Showing posts with label ADF. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ADF. Show all posts

2014/11/27

A Laughable Editorial

You Wanted People To Vote Them In, Darren Goodsir

Defence Minister David Johnston is in a spot of bother this week - amidst all the other crappy developments for the Abbott Government, like FOFA and dropping the $7 co-payment - for having described the Australian Submarine Corporation as being incapable to even build a canoe. That might even be true, if coming from a legitimate standpoint of cost and process. After all, we can always point to the crown jewel of the ASC, the Collins class submarine.

All the same, Johnston is in a spot of bother because basically it indicates the Abbott government won't seriously consider the ASC as an option for developing the next generation submarines. Of course nothing this government does smacks of anything remotely like impartial, so it's not like Johnston is a singular fuck-up of a minister in a lineup of otherwise excellent ministers. He is merely a minor gaffe-making minister in a lineup of ideological idiots who are way in above their shrunken heads.

Still, the Sydney Morning Herald editor wants to take him to task!
Defence Minister David Johnston is hardly displaying the qualities needed to oversee the subs decision, let alone his department. 
Senator Johnston has embarrassed Australia's defence forces, potentially undermined national security and lost the confidence of South Australians by saying he didn't trust the government-owned ASC - formerly the Australian Submarine Corporation - to build a canoe. 
ASC is involved in building three air warfare destroyers for the navy and maintains the Collins class submarines. 
Perhaps such a "rhetorical flourish" - his words and those of Prime Minister Tony Abbott, not ours - could be excused if it were an isolated embarrassment.
But the minister's performance has been substandard. 
Mr Abbott eventually will reshuffle cabinet, when he tires of defending the indefensible.
For the sake of appearing strong and stable, a sense of arrogance lingers around this government. This week the Prime Minister repeatedly refused to admit he made a statement promising no cuts to the ABC and SBS.
Note, the interesting tone of discovery in the excerpt there. It is as if it comes to the editor Mr. Goodsir as a tremendous surprise that there should be a sense of arrogance lingering around this government. I mean, really Mr Goodsir, you noticed this now, and not when they were in opposition and dared to go through an entire election campaign without offering up red of their policy? Perhaps Mr. Goodsir didn't find this arrogant but merely strategic (or politic), but most sensible people knew full well then that arrogance would be the hallmark signature of an Abbott Government.

What really hurts, given that Mr. Abbott went on to win that 2013 election, is that the Sydney Morning Herald openly supported a change of government to this pack of arrogant imbeciles. Why? Because a change was better than more of the same. It was as if the editor did not consider the possibility of a change for the worse - which alas has come to pass. Were we Hobbits, we'd cast Mr. Goodsir into the open maws of Mt. Doom, but no. We're here in Australia, governed by people with the sensibility of Orcs.

So it gives me great pleasure writing once more, you wanted this mob Darren Goodsir. You can't be complaining about their performance this early in the piece, especially over some throwaway line. It's only been 14 months. There is much, much more of this arrogance and recklessness and contempt of the public as well as their ideological opponents, still to come. This whole shmozzle of 14months in power is merely the entrée, the aperitif if you will, of this lousy government - a government you wholeheartedly asked Australians to vote in. Why, these people can't even craft a budget that gets through the Senate, 6 months since Budget Night. Thank you of the fine recommendation. The pity is that I didn't follow such crap advice and still somehow ended up with this unhappiness-making government.

Behold the emptiness of media persuasion. I blame stupidity.

Apologia

I bagged out the teachers of Tony Abbott in my previous entry. It was a bit rough on my part. Those teachers - whatever their degree or depth of their faith - didn't exactly set about to shape the youth that turned into "Prime Minister Tony Abbott" in the manner that he turned out. Doubtless those fine men and women are shocked at how misshapen their product is, and just how much harm he is doing to their reputation as educators. For that I offer my sincere apologies for my offence and my condolences for their sorrow and regret.



