2024/07/17

The Wowsers' Parade

Precious D

Thanks to my dear sister, I was at the Tenacious D show on Sunday night where they celebrated Kyle Gass' birthday. When presented with a cake and asked to make a wish, Kyle Gass quipped "Don't miss Trump next time". 

And now it's a furore as Jack Black threw Kyle under the bus and cancelled the tour.  

In a new development, Gass has also been dropped by his talent agency, Greene Talent, with rep Michael Greene telling TMZ they have parted ways due to the incident. 
In an Instagram post on Tuesday night, Black said the tour had been called off and suggested the incident had caused a major falling out with Gass. 
“I was blindsided by what was said at the show on Sunday. I would never condone hate speech or encourage political violence in any form,” Black stated. 
“After much reflection, I no longer feel it is appropriate to continue the Tenacious D tour, and all future creative plans are on hold. I am grateful to the fans for their support and understanding.”
Yikes. While I was there, I did not see that development coming. At the show, the moment came and went and some people guffawed and they just moved on to the next song. 

By the way, it was a really cool show, so I do feel for the good people of Newcastle who won't get to see it. 

Tendentious K

In all the fucked up commentary, the weirdest might be Kevin Rudd weighing in.
“It makes me feel sick someone would joke about violence. Physically ill,” he told news.com.au. 
“People might think it’s a bit of ‘funny haha’ at a concert to run off at the mouth off about this stuff.  
“It’s not,” he said.
That's really insane. Did we ask for his input? I guess that's what you get from news.com.au. He's in Minnesota, as Australia's ambassador to the USA. The gig was a bunch of Americans playing a show in Sydney. One of them makes a bad joke and it turns into this kind of commentary?:
“It’s about threats to physical life; it’s about the near assassination of a former and prospective President of the United States, depending on the votes of the American people.  
“It’s about the murder of innocent civilians and two people being seriously wounded. 
“These people need to grow up and find a decent job”.
Good heavens, right back at you Kev. Please - you go find a decent job, Kevin - for fuck's sake. 

God only knows why he was asked to comment. It seems to lack programmatic specificity if you ask me. If we all felt sick to the pits of our stomach every time somebody told a black-humoured joke, Gastroenterologists the world over would be rich as Steve Ballmer.

Then There Are Idiots Like These
   
Who the hell is Ralph Babet?  Turns out he's from the United Australia Party. God our democracy sucks sometimes. 
Senator Ralph Babet has demanded the federal government deport American rock band Tenacious D, after one of its members appeared to joke at a Sydney concert about Donald Trump’s attempted assassination.

"I call on the prime minister Anthony Albanese to join me in denouncing Tenacious D, Jack Black and band member Kyle Gass, and I call on the immigration minister Andrew Giles to revoke their visas and deport them immediately."
Stupid as 6 squirrels in a condom. Imagine going to the High Court arguing in front of the justices that somebody should get deported for telling an off-colour joke. 

I guess all the nut job rightists are currying favour with the incoming Donald Trump Administration they're imagining. 








2024/07/15

Quick Shots 15/Jul/2024

The Difference Between A Disaster And Catastrophe

The old joke in Latin America  goes like this. El Presidente visits a school. He asks the class if the children know the difference between a disaster and a catastrophe. A child raises his hand and answers "Yes, El Presidente. If you and your cabinet should be in an air accident, that is a disaster. Should you survive that air accident, that is a catastrophe." 

And so that joke sprung to mind when a bullet scraped Donald Trump and did not kill him. 

For the assassin to have fired and missed, is the worst of the three outcomes of not having fired at all, and having fired and successfully killed. 

RIP Shannen Doherty (12 April 1971 - 13 July 2024)

She wasn't even my type of actress or celebrity. She was memorable because she was on a TV show that defined an epoch.  She was a public figure who was neither one thing or another for me, despite her reputation for being troublesome and quarrelsome. It seemed like you needed somebody like that to place a tough Californian chick, so that was par for the course. Even so, she wasn't Brenda Walsh for nuthin'. 

The more people like that pass away, the more you feel the passing of time. She is decidedly a very Gen-X figure.  


2024/07/14

The Unbearable Lightness of My Wallet

The Money Loop

I've been pondering the phenomenon of sky high valuations of stocks. Way back before the GFC in the late 1990s, valuations hit a historic high and P/E ratios blew out. Then the tech bubble burst. Investors then decided that it was better to put their money into bricks and mortar, and so that led to some interesting financial engineering with mortgage bonds, and this led to a property boom that turned out to be unsustainable. That bottoming out was the GFC. And here we are again with sky high valuations on stocks. It seems we're due for another downward correction that wipes out a whole lot of real world capital formations. What's interesting this time is that P/E ratios have blown out to the high 20s for Google, Apple, Meta, Amazon and nVidia. And nobody is headed for the door before the bubble bursts. 

But then I was thinking about my superannuation account. I have it set on 100% Foreign High Growth Shares, This is because it's the easiest way to get exposure to things like the US Tech sector or Chinese manufacturing or whatever else grows in valuation like mushrooms. Every so often my employers deposits a percentage and my fund then goes out there and buys these high growth shares for me. I certainly don't imagine I'm alone - in fact the odds are pretty good that just about everybody in Australia with their superfund has exposure to these shares. And as long as there is such a thing as superannuation, the money's just going to keep dropping on these shares. Michael Burry is right, there's not going to be any price discovery on these shares any more, with all these funds shoring up the prices. Maybe that is why these sky high valuations can continue, because it's not about rational investment any more, but just passive investors outnumbering the active investors. 

In Australia at least, there is this strange loop of money. You go to the supermarket and you get price-gouged. The corporate profits bump up the share price of the supermarkets, and if you have your superannuation invested in say the ASX500, this is good for you. In a weird way, if the big end of town gouges us and scores huge profits, we still get some benefit out of that if our superannuation is in Australian Shares. The gouging becomes like an extra tax that somehow turns into an extra pension down the track for the citizen. 

Corporate Profits

Corporate Profits keep climbing. This is in spite of the cost of living going up and people not having enough money to get by. Spending is down, and the economy is teetering on a recession every time you turn on the news. Just because people's disposable income shrinks, it doesn't mean the companies looking after food and utilities don't make a ton of money. 

The Australian Treasury has something interesting to say about our Gini Coefficient.

Income inequality has remained relatively steady since 2007–08, with the Gini coefficient for equivalised household disposable income sitting at 0.32 in 2019–20. In 2020, Australia’s Gini coefficient for income indicated that Australia had the 14th highest level of inequality of the 28 OECD countries for which data was available for that year.1

Wealth is typically distributed less equally than income. Wealth inequality has remained steady over time, with the Gini coefficient for wealth increasing marginally from 0.60 in 2007–08 to 0.61 in 2019–20.

That's surprising. I did not expect that, and I wonder how they derived that figure. It suggests that if you are in the property market, it's all just musical chairs. You don't beat the market by buying somewhere special. It doesn't matter how much you're paid because chances are, you're just in the median and you make no impact on the Gini Coefficient. It's weird. We might be earning double what we used to earn, but that money has exactly half of the buying power it used to have, so your place in the pecking order hans't changed at all. It's actually hard to deliver a scenario where a first world citizenry can be better off by voting somebody in or out. 

