Showing posts with label Scandal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Scandal. Show all posts

2015/09/27

View From The Couch - 27/Sep/2015

Does Privatisation Actually Work For The Citizen At All?

Sometimes I think privatisation of government monopolies gets discussed in a vacuum, free of context so all anybody has to do is fling figures around the abstract and settle on a deal in the abstract, thus letting the chips where they may fall in reality, far from the negotiating room. So far, since the late 1990s when NSW embarked on allowing competition in the marketplace for electricity billings, it has contributed to condition whereby we seem to be getting charged more, thanks to the gold plating going on with the electric companies. this has led to the Australian Competition Tribunal to step in and overturning a decision by the electricity price regulator that would have allowed the electricity price to group even more. Now, that intervention is being contested with a phalanx lawyers, trying to get back to charging whatever the hell they like.
A phalanx of about 40 lawyers representing electricity networks across Australia are attempting to convince three men – the members of the Australian Competition Tribunal – to overturn a decision by the electricity price regulator which would have rewarded NSW households with a $100 to $300 a year saving on their power bills. 
And get this: because the electricity networks in some states are publicly owned, it is taxpayers who will pick up the tab for this legal free-for-all – rumoured to be as high as $90 million – which is also aimed at getting them to pay higher bills. Other states, where the networks are privately owned will also see the effects over time. 
Also present in the room are two barristers for the Public Interest Advocacy Centre which with a modest annual budget of $3 million, is mounting the case consumers should pay even less than the regulator's edict. 
The case has emerged as a fascinating window into just how far our economy strays from the free market ideal. 
Electricity networks are, of course, natural monopolies.
In a competitive market, firms are forced to operate efficiently, and at lowest cost, lest their customers flee to their competitors. 
Without this disciplinary force of a free market, electricity networks require a regulator to hold them to account, impose efficient pricing and keep prices as low as possible for consumers. 
Every four years, the Australian Energy Regulator determines how much electricity networks can charge customers, based on what an "efficient and prudent" business would need to charge in order to cover its costs and make a profit.
Networks costs make up about half your household bill.
And there you have it - the very picture of how the electricity industry is one big rent-seeking enterprise, trying to set prices not by any relationship to the market but by how much it can gouge. It kind of puts to rest any notion that there is any kind competition going on; instead is abundantly clear that it is yet another oligopoly that has the power to set prices any which way it likes. Worse still, the current Coalition Government has created conditions whereby there is minimal investment in renewable energy, so things quickly reduce to minimal choices for the consumer, and every opportunity to collude and set any price they like, for the electric companies.

Compounding the problem further still is the desire by the NSW Government to lease out the poles and wires so they can "build more infrastructure" with the proceeds. So it goes without saying that the NSW Government wants to be able to gouge lots of money so that it looks good on the bottom line for investors to pay up for the poles and wires. Once it goes private, the private ownership will do everything in its power to push up prices to what the market will bear. Again, it is not clear how privatisation actually helps the public. 

It is understandable that as a government monopoly, it is ripe for a sell-off and that the proceeds from the sale are desirable. It just doesn't seem to fulfil the bit where the government is supposed to serve all of its people, and not just the wealthy private interests. 

What Infrastructure? WasteCONnex!?

There's a certain element of predictability about what the state government of NSW does when it comes to infrastructure - it basically builds big budget toll roads first and foremost, and not much of anything else. They do this because General Construction forms a vast rent-seeking lobby whereby they can promise jobs as well as the seeming appearance of progress, by building vast concrete structures. What's truly amazing about the WestConnex project underway is that it is being built without a business case for which to answer. In other words, the government is promising to spend oodles of money on project without really knowing if it is going to be productive or useful, but it's insisting on doing so because the people who stand to make lots of money at the public's expense are their friends. The Government is minimally interested in the collateral damage it is likely to cause, and all of it is centred around the notion that toll roads are good things. 

I won't go into my usual complaint that the nepotism and crony-capitalism is a terrible thing (it is); I won't go into my rant about how medieval and anti-progressive toll roads are in concept (they are); or how self-serving the arguments are in favour of these things (God bless Adam Smith and self-interest); but I do want to point at the urban sprawl these developments are encouraging.

The NSW Government is saying, with its semaphore of policies, "go live out in the boonies 50km away from you jobs. We'll put in toll roads so you can pay $100 a week to go to and home from your jobs. But you get a backyard in a cookie-cutter suburb designed by the lowest IQ architects and town planners we could find." And they're not in the least bit ashamed that this is happening because hey, the electorate is so stupid they think they really want this too. And maybe it does - which goes to show we really get the leadership we deserve.