2014/10/04

The Crappiness Of This New War

Nobody Expects The Spanish Inquisition

The old war of the 21st century, as in 'the Bush-Blair-Howard Misadventures In Iraq', (a.k.a. the Coalition Of The Unwitting Go To A Quagmire For A Bath) was characterised by a one-sided whup-ass of the industrially and technologically inferior Iraqi forces followed by years of door-to-door combat culminating in prisoner abuse at Abu Ghraib prison. If it was meant to be morally edifying - and war rarely is such a thing - then the 'BBHMII' was a thoroughly miserable travesty in the morality stakes. Then they pinned it on a woman with low IQ and whistled by in their black limos. All  of which reminds us of the tremendous Monty Python sketch. Just as the Inquisitors start with fear, surprise, ruthless efficiency, devotion to the Pope and red uniforms and then their claims degenerate in meaning, the 'BBHMII' started with Shock and Awe and eventually ended up with a brawling kind of war, the sort of which nobody could make any sense.

Then there is Guantanamo Bay prison where people are still kept without trial or warrants as somewhere between insane asylum of the 19th century and a torture chamber. Barack Obama came to power in 2008 promising to close the prison but of course it still exists today. One would think that Obama could easily and readily close that damnable institution by releasing all the prisoners with microchips in their skulls. At least the torture ought to end. The fact that it doesn't end is rather emblematic, and we come to realise Frank Zappa wasn't exactly kidding when he sang that Torture Never Stops. Yes, it's all been one long night of the iron sausage for all of us. It's hard to claim any moral ascendancy when what our side is offering is victimhood in a military prison in Cuba.

Now we're about to go back in and do it all over again, mostly because we can find even more moral revulsion in ISIL/ISOR than we could in Saddam Hussein. Not many people in parliament are expressing objections to the deep hypocrisy and great folly in going back to war in Iraq.

What we can deduce from all of this is that there are certain cultural tropes in our leadership and military that go right back to the Dark Ages, and despite our iPhones and internet connectivity and social media and Lady Gaga and Katy Perry freedoms, our leadership in war is ethically no better than the kind of medieval kings. It is no wonder that something claiming to be an Islamic State and a Caliphate becomes our opposite number and promptly started beheading people like this is the Fall of Constantinople, where the Ottomans fired chopped heads out of bronze canons. We are in essence replaying the nightmares of the past because it amuses us as entertainment in the news cycle.

They Think It's A Real Crusade, Not A Metaphorical One

Some weeks go I noticed ion Facebook that a couple of people with whom I went to school had served in Afghanistan (a.k.a 'The Other Crappy War of the 21st Century'). Couple of good old boys from Sydneys North Shore, 'Phil' and 'Potty' doing their bit for the cause of enduring freedom... I mean 'Operation Enduring Freedom'. There they were, one in the ADF as a soldier and the other as a chaplain. They were smiling like they were having a good time, and maybe they were on their boys' own adventure.

The bit that caught my eye was the big crucifix on the collar of the chaplain 'Potty', which got me thinking, was he walking around Kandahar or Kabul or wherever they were stationed in that uniform? Doubtless he was; and it struck me that he was the living walking talking crusader in a nation of Muslims, wearing that dirty big crucifix on his uniform - losing over the hearts that might have just been won over by our good efforts. It's like spending all the good will you're earning on the slot machine of faith.

How could the ADF not looked like a bunch of Crusaders come to the land of the muslims. It got me depressed. I understand that there are many religious people amongst our services and that they would require spiritual guidance in the business of shooting and killing people and still wanting to go to a Christian heaven (and I do mean that with the utmost ironic contempt). I pity the soldiers who would be getting this spiritual guidance from 'Potty' who in his days as a high school kid was about as emotionally evolved as a raging haemorrhoid; but be that as it may, it made me sick to the pit of my stomach that the ADF thought this was worth the effort.

So you can see I am really thrilled and excited about the prospect of sending 'boots on the ground'; and 'Potty' with them, to offer spiritual guidance to our Rampaging Crusading Christian Solders so they can still go through the eye of the needle into a Christian heaven having dispatched a bunch of Islamist Beheading Bastards to Allah. It's a great concept isn't it? When do they get to sack Jerusalem and fill the streets ankle deep in heathen blood? Looking forward to that in the news cycle!

No, really it's appropriate to say Jesus wept.

2014/02/27

Quick Shots - 26/Feb/2014

Manus Island Breakout

I've been busy writing a script. Yes. I'm a paid writer at the moment so I've been a little quiet on this front. It doesn't mean I haven't been following the news. This business on Manus Island is turning into something rather awful as messengers keep getting shot. At the crux of the issue is fundamentally how this government actually sees the role of government and how it fits into what we might call a democracy. That's right, we're actually seeing a coalition government that has very little tolerance for what it takes to be a democratic government save for the bit - the election - that got them in.