This corresponds to the sobering reality that over the last 14 years since 2010, prices of goods have roughly doubled, and so has my salary. I don't feel a significant increase in my purchasing power at all. The ALP government is crowing about delivering tax cuts but in reality, they're making small changes to adjust my purchasing power to be roughly in line with the historic norm. This leads me to the next point.

Interest Rates Discourse Is Bunkum

During the 20 year lead up to the pandemic I came to the notion that interest rates were being artificially held down. This is because the Central Banks decided to favour investments and asset price rises over stability or equality. This resulted in the housing bubble, and in turn skewing the economy in such as way as to suck the oxygen out of the rest of the economy that has nothing to do with real estate or mining. When Vladimir Putin started his offensive against Ukraine in February 2022, while the world's economy was still emerging from the Covid Pandemic, inflation shot up and Central Banks have been running high interest rates ever since. 

The central banks do this in the name of stopping inflation, however if we the people are largely spending the same in the Gini Coefficient, is it really the local consumer pushing up prices through heated demand? Clearly it's anything but the local consumer. So all this talk of taming inflation through raising interest rates ignores the fact that inflation isn't coming from the people the higher interest rates are imposed upon.   If people are spending roughly the same portion of their disposable income on the same things in the same way they always did, then raising interest rates on them probably isn't going to change demand. 

It runs counter to the narrative that if you raise interest rates, it takes money out of people's pockets in such a way as to bring down demand and therefore inflation. They can argue - and have argued - that this is necessary, but the unchanged Gini Coefficient of Australia tells you it's not likely to change any time soon. Arguably, it's all Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping's fault we have the inflation. Why do ordinary citizens have to pay out of pocket to quell this damned inflation? With what raising interest rates costs our society, it might be cheaper to assemble a hit team to assassinate Vladimir Putin and end that lousy war in Ukraine. That might send a message to Xi Jinping to get back in the box. 

It is entirely possible that the reason inflation came down from the peak of 7.8% is because international supply chains were re-built and re-affirmed in the last 18months, and had nothing to do with the 13 interest rate hikes in 15 months. It might have been because of the corporate greed disguising their price rises as something caused by inflation, because let's face it - there have been record profits in a time marked by great cost increases.   

Just for reference, here's this discussion over in the USA about the same topic:

It's so on the money, Jon Stewart had to give up his Apple+ show over this one. 

Larry Summers: "Do you feel that Apple are somehow gouging or doing something wrong?" 

Jon Stewart: "Yes"

And right there, Jon Stewart is asked to bite the hand that feeds him that day, and he takes a solid chunk. 

Yet it needed to be said to make a point. It's not that Larry Summers is a bad guy for taking the Central Bank line - it's all the wisdom he has at his disposal. It's just that the entire discourse is fucked, as Stewart demonstrates. Apple's valuation going up USD 4000 for every American is nice for Apple. It's not like that USD 4000 rise goes immediately into people's pockets to be used. At best it goes towards people's retirement if their 401Ks have Apple shares. If Apple is indeed gouging while people are losing their homes due to interest rates going up in response to global events they can't control, then there's no real moral defence for that disparity. 


2024/07/10

Unfortunate Developments in Music

Why Does The AI Get To Do Music?

 Absurdly, there are AI platforms that basically do art and music and your homework for you. You type in some prompts and out pops the product of a million things mangled and distilled for your liking. It's created a weird world where you might enjoy your creative pursuits but your output is insignificant next to the power of AI to just endlessly create stuff. Some of it is okay, some of it is interesting, some of it is awful and some of it is disturbing. AI music, is firmly in the disturbing camp

There's already a great quote out there saying we want AI to do the washing and laundry so that we can do the music and art; not for the AI to do the creative stuff we enjoy and in the process tug us out of our domain. It bears repeating if for no other reason that we should not lose perspective on how exactly it is that AI has come to do these creative pursuits. Pertaining to music AIs, the simple answer is that the AI Tech stole the music in order to teach their algorithms what recorded music was, and how these genres and subgenera were meant to sound. Now the labels are suing them and rightfully so. Looked at from the label's point of view, the AI Tech people have basically sampled everything and are using it to create infinite numbers of remixes. That's not going to fly. 

We'll see how all that goes. If the labels win, well, that's how the music industry's always been and if a bunch of techno bros thought they were going to bust copyright this way, they had another thin coming. If the AI Tech Bros win, I think that is going to be the final nail in the music industry. It's hard to imagine because right now nobody is exactly saying their favourite music is AI music - but you just wait and see. If the AI Tech bros win, then it's going to be a free for all - and as usual the Indie musician will lose out. 

Spotify Is Probably Going Broke

In the last year, Spotify decided it would not pay out to the small end of town. If an artist doesn't have regular listeners, they won't get paid for plays on their songs on Spotify. They set a threshold and it's 100 listens from at least 500 unique listeners. The reason they cited for doing this was to make it easier to do the accounts. It's been the talk of the virtual town square for many months now. The new regimen came into effect in April. And just like that, the small indie artists and all the experimental types were cut out.  

It's understandable on one level because they would save a lot of money if they didn't have to figure out royalties for all the minnows of the music world. At the same time, not paying people for their music being played is pretty indefensible from a copyright point of view. 

The other thing that's surfaced recently is that Spotify itself makes and publishes its own AI music. They're short, but they fill airtime. Increasingly, they are put out under fake IDs pretending to be indie artists, and in turn, it earns a portion of the money pool back to Spotify. And that makes you wonder, if Spotify wants to have its hand in the till to draw some of that cashflow into its own coffers, they must be doing it hard. it's one thing to steal from defenceless indie artists who can organise and sue Spotify, but it's another thing to be siphoning off money from the pool of money that's supposed to be share with the labels and their artists.

All this leads me to think that Spotify ain't making real coin at all. And if it keeps going this way, it's going to keel over and die when nobody invests in this Ponzi scheme anymore. 

Jimi Was Broke

There was an article doing the rounds this week about how Pete Townshend ran into Jimi Hendrix just before he died. When asked how he was doing, Jimi replied he was broke. Townshend then went on to tell the story of how he too was shortchanged by Kit Lambert and Chris Stamp. Kit Lambert stole the money from The Who's earnings and bought a place in Venice. 

It's kind of strange because Jimi Hendrix also built Electric Ladyland Studios, so it seems a bit odd that he would say he was broke. He had a world class recording studio but he was also broke. Go figure. 

The issue of money and music seems to be eternal. Mozart didn't exactly become rich writing 41 symphonies and all those crowd pleasing operas.  Bach and Beethoven didn't exactly become millionaires on the back of their music even though together with Mozart, they're the most famous and influential German composers. I don't think Chopin died wealthy, nor did Schumann. Liszt and Brahms died wealthy but they seem the exception. Even in the classical world, the baseline is you don't make a whole lot of money doing music. And that's okay. 