I've said this before but if you apply the simple cui bono test, you come up with the same old crony-capitalist rent-seeking lobby groups. If somebody goes with a proposal for rail - whether it be a high speed rail system or a metro network - the government offices immediately think they're some train-spotting rail enthusiast nut with little understanding of state finances. It really is quite barbaric. In the mean time it commits us to more cars, and rampant emissions and urban sprawl. If this really is our way of life, we need to change our way of life.

Cars Cars Cars

Speaking of motor transport, the Volkswagen scandal this week has been quite informative. The notion that there can be clean diesel combustion has taken a major hit as Volkswagen admitted to screwing with the emissions test with a bit of software.

I grabbed that screenshot from the WSJ to show just how much VW vehicles are over the various limits.  We don't know if this kind of cheating is widespread, or whether it is just VW/Porsche/Audi indulging in this kind of chicanery. Anybody manufacturing a diesel model is now under a cloud. Sometime ago I read a report that Mazda had built diesel versions of their vehicles and while they could get fuel efficiencies up, it was harder for them to meet emissions targets, which feeds into the notion that maybe there's a lot of motivation to cover up emissions from diesel vehicles. Japanese manufacturers have been much slower in coming up with diesel as a cleaner option - they've tended to explore things like Hybrids, electrics and hydrogen fuelled cars; which tells you something about how hard it is to get emissions down on diesel.

Thus when you look at the overall picture, it is looking less likely that diesel cars are anywhere near as 'clean' as claimed. As a personal side, none of this surprises me. Next to big black German 4WDs, the biggest dickheads on the road seem to be guys driving VWs. You can easily tar the lot of them with the same brush and file them under dickhead consumers, dickhead corporation. 

But hey, we want to build our future cities around dirty big toll roads going out 50km to outer-ring suburbs where people can drive to commute every day. What could possibly go wrong?

2014/07/06

News That's Fit To Punt - 05/Jul/2014

Semaphore Of Sociopaths

It's all about the message, and what message we're allegedly sending to people smugglers. So goes the theory in the continuing shit-storm that is the Coalition 'policy' towards asylum seekers.but sometimes we're not even sure that's where the message is going to or whether it's being received properly. It's a mystery as to how this government thinks communication theory functions.

The latest corker episode appears to be Scott Morrison ordering Tamil asylum seekers  from India, to Sri Lanka, In all honesty it's hard to fathom the depths of the kind of morally deficient mind as Scott Morrison who would surrender the said Tamils to the Sri Lankan authorities. It's a bit like happily offering up Jewish refugees from say, Sweden and repatriating them to Germany in 1944 or something. He's certainly not talking about what exactly was done and this government is hiding behind its usual "oh, this is a military operation so we need more secrecy" routine. Which is to say Scott Morrison is offering up the moral tenacity of a Sergeant Schultz who always insists he "knows nothing".

Weirder still, Mr. Morrison, it turns out, is going to Sri Lanka to attend a commissioning ceremony for some boats.  You really wonder how these people live with themselves.

Financial Mischief Writ Large

The business of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia offering up inappropriate financial advice because of its incentive laden program for their sales staff has turned into the eye sore issue for the Australian financial sector. First, there were the whistle-blowers who carefully leaked the secret to the corporate watchdog ASIC. ASIC then sat on its hands for 18months and failed to investigate. After which the anonymous whistle-blowers were forced to come forwards so that ASIC could get off its backside and investigate the mess. If the 18month delay was bad, the Senate hearings into ASIC have shown that ASIC and its personnel are too close to the banking industry it regulates, for it to be a proper watchdog - (which, it must be said was also said of the SEC in America after the Bernie Madoff Ponzi scandal).

So the ALP government drafted up legislation to stop this problem, but then the Coalition government has since watered it down at the behest of the lobby groups on behalf of the big banks. In the aftermath, the minister responsible for this area Mathias Cormann claimed that there were enough safeguards and the industry had changed substantially so that the legislation didn't need the safeguard that required financial advisers to offer responsible advice. He then went on to talk down the situation at the CBA as some kind of temporal anomaly when in fact the Senate investigation had identified the misplaced incentive as a systemic risk.

The upshot is that the CBA will be forced to cough up more money for is victims but it wants to control the process - which is a bit like letting criminals decide their own punishment in court. Once again, you wonder how these people live with themselves.

We Cut Health And Education To Buy These Toys

On of the crappiest investments our government has made over the last decade has been the F-35 JSF project. Not content with the money we've already spent helping to develop these planes, Tony Abbott pledged to actually spend even more to bring these planes over to Australia. The joke, - as it were - is on us because we're about to take delivery of some of these planes that barely work in a matter of weeks, and the whole fleet has been grounded due to engine problems.

The F-35 is like 'The Zap Gun' in Philip K. Dick's novel, where our civilisation comes up with increasingly unlikelier weapons systems to make a show of having come up with new exotic ways to kill and destroy. The paper specs of the F-35 is meant to put the fear of something ferocious into the hearts of America's enemies but the only thing it's really scaring are the bean counters who track the expenditure towards their development.

