but it contains some really interesting information that is a little disturbing. 
Greek premier Alexis Tsipras never expected to win Sunday's referendum on EMU bail-out terms, let alone to preside over a blazing national revolt against foreign control.

He called the snap vote with the expectation - and intention - of losing it. The plan was to put up a good fight, accept honourable defeat, and hand over the keys of the Maximos Mansion, leaving it to others to implement the June 25 "ultimatum" and suffer the opprobrium.

This ultimatum came as a shock to the Greek cabinet. They thought they were on the cusp of a deal, bad though it was. Mr Tsipras had already made the decision to acquiesce to austerity demands, recognizing that Syriza had failed to bring about a debtors' cartel of southern EMU states and had seriously misjudged the mood across the eurozone.

Instead they were confronted with a text from the creditors that upped the ante, demanding a rise in VAT on tourist hotels from 7pc (de facto) to 23pc at a single stroke.

Creditors insisted on further pension cuts of 1pc of GDP by next year and a phase out of welfare assistance (EKAS) for poorer pensioners, even though pensions have already been cut by 44pc.

They insisted on fiscal tightening equal to 2pc of GDP in an economy reeling from six years of depression and devastating hysteresis. They offered no debt relief. The Europeans intervened behind the scenes to suppress a report by the International Monetary Fund validating Greece's claim that its debt is "unsustainable". The IMF concluded that the country not only needs a 30pc haircut to restore viability, but also €52bn of fresh money to claw its way out of crisis.
They rejected Greek plans to work with the OECD on market reforms, and with the International Labour Organisation on collective bargaining laws. They stuck rigidly to their script, refusing to recognise in any way that their own Dickensian prescriptions have been discredited by economists from across the world.

"They just didn't want us to sign. They had already decided to push us out," said the now-departed finance minister Yanis Varoufakis.

So Syriza called the referendum. To their consternation, they won, igniting the great Greek revolt of 2015, the moment when the people finally issued a primal scream, daubed their war paint, and formed the hoplite phalanx.

Mr Tsipras is now trapped by his success. "The referendum has its own dynamic. People will revolt if he comes back from Brussels with a shoddy compromise," said Costas Lapavitsas, a Syriza MP.

"Tsipras doesn't want to take the path of Grexit, but I think he realizes that this is now what lies straight ahead of him," he said.
Holy cow. So basically, the Euro creditors do want a Grexit, and sent terms that would be rejected by Greece and stuck to their guns. Tsipras didn't want to go to a Grexit so when he called a referendum, he was hoping to 'lose' to a 'yes' vote and use that as a catalyst to take Syriza out of government and the ongoing non-negotiations. But of course, the 'No' vote won which meant that Tsipras wasn't able to get his ticket to get out of the ongoing non-negotiations and had to head back. This explains Varoufakis' exit better, and how on Monday a new Finance Minister arrived Brussels without a plan. Yep. The Greek cabinet war gamed the Grexit and didn't like what they saw, so they tried to get back to Brussels with a white flag, but of course, there can't be a plan because they didn't expect the 'No' vote to win so resoundingly. 

Knowing all this now makes me more frightened. Thanks to both Greece and China, commodities have tanked as has the AUD. We may well not notice it immediately, but our balance of payments got worse by default in Australia. All this stuffs made us collectively poorer, and it's just the beginning. Economists are now readjusting the RBA outlook, thinking there's more than likely a interest rate cut coming. If it does, well, so much for TwIRP. 


2015/05/11

Introducing TwIRP

Not ZIRP

The news today is that not only is the RBA unlikely to cut rates any lower than the 2.0% where it sits, but it's also unlikely to start hiking them up for another 3years.
In the statement explaining the bank's decision to cut the cash rate to a record low 2 per cent, RBA governor Glenn Stevens omitted a key phrase used frequently in earlier statements to signal more cuts: "further easing of policy may be appropriate over the period ahead".

Financial markets are pricing in a just 30 per cent chance of a rate cut over the next 12 months, the longest odds for another cut in months. 
Rate cuts are good news for home owners and investors, but a prolonged spell of record low interest rates could be grim news for those who rely on returns from their bank savings, such as many elderly Australians.
Which sort of indicates that even if China's economy implodes under the weight of debt and the nation dissolves into civil warrior something catastrophic, the Property Bubble is unlikely to pop. That's the good news for those who took out (and continue to take out) stupendous mortgages. The RBA's right behind you, even when it says it might block you. Really. 2.0% - get over it! It's good (they say)!