The vaunted connection between fame and fortune are not that well entwined when it comes to music. The fact that Spotify severs that connection for the average indie musician is kind of mean - but maybe that's just what people should expect from a tech enterprise? You weren't making a gajillion bucks on Spotify anyway. We should ask ourselves what Jimi would have said about all this. 



2024/07/07

Glory Of Democracy

The Fallout From The UK Election

It's interesting watching the aftermath of the Tories getting the boot. Just as the LNP Coalition got a firm rebuke from the electorate, the boot that go planted in the rear of Rishi Sunak's government was pretty decisive. The prevailing opinion seems to be that the combination of BoJo the Clown and his party-in-a-time-of-Covid scandal, together with Liz Truss' historically disastrous 49 day term as Prime Minister sunk the conservative vote. That might be underselling the impact of Brexit and the mishandling of the COVID  pandemic on top of the cuts made to NHS that made the entire experience much more miserable than it needed to be. 

I don't know how the UK conservatives come back from this defeat. Then again, I don't know how Peter Dutton and the Liberal Party have come back in the opinion polls after their defeat in 2022, given that he is peddling nuclear power as the panacea. Maybe in one election cycle's time, the Tories will be back peddling some insane nonsense and somehow be competitive in the polls. These things are unknowable given that we're already well down the road to Idiocracy. Stupid is more prevalent than ever before. Even though the Tories got thrown out resoundingly, there's every chance that Starmer's is a one-term Labour government. The Murdochs would be on a mission to make it so, one imagines. 

One can only hope that the Tories got thrown out because it became painfully obvious that conservatism had no place in dealing with the world as it is today. 

China Laughing At The Presidential Debate

If the debate had every progressive on the planet running for the hills, then there's one nation that took immense delight in the debate - China. From their point of view, America has a choice between the demented Biden and the psychopathic Trump. They can't laugh enough at how weak and stupid democracy is as a system. I get their point of view. After all, it must be reassuring to know they are stuck with Xi Jinping as their dictator because hey it beats having an actual debate on anything. 

For my two cents, this is exactly what is wrong with China. China's never had a proper election. Its people have never had to stare at stark choices like a demented Biden versus a psychopathic Trump. A Boris Johnson versus Jeremy Corbin. Or closer to home, a manic Mark Latham and a closet-fascist John Howard. A rebounding Kevin Rudd versus an unhinged Tony Abbott. A voter has to think about these choices and weigh them up. They might resort to just ideology or family tradition or a mountain of prejudices, but think, they must. 

When I think about the candidates I voted for in a bid to remove John Howard's government from office and the decade it took to see him gone, I can tell you each and every vote was important. It might have looked hopeless to have Kim Beazley or Simon Crean or Mark Latham as the choice against Howard, but our democracy survived those moments. We, the Australian people negotiated those terrible choices. Democracy is great, even when your side loses. In the voting booth, your vote feels puny in the face of whatever electoral reality is swirling around you, but everybody's vote counts. We the people, can - and must - own every outcome from all these elections, the good, the bad, and the ugly. 

So right now America has a choice between Biden and Trump, and that looks really bad. Sure. Yet there are ructions to say the Democrats might want somebody else that is not Biden. As bad as the optics were from the Presidential debate, democracy has every chance for renewing itself. We may not be having Biden representing the Democrats in November. Hope springs eternal. The Chinese have no such hope. They are indeed hopeless on this front. 

So I say Glory be to Democracy. 

 


2024/07/05

News That's Fit To Punt - 05/Jul/2024

Tories No More

As an outsider, I always wondered how the Conservative Government could keep going on in the UK since 2010. It seemed to become a worse government every year, and somehow managed to hold on longer than some other good governments around the world. 14 years is a long time since Gordon Brown. Keir Starmer and his Labour party defeated the Conservatives by one of the largest landslides in UK electoral history and will form government. 

How long is 14 years? From an Australian standpoint, it's longer than the 11 years of John Howard's Liberal government and 13 years of the Hawke-Keating governments of the ALP. It's a shit of along time to be captives to a bunch of clowns that would do such terrible things as the Post-GFC Austerity, Brexit, the Covid Pandemic, Boris Johnson as Prime Minister, and followed by Liz Truss and Rishi Sunak in that role. 

It feels like there have been more British Prime Ministers than there have been Dr. Whos in the last 15 or so years. Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II died on their watch, although it's hard to pin that on them, maybe there's something to that anyway. After all, imagine the despair of the late Queen in her dying days when she was presented with a freshly minted Prime Minister Liz Truss. The Truss Prime Ministership, though blindingly short, was enough to drive many to an early grave.

Theres' something in all of that which mirrors the Australian experience from 2010 to 2022. Perhaps if there is a future where history is read, the 2010s will be remembered as the decade when conservatism as a whole got found out to be rather wanting in addressing the needs of the people worldwide. ("Tony Abbott, Scott Morrison and Peter Dutton walk into a pub. The bartender says 'what is this? Some kind of joke?'")

I'm sure Starmer's government will fumble a few things and accidentally drive into the ditch of scandals, but on the whole, that is probably going to be the lesser of two evils when compared to the abject misrule by the Tories through the 2010s and halfway through the 2020s. 

Maybe The Truth Is Dawning On People?

I wrote in recent days of just what a detriment having the Hamas leadership has harmed the people of Gaza. There are finally reports this notion is burgeoning in the very people of Gaza. 

Open criticism of Hamas has been growing in Gaza, both on the streets and online.

Some have publicly criticised Hamas for hiding the hostages in apartments near a busy marketplace, or for firing rockets from civilian areas.

Residents have told the BBC that swearing and cursing against the Hamas leadership is now common in the markets, and that some drivers of donkey carts have even nicknamed their animals after the Hamas leader in Gaza - Yahya Sinwar - urging the donkeys forward with shouts of "Yallah, Sinwar!"

“People say things like, ‘Hamas has destroyed us’ or even call on God to take their lives,” one man said. 

“They ask what the 7 October attacks were for - some say they were a gift to Israel.”

Some are even urging their leaders to agree a ceasefire with Israel.

There are still those in Gaza fiercely loyal to Hamas and after years of repressive control, it’s difficult to know how far the group is losing support, or how far existing opponents feel more able to speak their mind.

Yes, the 7th October 2023 attacks essentially handed a big bat to the Israelis and they are taking their hacks. I didn't think anybody in Gaza saw it that way - seeing that the Pro-Palestinians the world-over are working very hard not to see it that way - so this is refreshing. Maybe it will be seed of realism instead of endless idealism? Who knows?

The God I Got Old Moment 1,000,001

At some point, the world ceases to be about what your generation's causes might be. Then we become old men yelling at clouds or Karens in the carpark being annoying. 

This article weirded me out. 

 What weirded me out was that it's written by a guy who wants to discuss feminism and how it is failing to win over young men. I mean, come on. It's not that the men are alienated - it's that they're disenfranchised. They got disenfranchised to give women access. Society used to rob Peter to pay Paul, but feminism made it so Peter AND Paul got robbed to pay Mary. Is this good? Is this better for the world? It's certainly been better for women, ergo in a zero-sum game for social capital, it's worse for men. However in an important way, it spreads the GDP pie better doing it this way, and certainly having women in the workforce participating at all levels has made the economy grow. It's not just an issue of social justice.  