The nutshell of the problem is that they set out to deign a plane that fulfills the varied needs of the four service branches of America, each with their unique profiles. Some of these requirements were going to be mutually exclusive and contradictory. As it stands it doesn't seem to have passed any of the tests to be commissioned. Not even the US Marines who were most bullish about getting their F-35s commissioned is looking like they will succeed by the end of this year, as they had announced.

Thus I point to the fundamental waste that is the F-35 at a time when there is *allegedly* such need to cut government services. If we should be buying any warplanes, we should be buying the F-22. At least they work, and come in cheaper.

2011/07/16

Murdoch-Watching

Eminently Despicable

The first time I had to consider what it might be like to work for Rupert Murdoch was when I was in high school. My parents made friends with somebody who worked in newspapers for years and he was so kind as to invite our family over for lunch and regaled some interesting stories about the time he was a strapping young journalist and a young Rupert Murdoch turned up as the owner of the paper. According to the old journalist, Rupert was certain there was only the three 'esses' that could sell newspapers and they were Sex, Scandal and Sensation. When you think about it, one leads to the other and it's exactly the kind of bundle that Rupert Murdoch's muck-raking rags have long made an institution thereof. It seemed like a very cut-and-dry proposition, even for a kid like me - if a little vulgar. But you could see that that could be a style that worked with a vulgar public of which we could all count upon.

The second time I seriously had to consider Rupert Murdoch's style in the mid-90s when I popped over to Hong Kong for a short contract working for Star TV Japan. That too was an interesting business because once you're inside the Murdoch machine, you really do feel the cut-throat corporate culture of Murdoch's companies, right up against your nose. At the time it was a little contentious because I might have stayed on had they offered the contract with the terms I wanted, but at that point in history they were making a point of not handing out ex-pat deals, and so our negotiations hit the rocks pretty quickly. I was told they would play hardball, and I figured there was no point being polite about it, so in the end I flew back.

The third time I came across the Murdoch corporate culture was when I was working on a music project with an elaborate proposal and a business plan which ended up being presented to people in Lachlan Murdoch's orbit. It went nowhere as more and people attempted to pee in the same pot. Again, we came up against some hard-ball style negotiations and this time I sat back and watched as my colleagues wilted under the withering pressure. And I recognised the style from when I dealt with Star TV Japan.

All this is to say that even if you're just drifting along in the world, you can run into a lot of Murdoch enterprises and they're invariably crass, vulgar and promote a kind of idiotic dualism which makes you wonder if they are twisted Manicheans. What's really amazing is that nobody seems to tell Rupert how stupid this is and how he and his press organs are contributing the significant dumbing down of the public. But even if you could mention it, it would appear he would hardly listen, after all why should a man as powerful like Rupert Murdoch suffer such contrary opinions? What's infuriating is that because his papers spread fear and ignorance like black rats bringing the Bubonic plague, it finds converts everywhere, writing in ill-informed  comments on newspaper sites, arguing arcane right-wing paranoia shit.

Anyway, here's something in 'The Economist' which is interesting in the light of the recent developments.
One of the distinguishing features of News Corporation is aggression. The firm combines the heft of a big company with the scrappiness of a start-up. Even more than at other media firms, executives sometimes seem inspired by Machiavelli—or Richard III. Competitors are to be crushed. Executives in other companies that take an opposite view on strategic questions are idiots. In 2009 the usually cerebral James Murdoch launched a scathing attack on the BBC, whose size and zeal for expansion into new areas he described as “chilling”.

This take-no-prisoners approach makes the company extremely bold. It was News Corporation that broached the possibility of releasing films early on pay-television—a move that still enrages cinema owners. Together with the Financial Times (part-owner of this newspaper) it has led the charge to demand money for newspapers on the web. In America the firm drives a particularly hard bargain over payments from cable and satellite carriers for its broadcast network. BSkyB is a similarly brutal negotiator.

Unfortunately, this attitude earns the company enemies as well as revenues. Over the years News Corporation has offended governments and regulators. Its aggression and sheer size terrify rival media firms. In October 2010 the BBC and the owners of the Daily Mail, the Daily Telegraph, the Daily Mirror and the Guardian newspapers signed a letter opposing its bid to take complete control of BSkyB, in which it now has a 39% stake. Part of the reason News Corporation has handled the phone-hacking crisis so badly is that it tends to view hostile reporting as motivated by rivalry.

As the company braces for further embarrassment and disruption, it will also have to work out a future without BSkyB. Public and political opinion have become so hostile that the government may refuse to sign off on any attempt to renew the bid, even at the risk of a judicial review. This makes the transition News Corporation wants to make to a new, eventually post-Rupert world a lot harder.