The funny thing is that the RBA can't bring it self to go right down to Zero Interest Rate Policy because after all, Australia's economy is yet to implode and it probably sees those 8 increments of 25 basis points down to ZIRP as being valuable because - I dunno - China may implode and dissolve into utter chaos after all. Otherwise it can't construct a scenario where the Australian economy becomes worthy of high interest rates - as in more interesting - in the near future. 2.0% - get over it. It's just crap (others say)!

So caught between a rock and a hard place, it's likely going to stay on 2.0% for a long time.
As such, we may as well name this the Two-percent Interest Rate Policy: TwIRP.

Those Who Live In Glass Houses

News Corp is hilarious. No, really, they are.
Detail is scant as yet but the first initiative delivers further anti-avoidance powers to the Tax Office to recover unpaid taxes from multinationals and issue fines. The second is the so-called "Netflix Tax" through which GST will be extended to digital downloads from overseas. 
The rich paradox in this Netflix Tax is that it was urged upon the government by Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation, whose Foxtel pay-TV business stands to lose from digital competitors offshore. As previously revealed though, News Corp has now been identified as the Tax Office's number one tax avoidance risk in Australia.
You have to laugh. Especially when you consider it's the Coalition Government going after tax avoidance by multinationals, and we know Rupert loves him some Coalition Government; he put them there and now they're doing this.

At least, they say they're doing this. You can trust a Tory and their professed policy about as far as you are willing to stick your genitals into a meat grinder.

2015/05/05

RBA Cuts Rates to 2.00%

Historically Low Rates

Just as the scuttlebutt around the markets predicted, the RBA cut interest rates yet again. At 2%, it's never been this low in the time the Reserve Bank has existed. More over, they did so even with the threat of real estate prices in Sydney going even more ballistic. It's pretty much as the IMF suggested, and really hen you look at it, it's still quite high compared to the other countries running their ZIRP, especially if the Reserve Bank of Australia likes to move in 0.25% increments. We have 8 increments to zero, and 6 to the 0.5% being offered in the USA. It's enough to still encourage wary internationals to buy our bonds.

Of course, as I've discussed before, low interest forms a very difficult frame around what exactly we're seeing as our economic future. The collapse in interest rates in advanced countries has gone hand in hand with the collapse of the future horizon, where it's unclear where the next spurt of growth is going to come. The fevered investor activity in real estate happens exactly because the investors cannot see the future-industry-to-come beyond the mining boom, they're rushing to lock up their spoils in real estate in the hopes of squeezing rents for their cashflow.

Added to the fact that speculative activity increases as money supply becomes easier, and you have exactly the scenario where there's too much money chasing too few assets. There is inflation going on in the markets, but interestingly enough, we're being dragged towards ZIRP all of our own down under precisely because the RBA doesn't want to pop the bubble and create a stampede for the door.  The problem is, the RBA has to either wear a preternaturally high Australian Dollar, or wear a property bubble. It's already at the point where the RBA is finding it hard to raise interest rates, so the question that looms is just when are we going to get down to ZIRP? Because the rates really appear unlikely to go up any time soon. In fact going up would act like a margin call and suddenly all these happy home loans will become distressed. It would cause a shitstorm. Besides which, given the weight of globalised capital markets, the only way forward is no cuts or more cuts.

And what the hell is Sydney going to look like when interest rates hit even 1.00%, let alone a number starting with zero? It's going to be really wild.

What's really strange is that politicians of this land seem perfectly okay with all of this.

2015/04/15

IMF Says Cut Rates To RBA

Doesn't Low Interest Mean It's Not Interesting?