What makes me feel old is that this process has been going on for a good 50-60 years but somebody wants to describe this as alienation and as something new for a new upcoming generation. I never understood the men who embraced feminism so actively on campus, but I figured it was a sophisticated line of chat to get laid more than being a boorish, un-reconstructed sexist pig.    

There have been experiments that show even monkeys know when they've been treated unfairly and they respond badly. It's not surprising 60% of boys have picked up on something they think is unfair. I don't think they're right to feel put out, but I can see why they feel put out. And that, makes me feel old. 


2024/07/04

View From The Couch - 04/Jul/2024

Payman Quits ALP

 And just like that, Fatima Payman quits the ALP, pointing fingers. 

She said she was "deeply torn" over the decision and continued to believe in the principles of the Labor Party, but felt she could see "no middle ground" that would allow her to remain in the party.

"On one hand, I have the immense support of the rank and file [Labor party] members, the unionists, the lifelong members, the party volunteers who are calling on me to hang in there and to make change happen internally," she said.

"On the other hand, I am pressured to conform to caucus solidarity and toe the party line.

"My conscience leaves me no choice," she said.

Ha. There's that word conscience again. 

So the way she sees it, there's the rank and file, unionists and activists all asking for her to stay, and grit her teeth and gut it out for the good cause, and then there's her conscience that says she can't toe the party line. 

Farknell. Good riddance. The ALP is better without her. and I'm not even a rank and file member. I mean, what would Paul Keating say in the dunny behind Old Parliament House.  

You know what popped into my mind? This: 


The first rule of party politics is to toe the line and keeping it elegant. Otherwise you're just rabble. Or 'Campus Trots' as Albo calls them. If you can't do it like Penny Wong, you shouldn't be there. If Fatima Payman really had a conscience, she should quit the Senate altogether but hey, six years in Parliament gets you that fat pension so she'll stay on. Her vaunted conscience won't extend there, I'm pretty sure.  

What a blight on our country.  

Deep In Muslim Territory

I live in Jason Clare's seat of Blaxland. His office is just around the corner from where I live. There are a lot of muslims here and now they're organising into something to protest the ALP's allegedly weak position on Palestine. 

This bit made me laugh:

Asked if a shift away from Labor could end up getting a Coalition government elected, Sheikh Charkawi said it was about punishing Labor.

"The community doesn't want a Liberal government either.

"And there could be an unintended consequence. 

"But ultimately, if you don't participate, and if you don't effectively flex to show the power of your vote, how will they ever take your vote seriously?"

So, the kind of bloody-minded thinking that would beggar they neighbours and take the world into a hellhole with Palestine, is going to organise to sabotage the ALP in this electorate, even if it gets a Liberal Party member elected. I can assure you this area is full of this kind of low civility, but even this kind of 'thinking' takes the cake. It's not the-enemy-of-an-enemy being a friend. They don't care that the enemy-of-an-enemy is going to rule over them as an enemy, as long as they do in their own enemy. They would cut off their noses to spit their face, cut off their dicks to spite their balls. It's insane out here. Jason Clare had better watch out! 

On second thoughts maybe not. Nobody in the Muslim Vote party would ever toe the line because their conscience won't let them.

Some Other Thoughts on Gaza

The Philistines of old lived in Gaza. 


Yup, that's it right there in red. 

2024/07/03

Who Pays Payman? Who Pays Out On Payman?

Caveats To Today's Discussion, Lest I Be Tarred

Before I get on with this today, I just want to make clear that:

  • I am not a Zionist
  • I am not Jewish
  • I do not support Binyamin Netanyahu, or his government
  • I think what is happening in Gaza, free of context, is a terrible thing; 
  • ...and I think that the IDF response is disproportionate.

That said... 

Exile On Federation Mall

This business of West Australian senator Fatima Payman who crossed the floor to vote with the Greens in support of Palestinian statehood, is eating up a lot of airtime. On Sunday she was interviewed and said she'd do it again if the issue came up again. In response the Prime Minister summoned her to The Lodge and told her she's now excluded from Caucus until further notice. Albo can't outright expel her from the party because damnit, they need that vote in the Senate. So exiled out of Caucus it is, and Albo ends up looking weak. The ALP strategists must be having some heaving indigestion over this one. 

The ALP is in a bit of a pickle. The offical line is that the ALP supports a two-state solution so Senator Hayman voting to support a Palestinian statehood is not against the policy. It's just that she's flying in the face of ALP rule where everybody takes collective action. You can't go it alone with policy positions. Them's the rules. So the ALP finds itself admonishing the person standing up for what they allegedly hold as their offical position. 

The reason why the ALP doesn't commit to this position is because Hamas holds power in the Gaza strip,  and as far as anybody can tell Hamas is a terrorist organ more than a credible government. The ALP would like to support a normal state for Palestine but they don't want to be supporting Hamas, or for that matter lend any legitimacy. The gap, as it were between the ideal of a Palestinian state that behaves like a state and Hamas is so large nobody is willing to stick to their ideals. If anything the events of 7 October 2023 have put a big fat underline under this problem.  

If Senator Payman doesn't want to roll with the realpolitik that's her business but she shouldn't be surprised she's the one that's out on her own. 

The Business of Voting With Your Conscience

Penny Wong sort of admonished her colleague by pointing out that she had to vote with the party against her own wishes during the debate for gay marriage. Fatima Payman retorted that process took 10 years and the Gazans did not have 10 years. I beg to differ - they have had 70 years to come to some peace agreement over there, but they have not- and it's not incumbent upon the Australian Parliament to make that happen. But that is by the by. 

I guess the best way to interpret this is that if you draw false equivalences, you can expect to be shot down. Senator Payman also cited 40,000 casualties in that quip to underline how dire the situation is in Gaza - and let us all properly state it and leave no ambiguity, what the government of Israel is doing in the Gaza strip is terrible. However, what exactly we call that kind of loose acceptance of civilian casualties by the Israeli military, is highly contestable. Is it genocide? It certainly seems like War Crimes; but I'll come back to that one too. 

If we are indeed playing the conscience game, I would like to hear something about those killed on 7th October 2023, which prompted this mess. What troubles me about Senator Payman and those who support her defiance is that on the face of it, we have no accounting of what the Hamas-led Palestinian militants did to buy the violent response from Israel. If the argument is that there should be a two state solution, and therefore there should be recognition of a Palestinian state, then surely that Palestinian state should be held to account for its violent actions. I don't really detect there to be that kind of consideration coming from that camp. 

So Much For Having Labor Values

It's disingenuous at best to claim having core Labor values when you cross the floor. It's more contradictory and self-defeating. 

Speaking afterwards, Payman said she crossed the floor to represent the core values of the Australian Labor Party — equality, justice, fairness and advocacy for the voiceless and the oppressed.

"I walked with my Muslim brothers and sisters who told me they have felt unheard for far too long," she said.

"And I walked with the people of Palestine, for the 40,000 killed, for the hungry and scared boys and girls who now walk alone without their parents and for the brave men and women who have to walk alone without their children.