You'd hate to be a News Corporation shareholder right now. The other part of the business, the newspapers themselves might be in for some stick too.
Frankly, Murdoch's political leverage has been spent. The era of media moguls bullying politicians is finished. It went down the plughole from the moment the Milly Dowler story broke and it has diminished further with each passing day. News Corp's leverage will be completely shot in the US if it is discovered its employees or agents have hacked the phones of the families of September 11 victims. The Justice Department has been asked by members of Congress to investigate that issue.

If the capacity to hold politicians to ransom is critically injured, what is the point of continuing to own newspapers that do not return a profit? That is the question which in the days and weeks ahead will open up some deep divisions in the upper reaches of the News Corp estate.

There are other possible violations to be weighed. If a subsidiary in London made illegal payments to police officers, that is a breach of US law.

This story is unravelling so fast that it's impossible to predict all the ramifications. Nick Davies, the Guardian journalist who has done so much to crack open this scandal, says Murdoch has lost control of the outcome. It now has a life of its own and to a very large extent markets, not oligarchs, will determine what happens.

What has risen so quickly to the surface is the deep dislike and resentment of Murdoch on the part of the political establishment. For years they had to fawn all over him, now they're pleased as Punch to be kicking him all the way down.

We can well imagine there would be much joy amongst the ranks of politicians. Somebody was describing somewhere - I can't find it now - that the British Parliament resembled a populace freed from tyranny once they realised they all hated the tyrant.

Paul Keating Says...

This one came in from Pleiades. It's a transcript of an interview with Paul Keating from Lateline on the 14th. It has several interesting portions on it covering Julia Gillard and the Carbon Pricing reforms, but while we're on the topic of Murdoch, he had this to say:
PAUL KEATING: Well there's one thing that's clear for sure comes out of this and that is self-regulation by the media is a joke. A joke. You know, I notice tonight John Hartigan talking about the Press Council of Australia. I mean, people shouldn't have a right to appeal about invasions of their privacy to some body funded by newspapers; they should have a right at law.

What we need, what we seriously need, which has been now recommended by the Commonwealth Law Reform Commission, the Victorian Law Reform Commission and the New South Wales Law Reform Commission is a separate right-of-action in privacy, a separate tort.

So in other words, you don't have a right of appeal to some body, you have a right to action, you have a right to the law. In the end, the only regulator of this bad behaviour is the law. And, this episode in Britain ...

TONY JONES: Well there's certainly no right to privacy in the law in Australia at this time. And in actual fact, at a broader level, it's sometimes said that privacy will be one of the great issues of our time, because of the internet, because of Facebook, Twitter, etc., etc. But it doesn't seem that there's any chance at the moment you're going to get a consensus on this. Could the Murdoch issue reflect into this debate in Australia?

PAUL KEATING: Well, I mean, Minister Conroy's now sitting on the Commonwealth Law Reform Commission report. Very reasonable recommendations. It basically says if you had a reasonable right to privacy and there are no public issues involved and they are infringed, you have a right of action at law.

For instance, those people in London who News International or the News of the World was asking the police to finger by their movements off their mobile telephone, those people had a reasonable right to believe that their free movement through London was their own affair, that they weren't to be tracked by the police via the telephone system for the benefit of a newspaper.

TONY JONES: But do you believe this sort of thing only happens in Britain? I mean, could it also have happened in Australia?

PAUL KEATING: It could have happened in Australia. In fact, your chief executive officer made the very same point in a speech a year or so ago. He - I brought the quotation in, which is a point.

He said that - Mark Scott, "With digital surveillance, location tracking and genetic tracing becoming commonplace, there's a very firm case for the law to allow people to protect their privacy." Correct. Correct.

TONY JONES: Let's talk about the politics of this with the time we've got left. Do you think Murdoch's News Limited is effectively at war with the Gillard Government?

PAUL KEATING: I think it's beyond doubt. I mean, when the Daily Telegraph yesterday is saying, "Let's have a national election," why do we need a national election? We have an operating - a clear operating majority in the House of Representatives, it's a stable majority, the business of the Government is reasonable business, that is the controversial matter is putting a price on carbon.

There is a consensus, it seems, in both Houses of Parliament for it. Why should there be an early election, other than the editors of that newspaper believing that were there to be an early election, the existing government would be defeated.

So this is why ministers are saying News Corporation is after - or News Limited is after regime change. You know, I think, you know, how can you read it any other way?

So there you have it. In a nutshell, our privacy could be law, but Stephen Conroy is just sitting on the report not doing anything. I'm sure Stephen Conroy's ears were stinging when he got a wind of that one. Anyway, it's also quaint to note that Paul Keating knows exactly what's going on over at News Corporation - they're after a 'regime change'. He always had a way with words.

Blog Archive