This is news of sorts. The IMF wants the RBA to cut rates. If you ever wanted an indication that the global trend towards ZIRP in the first world, this is pretty much it.
Reserve Bank governor Glenn Stevens said last month that more rate cuts "may be appropriate" to encourage growth in demand and inflation, despite also previously warning that his power to boost economic growth by lowering interest rates is diminishing with every cut. 
But now the IMF has issued a clear warning to Australia, saying the economy has much spare capacity and the RBA may have to keep cutting rates to prevent "inflation expectations" from dropping permanently. 
Its latest World Economic Outlook also predicts unemployment will rise to 6.4 per cent this year, and remain at 6.2 per cent in 2016. Australian unemployment is currently 6.3 per cent. 
"In economies in which output gaps are currently negative [Australia, Japan, Korean, Thailand], policymakers may need to act to prevent a persistent decline in inflation expectations," the IMF has warned. 
Economists say the IMF's point about "inflation expectations" is serious because once consumers and employers believe inflation will be much lower in the future they will start behaving accordingly, with consequences for wages growth and spending.
So the IMF wants the Australian economy to continue to expect inflation as it has done for the last 40years. I don't think that's hard given the persistent gap between CPI and costive living as measured by the ABS. If the cost of living stays high, people will continue to have "inflation expectation", despite the artificially lowered CPI governments and the RBA use to claim inflation has dropped.

Be that as it may, the IMF is essentially saying that Australia is currently lining up with economies like Japan, South Korea and Thailand where there is deflationary pressures. You sort of wonder at the faith of people who keep pushing Sydney property prices ever upward. Gravity is pulling pretty hard if we're really lining up with Japan and South Korea.

It's also interesting that the IMF seems to think we're at the doorstep of a deflationary spiral without having had the property bubble pop. In Japan, the deflationary cycle started as a result of the property bubble bursting. The IMF is essentially saying the property bubble is not relevant, Australia is on the brink of a deflationary spiral based on the raw numbers. I have to confess there's a bit of cognitive dissonance there. Something's not computing.

Of course, should the property bubble pop, then we can contain there being a massive deflationary spiral simply because the heights the bubble has risen are so damn high. We can be guaranteed of ZIRP when the bubble pops, and then maybe even Australia's very own QE program after bail out of banks - but of course that would be the mark of a very advanced, mature, and uninteresting economy.

2015/04/07

News That's Fit To Punt - 07/Apr/2015

RBA Doesn't Cut Interest Rates

It's amazing how a non-news makes the news. The RBA did not cut official interest rates and so the share market went into a bit of a spin. You can read the statement they issued but a non-change should mean no news, but here we are.
Fear of fuelling the Sydney and Melbourne real estate markets appears to have trumped hope for job-seekers and borrowers across the nation with the Reserve Bank leaving the official cash rate on hold in April rather than opting for cheaper credit to spark a new round of hiring. 
But a rate cut has now become almost certain in May - just before the federal budget - after the RBA listed the pre-conditions and backed specific efforts through tougher regulation designed to "contain" house price growth being inflated by prospective landlords. 
"Growth in lending to investors in housing assets is stronger than to owner-occupiers," RBA governor Glenn Steven said in his monthly statement. 
"Dwelling prices continue to rise strongly in Sydney, though trends have been more varied in a number of other cities. The bank is working with other regulators to assess and contain risks that may arise from the housing market."
The unemployed go a mention in there. It's this traditional thing where if unemployment is too high, they cut rates in the opes that it promotes businesses to hiring people. You get the feeling that they're not hiring at 2.25%, would they necessarily hire more if the rates gets down to 2.00%? And keep in mind, at such historic lows, what kind of fragile business would it be to need 2.00% interest rates to decide, "hey, we'll hire more peeps!"?

On the other hand, the correlation between lowering interest rates and more investors entering the market is more direct; I mean, there is no cushion of business sentiment, it's straight up maths. So the equally blunt question is, what kind of investor gets into property on the basis that interest rates are at 2.00% but it's too hard at 2.25%? Equally weird as the business that can only hire at when interest rates are at 2.00% - but not necessarily symmetrical. I would dare say the investor balking at the border of 2.25% is far dogdier than the employer balking at the borderline of 2.00% and 2.25%.   