"I walked for humanity. I am proud of what I did today and am bitterly disappointed that my colleagues do not feel the same way."

Ah yes. So if that's enough for her to cross the floor, then it begs the question just how much she understands these so-called Labor values, given that the Labor party by definition has always been the collective action party. I mean, hello. Has she not read much Marx and Engels? The moment she chose to walk with her Muslim brothers and sisters across that floor, she abandoned her ALP bothers and sisters. She put her Muslim identity above that of the political party that delivered her to Federal Parliament. She can't spin this as being faithful to true Labor Party values when she clearly states she put something else that's not the Labor Party above the party line. 

Frankly that line of reasoning is a Liberal thing to be arguing - as in Capital 'L' The Liberal Party. If she can't toe the collective line come hell or high water, she's no Labor Party faithful. Please let's not delude ourselves into thinking otherwise. As for this threat of muslim votes being organised to oust Labor from safe seats, you have to say, maybe they're just conservatives who can't get a look in because they're also not white people. 

Honestly, she should quit the ALP. She hasn't got the right stuff, and she even has the wrong stuff. 

Does 40,000 Amount To A Genocide?

If you read history, you get inured to the suffering of other people. People suffer in history, wherever it took place. Worse still, nobody cries for Carthage in 2024. Cities got razed. they got bombed, and flattened, a couple even got nuked. Cities like Dresden, Osaka and Tokyo lost hundreds of thousands in a night. Nobody calls those moments a genocide because World War II served up 6 million Jews as the number that delineates what genocide looks like. Like it or lump it, 6 million is the benchmark. Nobody looks at Dresden and the 120,000 that perished that night and calls it a genocide of Germans. Nobody looks at the 120,000 lost in a flash at Nagasaki and calls that a genocide. So by this historic scale, if 120,000 Palestinians perished at the hands of the Israelis, it might not be a genocide yet. 

So much for the 40,000 casualties forming an argument that says there is a genocide going on, but that's if you're a reader of history. It turns out that for lawyers, the bar for proving genocide is actually pretty high. 

The bar for proving that a genocide has occurred is “so high,” said Cohen, the law professor. The ICJ has previously said that crimes that may be abhorrent, such as those constituting ethnic cleansing, do not automatically fall under the definition of genocide, he added.

A. Dirk Moses, an expert on genocide at the City College of New York, said the legal definition of genocide “is extremely stringent and narrow” and added that he is “skeptical” it can be “a tool for recourse for those that are suffering mass violence.”

The definition was set “not by the victims but by states, to ensure that the law cannot be used against them in meeting or confronting security threats,” he said.

We really should stop bandying around that word genocide like it has any relevance to what is going in Gaza. And that very situation out there, brings us back to the need for a proper state, and not a terrorist organisation to be ruling Gaza. I do feel sorry for the people of Gaza getting bombed. I feel sorry for those being used as human shields - Hamas is so ruthless and spinelessness at the same time, it would hide behind their own women and children to force larger collateral damage, and then use that collateral damage as evidence of genocide. The Gazan Palestinians would have been better served had they had a proper state instead of Hamas as their reps - but alas they voted them in and they never left.

In And Out Of Oslo

Once upon a time the Palestinians and the Israelis came to an agreement about a 'two state solution'. They went to Oslo and signed an accord on it. To get there, the Palestinians had to stop being terrorists and become more state-like. That was the long road for Yasser Arafat and the PLO who became the Palestinian Authority. They had to give up on being terrorists. The Israelis had to come to the table and agree that the Palestinians could not be all chased off and made into refugees. For those of us looking on, it was a watershed moment when we thought maybe the Arab-Israeli conflict could finally come to a close. 

Boy were we wrong. 

Less than six months after the signing of the DOP, an Israeli extremist killed 29 Palestinians in the Cave of the Patriarchs massacre.[5] In response Hamas conducted its first lethal suicide bombingkilling eight Israelis and injuring 34.[41][42] An additional five Israelis were killed and 30 injured as a Palestinian detonated himself on a bus in Hadera a week later.[43] Hamas claimed responsibility for both attacks.[43] The attacks may have been timed to disrupt negotiations between Israel and PLO on the implementation of the Oslo I Accord.[41] In 1994, Hamas killed around 55 Israelis and injured over 150 in an effort to derail the peace process, stating that these attacks were a part of jihad against Israel's occupation and in retaliation for the Cave of the Patriarchs Massacre.[6]

Following the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, the labor party's recently selected prime minister Shimon Peres' would give the green light for the assassination of Yahya Ayyash, which Avi Shlaim describes as "the greatest mistake of Peres's political career" due to the subsequent rise of suicide attacks. Shortly after this increase in violence and Israeli security concerns, polls would show Likud's Binyamin Netenyahu ahead of Peres for the first time since Rabin's murder. Shlaim describes the role played by the Israeli right during and after the Oslo years, highlighting prime minister Binyamin Netenyahu's "largely successful" attempts to undermine the accords after his election in 1996.[44]

Despite the Oslo Accords stipulating that "neither side shall initiate or take any step that will change the status of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip pending the outcome of the permanent status negotiations", Israeli settlement expansion continued during the Oslo period. The Jewish population in the West Bank and Gaza Strip (excluding East Jerusalem) grew from 115,700 to 203,000 between 1993 and 2000.[45]

Binyamin Netanyahu came to power in Israel with the intent of killing the Oslo Accords. Similarly, Hamas broke free from the old PLO, specifically to keep fighting and by definition, kill the Oslo Accords. All these years later, It's still Bibi for the Israelis and Hamas for the Gazans. The shit show we're seeing has been very well planned, rehearsed and orchestrated. Neither side wants a sensible peace if they can keep fighting their ideological war.

It's one of life's tragedy that they make you think so much about their problems that they opted to make more complex and more violent for their own purposes. I have to say, after the Oslo Accords fell apart, I stopped being invested. There is no process. There is no peace deal that will hold.  

"From The River To The Sea"

 It's no joke that the phrase refers to wiping out the Israelis and reclaiming land. It sounds so romantic like something from a David Lean movie but what the phrase means is pretty uncompromising. 

I've asked some Arabic women about all this, the conflict and prospect of peace and what I was told is that the way they learn it in their religion, when the fighting stops, it is the end of time. As long as the fight goes on, it means the Apocalypse is not yet here and the rest of the Arabs can live on knowing the end of the world is not here. If peace should ever break out, this would be a terrifying development because the end would be near. Even if the present day parties could or would agree to terms, from the Arab point of view it would be only a temporary respite before the fight continues once more. The whole point of it, is that there is no peace in their framework. Therefore, there is no peace process. 

From the Arab perspective, the Oslo Accords was only ever going to be a mere ceasefire that punctuates the eternal struggle. Whatever peace that can be arrived at after this ordeal, will also be temporary. 

There is no ever-lasting peace. The Arabs do not want it. The Israelis know this too about their Arab opponents. And so they will not stay their hand because there isn't a good enough reason to hold back if there isn't going to be a peace. What is killing 40,000 people, is the very notion of 'From The River To The Sea". 