I guess we ought not to be surprised when the government subcontracts out the detaining of asylum seekers, then it also subcontracts out the security to private firms. And it should not surprise us that such firms might have far less ethical staff or formal procedures when compared to a government organ, and that it should lead to mishandling a population like the detainee asylum seekers. What is worse is perhaps that the minister of immigration Scott Morrison would lie to us about the status of Manus Island and its riot. There is no other way of putting it. He made announcements to effect that were otherwise to information that he had already obtained. This is lying - in spite of Scott Morrison's protestations to be otherwise. Worse still has been the general lack of transparency about the whole handling of asylum seekers, which admittedly not a new problem with this government but a fundamental philosophical one.

All this culminated in ALP Senator Stephen Conroy accusing General Angus Campbell as aiding a cover-up. The furore has been rather telling. Today, the Defence department chief David Hurley came out swinging in defence of Campbell. Now, the Coalition are carrying on as if some great offence has been made by Stephen Conroy. You sort of worry about how the Coalition sees the military because they're essentially using the privilege of the military operations to say "we can't tell you what we're doing." The problem with this is that it places the military out of reach of proper scrutiny. Worse still, the Coalition Government's accountability is taken away with it, so there's really no telling what this government is doing, but no, they're not telling. They are effectively saying the chain of command of the ADF stops at the Prime Minister's office for him to use at his leisure. This should be constitutionally debatable - not that anybody would bother - but it should be debated.

To add insult to injury the same government wants to break custom and break open the cabinet papers from the Rudd Gillard government so there is absolutely no quid pro quo there; worse still, they *only* do things that suit themselves for no good reason other than it suits themselves.  I can't think of a dirtier modus operandi than that, and if that's not anti-democratic, I don't know what is. But I digress.  The more salient thing is that the Coalition Government has adopted the military chain of command and military protocol as its defence for not being held accountable to the Senate of the land. This is a bit like ancient Rome on the eve of the Triumvirates. You could make a cartoon of Senator Publius Conrus in a toga summoning Consul Claudius Morrisus to account on the Senate floor and Claudius Morrisus says he cannot discuss the said matter because it would affect the operations of General Pompei Campbellius in North Africa against the pirates at sea. In fact that's exactly what it is, and what we're seeing is the Coalition Government actively trying to limit the control of military from the Senate.

I can't tell you how disturbing this is, because any time you cut the military loose from government control like this, it sets a precedent. A precedent which will be abused at some point in the future, even if there is not much harm today. I understand David Hurley's protestations but he is *wrong*. This *is* a problem for Australia and Senator Conroy is correct in asking General Campbell whether the ADF is politically in bed with the Liberal National Party to such a degree that it would take such military operations out of the purview of the Australian Senate.  History is full of military operations done outside of government purview that turn into major political disasters. The Japanese Kwantung Army in Manchuria in the 1930s was such an entity that refused to be accountable to the Diet of Japan. The 1960s CIA is such an organ that created the conditions for the Bay of Pigs and in a roundabout way brought about the Cuban Missile Crisis. The rise of the Triumvirate in ancient Rome was exactly this problem, where the Roman army ended up being a privatised organ of ambitious citizens. It killed their republic - which in fact might jive well with Tony Abbott's anti-Republican position.

Which is to say (and jokes aside), not only is this Coalition Government not very well versed in science, it appears it is not very well versed in history. And where it seems to discount scientific findings with spurious and casual disdain, it would also ignore lessons of history at its peril. In that light, I can't say I'm impressed with Defence Department chief David Hurley or the other indignations hurled at Stephen Conroy for his remarks by Tony Abbott and company.

Now be that as it may, Stephen Conroy is still a nincompoop in my books. It pains me to defend him. But that's the nature of having truth on your side - it's defensible to be truthful. Morrison and his lies are not defensible in any way shape or form. The endorsement that at least Morrison is not a wimp from Tony Abbott, is a bit like claiming the best asset of Maria Sharapova's tennis game is her grunt. It amazes me that the Coalition don't worry about things like the truth or facts; instead they worry about form. They just seem to love it when they can push the envelope of hypocrisy as far as it can be pushed, if it looks good to them and their punters. I really worry about the mental health of people who think this is a good government or for that matter better government than they were getting under the Rudd-Gillard ALP.

Blog Archive