Either way, the unemployed person is like the garni du jour next to the sandwich. They can't get a job because god only knows why and until they do, they can't get into property and even then it's doubtful that they can without shouldering greater risk or higher interest rates. It simply doesn't help them in the near-, mid-, or long-term that interest rates are cut, and it can hurt them when they go up. That's a tough spot. I was thinking as I was reading the article that the CPI under-reporting has doubly hurt the unemployed because they get less dollar value from the dole than they used to, and they're further away from ever owning any assets so they're locked into being poor in the medium term if not right out to the end of their lives. 
Well done RBA! 

Ideology Gives Rise To The Thought Police

I was doing the St. Johns ambulance First Aid course last week. Every time it came to dealing with the upper torso and the inner thigh, the male instructor would lay down the fact that it would be better to find a female person to do it than doing it as a male. I get it. It might be misconstrued. So, the First Aid instructor might have had a few brushes with the gender politic thing and came off second  best, or maybe he witnessed the results of being misconstrue, but it was made absolutely clear there's a gender divide. Personally, I'd do exactly as instructed. I sure as hell wouldn't do anything that could be misconstrued and that would mean I would go look for a woman to deal with a female injured person. Vital minutes could be lost, but - fuck that - I'd rather not be misconstrued either. 

The point is, you still have to think of gender in an emergency. Why the hell would sexism ever disappear? This led me to think that even when the final bastion of sexism is destroyed, it would just get reinvented as this kind double-think. On that note, I present to you this stupid article:
Labor's health spokeswoman Catherine King attacked Senator Leyonhjelm for another of his posts in which she said he trivialised the serious issue that is breast cancer.

Under a Catallaxy Files article titled "Feel a boob day", "DavidLeyonhjelm" wrote "It's not enough to perve. Detecting breast cancer requires palpation." 
"One of the best ways to do this is to bet a woman 20 cents you can make her tits wobble without touching them. After a minute or so of close up staring at them, you grab them with both hands and make them wobble. Of course you then give her the 20 cents. It's a small price to pay for reducing breast cancer." 
Senator Leyonhjelm admitted making the second comment, saying this was a "longstanding joke" between him and his wife as it had actually happened to her in real life and urged others to see the humour. 
"At the time a guy actually did it to her, she giggled but I think I found it more amusing than she did," he said.
"Have you ever heard of FTITCTAJ? F--- Them If They Can't Take A Joke," he said. But Ms King said it was no laughing matter.

"Breast cancer is a tragic disease which takes a terrible toll on Australian women," said Ms King. 
"Every day in Australia, on average, 40 women are diagnosed with breast cancer, and 8 women will die of this disease. 
"I cannot comprehend how anyone could make light of this in such a degrading, and juvenile fashion.
Argh. It gives me a headache that they're arguing this in the Senate. If there's one thing worse than the doublethink necessitated by the political correctness, it's the unreconstructed sexism of older men who make no attempt to re-examne their position. 

And wowsers. 

Go On Joe, Bite The Hand That Feeds You

Down in Eden-Monaro, a famously swinging electorate, the voters have been polled and they say they are angry with tax avoidance by big corporations and are anxious about penalty rates. 
Polling obtained by Fairfax Media found more than nine out of 10 people in the NSW bellwether federal seat of Eden Monaro believe the government is not doing enough to ensure large companies pay their fair share of tax. 
The issue will take centre stage this week with the first public hearings of the Senate inquiry into tax avoidance. Representatives of Google, Apple, Microsoft, News Corp and miner Glencore are due to appear in front of the committee.

Almost 75 per cent of 707 people polled in Eden Monaro said big companies paid too little tax, while just 3 per cent said they paid too much. In launching the tax white paper process, Treasurer Joe Hockey flagged the need for a corporate tax cut to make the Australian business environment more internationally competitive.
You wonder if this message is getting to WTE Joe. After all, given how much the international miners  donated to the Coalition, you'll never be sure that the Coalition isn't a puppet for these interests.  WTE Joe is allegedly trying to get more tax out of these companies through a 'Google Tax' but it wouldn't mean much unless it was getting everybody - and by that we include Rupert Murdoch, whose Australian operations shipped 4.5billion out of Australia before tax. Will WTE have the fortitude to tax the biggest media benefactor for the Coalition. Or will he do what he did last year and go after the small fry harder while letting the big fish swim away with billions? Because being even handed with this would mean going after the very hand that feeds him and his party. 









Blog Archive