Here's the thing - and it's probably very unpopular to say it but it goes like this: You can't go and kill 1200 people and then complain the other side killed 40,000 of your people in retaliation. There isn't a moral scale for this kind of thing. If you go and cut up somebody's mother or sister and the other person comes and shoots your daughter in the face with a .50 Desert Eagle, you can't really claim victimhood. It doesn't make any sense - no matter how much you hated the guy and he hates you. Once you start the violence, you better own up to what ever results from the violence unleashed. 

The Palestinian cause and the people who throw themselves behind them are shocked the world is rather tardy in helping them out. They underestimate just how fatigued the world is from the commitment to keep fighting. The rest of the world just wants real peace, people. 


2024/07/01

Star Wars Content And Its Discontents

Star Wars Ain't What It Used To Be

There's a bit of brouhaha going on about the new Star Wars TV series 'The Acolyte'. Like with 'The Marvels', I've avoided seeing it. It seems prudent to know when the content isn't targeted for you. Just as I don't go and seek out Country and Western Music or Lesbian Political Poetry, I have decided I won't be seeking out 'The Acolyte'. As such I have nothing to say about its quality, lacking or otherwise.  

I do want to pass some judgement overall on Disney+ and its effort to bring these products to screen. Star Wars products that have been devised since Bob Iger bought Lucasfilm from George Lucas, have been underwhelming, with only a few exceptions. The Skywalker saga sequels were resoundingly awful while 'Rogue One' did manage to tell story that appealed to the old Star Wars audience. 'Solo' was alright except grossly miscast. These were a very bad sign for the TV shows that came along. 

'The Mandalorian' started out okay but as the second season gave way to The Book of Boba Fett, it kind of drifted off into a weird diversion that went nowhere. 'The Bad Batch' has been passable but it's not something to write home about. 'Andor' season 1 was good, but that one will come to definite end at the end of its Season2. 'Ahsoka' had its most triumphant moment when the casting was announced and they got Rosario Dawson to play the titular character. The show didn't exactly live up to the hype. With 'The Acolyte', they appear to have hit a new low. 

Two questions arise out of all this: Why do they want to make stuff that alienates the original audience so much? And when will they run out of money to keep doing this, because they're not winning.  

Who Are These Customers?

It's crazy, when you think about it. The original Star Wars movie opened up an entire new generation of audiences to cinema. The modern blockbuster as they call it, was borne from that moment in history when the audience for movies exploded, thanks to that movie in 1977. Cinema worldwide has ridden that wave of Gen-X kids who flocked to see Star Wars, and kept watching movies well into their adult lives. That's pretty much it. The Millennials are not married to cinema the way Gen-X were married to cinema - they're married to the internet and streaming and the golden age of television, but not cinema the way Gen-X were. 

For the last few years, Hollywood Box Office receipts have dropped off significantly. There has not been  significant post-Covid recovery. here has been much discussion about why this might be, but what people are failing to notice is that at 50-something, Gen-X just doesn't get out to the cinema every week any more. So they blame streaming and people falling out of the habit of going to the cinema, but really, it's because the generation that gave Hollywood the Blockbuster for 40 years has passed on from being their regular customers.

But even that is by-the-by. The very real problem Disney+ has on it stands is that the people most positively disposed towards Star Wars - arguably the reason why you would want to buy Lucasfilm and bring it under the House of Mouse - are absolutely up in arms with the terrible product made by Disney+ creatives. This is the audience they bought when they slapped down all those billions for George Lucas. The trick is, you have to keep on making stuff for the same audience, but by the looks of things, there is no intention of doing so. 

Imagine you buy McDonalds worldwide. Do you keep running it as is, or do you change the menu so it's nothing but Vegan? If you do the latter, what do you think happens to your global customer base? 

Are Disney then really that surprised when 'The Acolyte' - with its episodes about Communist Lesbian Space Witches - gets some of the worst reviews? People are calling it the worst Star Wars TV show ever, including the Christmas Special. Now, I was around to see that Christmas Special when it first aired. If you have people thinking you have made something even worse than that, you might want to review your entire organisation.

Why Are The Audiences So Angry?

It's because it's the end of the road. The angry, are actually the old-farts who are forced to reckon with the fact that we are no longer young and times have passed them by. Maybe Gen Z is really as queers as they say, and this shift to addressing a 'woke' audience is what the marketing hacks ordered, but this bunch just don't like it. They don't like being called racists and homophobes by Disney's shills either. 

For a long time, movie marketing has been about the 18-24 demographic. Gen X hasn't been that demographic for a good 20 years now. Film and TV products - now referred to as 'content' - is decidedly aimed at people much younger than Gen X. The older generation is tacitly being told to go quietly into the night - the movie business is no longer interested in their custom. 

And perhaps maybe that is what is freaking out the Gen-X cohorts who pretty much supported Hollywood for 40 years. It's a two-way street. Gen Xers seem like they've stopped going to the cinemas except for absolutely-once-a-year marquee movies. I think we're seeing just how disinterested the current 18-24year old demographic is, when it comes to spending cash at the cinema. Box office receipts have been terrible. We'll see how long Hollywood holds out before it starts making movies for the people who want to go see movies. 

Grogu-X

Have You Looked at Baby Yoda Properly? He's 50 years old but still a baby and he throws his psychic weight about. Surely that's Disney's view of the Star Wars fanbase - a bunch of emotionally immature 50-year old man-children. 

Disney's Other Disasters

 It's not just Star Wars. Disney also screwed up the Indiana Jones franchise, and made a truly abominable TV series out of 'Willow'. The latter was so bad they've had to pull it from Disney+. Beyond the issues of mishandling Lucasfilm, they've also contributed to the carnage that has been Marvel Phase 4. None of the Marvel TV series they have produced have been anywhere near as good as the Marvel shows made with Netflix. None. And I've watched all of that stuff. 

At this point, I'm waiting to see 'Andor' season 2, and then I'm cancelling my Disney+ subscription. There's just no point in staying with them. The jig is up, It's over.  


2024/06/28

That Presidential Debate

How Bad Was That?

If you lean to the left like me and you're with the progressive, there's no way in hell Donald Trump is acceptable. It goes without saying, but I'm saying because let's face it: Joe Biden looked much worse than Trump - who was largely being himself - and revealed to the world how far gone he was. 

That wasn't just some sleepy forgetful guy there. That is the POTUS looking for a second term and maybe even some of his lost marbles. I kind of brushed aside some of the rumours about how bad his senility was, but there was just no denying it in that performance. Get this: Trump was awful, but we're not talking about that because we're so used to pointing out how awful Donald Trump is, every time he opens his mouth. No, we're taking about just how far gone Joe Biden is towards the happy place. Man, I was squirming listening to him mangle not just his answers but his legacy with it. It was so bad he's going to be remembered for it. 

Look, if you were applying the criterion that maybe Donald Trump isn't compos mentis, you have to apply the same scrutiny to Joe Biden and frankly, he looked further along the road to an unravelled mind than even the Donald. The early crit is that there would be panic in the senior democratic ranks. Jeez, you reckon? 

How Did We Get Here?

I've probably said this here some time ago but American politics has uniquely been unable to move on from the Baby Boomers. Australia quietly made the transition in the last decade. Anthony Albanese is probably the lat ALP leader who is a BabyBoomer, and he's a young one at that, being born in 1963. Malcolm Turnbull was the last Liberal Party leader and he was born in 1954. Scomo, is the first Gen-X PM of Australia and while he was terrifyingly terrible, he wasn't an old fart - just a stinky one. 

 If you look around the world, the leaders of the first world apart from Japan have moved on from Baby Boomer leadership. Boo was the last Boomer UK PM. Liz Truss was also a terrifyingly terrible Gen-Xer born in 1975; Rishi Sunak was born in 1980, so he's practically a Millennial. Macron was born in 1977. Olaf Scholz of Germany is a Boomer, but Giorgia Meloni, Justin Trudeau, Pedro Sanchez, and even our favourite Gen-Xer Volodymyr Zelenskyy, were all born in the 70s. 

Somehow, America has resisted moving on at every juncture in the last 25 years. They have gone from Bill Clinton being the first Boomer to be POTUS, followed by 2 terms each of Dubya and Obama, 1 term of Trump, and 1 term of Biden; all of them baby Boomers. Flanked by the likes of Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer, the Dems look pretty ossified. The Republican leadership in Congress and the Senate on the other hand have added some Gen-X voices voice, but they seem to be the voices of the deranged, like Marjorie Taylor-Greene and Matt Gaetz. Gaetz is in fact a millennial.   

I understand, age is just a number. Paul McCartney is 82 and still touring. When asked about retiring he     quipped "first you retire and then you expire. What am I going to do? sit on the couch and watch Netflix all day?" And he seems mostly fine, but he doesn't run the top job in the Free World. The point is, it's one thing to defy age and keep going - and the Boomer generation of US leadership has gone on for a very long time, but it also can't last forever. These guys are simply getting too old, but America's been in denial about it until this debate. Both sides need to play back the debate to the respective candidates and ask them if they think they really did alright. Maybe they will see the blindingly obvious and step down.   

Wanna Feel Old? 

A couple of days ago, Derek Jeter turned 50. Fifty!


2024/06/27

View From The Couch - 27/Jun/2024

Welcome Home Julian Assange

After 5 years of incarceration at HMP Bellmarsh, Julian Assange has struck a plea bargain deal with the Americans, this week. And just like that the long siege was over. The seemingly quiet denouement belied the all-of-government effort Australia put together to work towards the release of Assange. 

In the commentary and articles that have come out in the wake of the Saipan court appearance, this one caught my attention. a six MP delegation consisting of a wide spectrum of Australian politics went to lobby the US Department of Justice. One of them was none other than the Fossil Fool himself Barnaby Joyce.

The delegation raised several issues including freedom of speech, shifting public sentiment in Australia, the US-Australia alliance, and jurisdictional rights.

Senator Whish-Wilson says Mr Joyce played an important role.

"He said, 'I was the deputy PM, I've been the acting PM. I have been the deputy head of the National Security Committee for many years, and I don't agree with what Assange has done. But it was not illegal and this extra-territorial overreach [by the US] is a precedent that cannot stand.'"

Dr Ryan said that the US officials pushed back against their arguments, claiming Assange's freedom was purely a legal matter, not a political one.

It was then that Mr Joyce brought Johnny Depp's dogs into it, raising the infamous case in 2015 when the then-minister for agriculture threatened to euthanise the Hollywood star's pooches — Pistol and Boo — due to quarantine breaches.

Dr Ryan said Mr Joyce suggested to the meeting that political considerations inevitably played a role in these sorts of matters.

"Basically, he said there had been pressure placed on him at the time and if it had been left to him, Pistol, Boo, Johnny, and Amber would be behind bars in Australia."

That's pretty funny. I don't much like Barnaby Joyce but if his lousy-loutish-loony-bin argument of bringing up Johnnie Depp, Amber Heard, and their dogs made the point that all of this was a political consideration over a legal one, then I have too say he was a beautiful broken clock that happy day. He's done good, and Lord knows I never thought I'd write that about Barnaby Joyce. 

The other bit that was amusing was this observation:

Senator Whish-Wilson believed two main issues cut through during the meeting — public opinion in Australia and the impact on the US's reputation globally.

"I was watching when they were suddenly taking notes on a couple of occasions. Firstly, when we raised the issue that the political situation had shifted [in Australia]," he said.

"And also that the Chinese government had commented around [Australian journalist] Cheng Lei's imprisonment … that they were criticising the US saying, 'How can you point the finger at us when you are going after Assange?'"

Dr Ryan also made the point that at a time when Russia, China and other authoritarian nations were locking up journalists, it was not a good look for the US to continue its prosecution of Assange.

"I'd taken some Chinese newspapers with me. And I said, 'Look, here's evidence in the Chinese press where this case has been used as an example of the US not respecting freedom of the press,'" she said.

"In the Chinese media's perception, there was a degree of hypocrisy in the US accusing China of that sort of action. They were really surprised by that."

You can just picture the DOJ representatives squirming in their chairs. I guess the important thing was to remind the DOJ that at the end of the day they were running point for a political consideration that had run its course. The politics surrounding Julian Assange had simply changed vastly, as had Australian politics. 

"It would be fair to say within that hyper-partisan environment, they didn't know what to make of this group of assorted Australian politicians who on paper had so much that divided them, that were all pushing for this same outcome, and all prized Julian's freedom."

"Mate, it's just a point of fairness", I can hear somebody say. 

Why Blog About This Today?

Back in the glory days of Julian Assange telling truth to power by telling the world of their misdeeds and  before his situation blew up, he made the remark that blogs are useless. Bloggers, are mostly only talking to their friends. They make no impact on the world. And it always stuck with me because by then this blog here was a few years old. 

First of all, he's right. 

Secondly, he sure made an impact because what he did got the entire US government to come for his head. Yours truly over here's been noting stuff down that amuses him over the decades and here we are - no impact, no substance, no importance - but I don't regret this. 

Thirdly, I just wanted to write how, as useless as my blog has been, I'm still here and I have enjoyed my freedom for the last 12 years so go suck on that pal. But I'm delighted he's been released. That much is true. 

Where Have I Been For The Last 8 Months?

Hard to say. The usual rabbit holes of Youtube and all that it entails, I would say. Work has been exhausting too. New years came and went and all I did was make a 1/24 scale plastic model of a 1970 Pontiac Firebird. Easter was spent doing things I didn't expect to do and then recovering from it. I haven't managed to do a whole lot of recordings, but my band WhatEva did manage to play a bunch of gigs.  

As for the Youtube thing, what have I learned? Putin's Russia is deeply, deeply fucked up. If this war in Ukraine keeps going, Russia may even disintegrate - and then we'll really be in a world of pain.  





2023/10/15

Australia Says 'No'

Fear And Loathing In Maranoa

As the pollsters have been predicting for some weeks, the referendum failed to garner the 'yes' vote. 

I happened to catch a Youtube video of Sky News hosts gloating about it and I've wondered if they inhabit the same reality I do - everything they said in celebration of the outcome sounded like Australians came together to thwart a massive conspiracy the likes of which has never been seen. I mean, come on, how much more disinformation does Murdoch's people need to spew about, even after 'winning'. 

The ABC put together this analysis which is informative. 

The journey to the 2023 vote was set in motion in 2017 when Indigenous leaders and community members “from all points of the southern sky” met at Uluru and wrote an invitation to the Australian people to walk with them on a path toward “constitutional reforms to empower our people and take a rightful place in our own country”. 
That letter asked Australians to listen, and urged us all to support structural reforms to overcome the “torment of [First Nations] powerlessness”: 
“Proportionally, we are the most incarcerated people on the planet. We are not an innately criminal people. Our children are alienated from their families at unprecedented rates. This cannot be because we have no love for them. And our youth languish in detention in obscene numbers. They should be our hope for the future.”
Neither side of the Voice debate denied the need for Australia to create a better future for First Nations children.
 
But, by majority vote, Australians have made clear that a constitutionally enshrined Voice to Parliament is not how they want to respond to these crises. 
An urgent question emerges — what is?

So  the last rhetorical bit got me thinking about the whole exercise. 60% of the population voted no. It's nothing to be sneezed at. Within that context there's an electorate out there that voted 84% 'no'. I hope I never go there. 

Unlike the plebiscite for same sex marriage a few years ago, the outcome of this referendum was more in line with the 1999 referendum for the Republic. As was then, the great unwashed decided the Monarchy was fine enough thank you very much in the same way they decided the very idea of Indigenous people having a say in the laws put forward about them was not acceptable. This country has not come very far since then, and dare I say it was miraculous that the '67 referendum to recognise the Indigenous people as citizens got up. 

A Question of Civility

There's a Japanese politician Taro Aso, who got into trouble for saying something undiplomatic during the pandemic. He was asked about how well the Japanese people responded to government directives to wear masks and exercise social distancing compared to other countries. To what, he asked, would he attribute this difference? Aso replied the level of civility is fundamentally different between those countries and Japan. 

He was asked for an observation and then was pilloried for his off-the-cuff opinion. I get it - it sounds like he's saying other countries and populations that don't behave like the Japanese are somehow inferior. What he may have meant was the Japanese were superior, which is not better, but a different proposition. It's not that they/you suck, but we just do things better, is different to "you all suck". 

But when I look around me, what I feel is that the gulf lying between the 'Yes' and 'No' voters is exactly that characterisation: There's an absence of civility in wanting to vote 'no'. Are they inferior human beings? No, but their civility is pretty low if they want to vote to keep the status quo in Australia where the indigenous population is impoverished, incarcerated, disadvantaged and alienated at every turn. I'm not the one that's being churlish in suggesting that it's an utter lack of civility that made them vote 'no'. 

I'm Used To This Feeling

The Republic Referendum of 1999 felt pretty much like this, but that one happened way before Blogs, let alone Social Media so I suffered that in my own headspace more than anywhere else. In retrospect, I think I took that defeat on the chin too, although in the years since, I've sort of backed off the Republican position. Maybe it's that old age brings a certain kind of cynicism about other human beings, that in turn makes you fearful for their lack of civility. In which case a Republic would open doors to any number of executive hour stories, as many republics around the world have found out, including the United Staes of America on the 6th of January 2021. 

That leads me to suspect we with the higher sense of civility should perhaps stay our hand at casting condemnations at the low civility 60% of this sorry nation. After all, there was once an organ called ATSIC and it was abolished because of the corruption allegations it managed to accrue in its time. That experience alone should temper the notion of any political organ that purports to represent the indigenous voice - and in turn, maybe there is a kind of wisdom in the base (and I mean, bottom feeding base) conservative impulse to just saying no to enshrining body that could go the way of ATSIC. 

After all, it was never answered who was going to sit on that advisory body and how they would come to be. Maybe that was a discussion for another day once there was a referendum consensus that we would have such an organ but... it does the beg the question. If roughly the same consensus that didn't want a Republic also don't want a rewrite of the constitution, with some humility, we with the high sense of civility should take that on board more seriously. Is it really intellectual arrogance for the inner city types to want to change the constitution? No. Just the hope that we thought we were better than this. 

So there you have it. Our nation is split into haves and have-nots. It's not about having money or property - it's about having a conscience. 

2023/10/11

Referendum Coming Up

The Voice, The Voice

The referendum for The Voice is coming up on Saturday. No surprises, I'm voting 'Yes', so let's just get that out of the way. The choice is pretty stark. There's really no confusion except those points-of-confusion spread about by 'No' vote campaigners. If you want to side with people who think outcomes for indigenous Australians are going swimmingly well, you vote 'no'. If you want to side with the people who don't think things are working that great when it comes to outcomes for Indigenous people, then you vote 'yes'. The fact that you might be lining up with the woke, the sanctimonious, the inner-city-latte-sipping urban elites, and the LGBTQ+ alphabet soup people is actually by-the-by. In turn, if you want to be on the side of conservatives, red necks, racists, conspiracy nut jobs, and other assorted bloody-minded personality-disordered types, you vote 'no' and wear the opprobrium. Society is binary (gender, is less so) in 2023.  

There was that scintillating observation made by an indigenous MP that things were working out great for indigenous people because European colonisation brought running water, got ridiculed a lot. She's only right if you ignore all the suffering otherwise - and we are trying to address the suffering. The "what have the Romans ever done for us?" gag from 'The Life of Brian' is now coming up to almost 50 years old. You would think that our political classes would have digested it a bit better by now, but clearly they have not. Nobody siding with a parochial 'cultural' mindset (as per David Graeber) is not going to accept the merits of civilisation. It's interesting that the best argument in favour of continuing the status quo is history as seen through the prism of civilisation and technology. 

Conversely, it is equally notable that the there are a number of indigenous groups saying they want to vote 'no'  because they didn't get a say, or it doesn't get enough of a bite out of what mainstream Australia possesses. Some even argue if it's not the treaty, they don't want to know about it. Others have said they weren't consulted, while yet others more have said they don't get how it's going to make their lives better immediately - so 'no' thank you. The defiant poses struck by these indigenous leaders arguing for a 'no' vote is also reminiscent of the argument made by David Graeber that the heart of culture is defiance. That in the face of encroaching civilisation, some would defiantly say no to it, is deeply cultural. 

All this has me thinking that this referendum is largely symbolic for a reason. The Prime Minister Anthony Albanese wants us to waste our energy on something trivial, patronising, and somewhat idiotic for the sole reason of distraction. He would like us to expend tremendous amounts of energy arguing the pros and cons of something that is largely without economic or climactic impact. The nation has spent a good deal of time talking about this, while exercising very little scrutiny of just what this government is doing about housing, energy policy, climate change (read "GLOBAL WARMING") and healthcare after the pandemic. He has basically given us this idiotic shibboleth with which to beat over our own heads. It is government by the patronising, for the patronising of the patronised. 

In other words, we are the idiot marks for putting up with this so-called debate.  

Blog Archive